Thursday, December 08, 2016
A series of wrongs finally makes for one right
California did it again. With a mandatory Jackpot 6 payoff on closing day at Del Mar, there was no announcement that there would be no consolation payoff for five winners, as there had been every other day at the meeting. Bettors didn't find out until after the prices had been posted. The uproar was immediate and sustained, as it should have been, so much so that Del Mar relented and announced that those with five winners would be paid. It was the right thing to do but it could turn out badly. A precedent has been established that the "official" sign is not the final word on payoffs.
MIAMIâCalifornia, which has done everything wrong, has finally been moved to do the right thing. Ultimately this might turn into another mistake.
Del Mar management, the California Horse Racing Board and the stewards each completed egregious faux pas in such a relatively short period they couldnât have screwed up more if they were trying.
Recognizing the latest mistake could have been the outrage that set off a revolution, Del Mar did something tracks rarely, if ever, do. Without being obligated by law, but spurred by business sense, it went into its own pocket to pay off an extra set of winners.
Last Sunday was closing day at Del Mar. The trackâs jackpot Pick 6 had the customary mandatory payout. When the official was posted on the final race, the price for 6 winners was posted--$15,660.
No consolation payoff for 5-of-6 was posted, to the surprise and consternation of those with such tickets. No reason they shouldnât have been surprised. When the bet was hit earlier in the meeting with a single jackpot winner or with multiple winners, there were consolation payoffs. Most significantly, there was no announcement there would be no consolation payoffs.
Del Mar fell back on a rule created by the Association of Racing Commissioners International, which dictates no consolations on mandatory payout days. Who knew? Apparently not anyone in the upper echelon of Del Mar, which explains why there was no announcement to bettors.
The ARCI rule was utilized because California allowed the bet to be introduced without creating a rule of its own. Think about that. A new bet, which everyone recognized could zoom into the millions--in fact, that was its purpose--was instituted without rules about payoffs.
After three days of standing its ground in spite of an uproar from coast to coast, Del Mar announced it will pay those who had 5-of-6 the $81 they felt entitled to on Sunday.
This could come back to bite Del Mar and other tracks in the behind since a precedent has been established.
Throughout history, the official result has always been the last word for pari-mutuel payoffs. Now when results are overturned because of a successful appeal or a drug positive, bettors could go to court and say, âThey paid off on the Jackpot 6 well after the fact. Since the result has been altered for every other purposeâpurses, horsesâ records, etc.âwhy shouldnât I be paid, too.â
With so many wagers being made by computer, the mechanisms are in place. This wasn't the case when paper tickets provided the only proof of having the winner.
These tactics might not ever be successful but they have the potential to generate a lot of legal headaches.
Gambling's not shameful
Horse racing is a sport. So is curling. Without gambling, horse racing is curling.
The kickoff panel at the annual Symposium on Racing and Gambling in Arizona discussed whether racing should be marketed as a sport or as a gambling vehicle. This was as much a waste of time as debating whether Certs is a candy mint or a breath mint.
Racing is a sport on a balmy winter afternoon at Gulfstream, a spring day at Keeneland, a summer getaway at Saratoga or Del Mar. But absent gambling, the Little League World Series would draw bigger crowds. Anyone who thinks otherwise is delusional.
In the dead of winter at Aqueduct or on a snowy night at Penn National, racing is slot machines with flesh and blood. Trying to present it otherwise is not only futile it diminishes the credibility of those trying to do so.
Whether at the Spa in August or Aqueduct in February, the unifying thread is racing is a rare form of entertainment with gambling in which an intellectual challenge and strategy offers the individual some control over his fate. Yet it can be equally enjoyed by newcomers seeking only an exciting diversion.
Poker and fantasy sports might be the only other forms of entertainment in this category. Not coincidentally both are soaring in popularity and attracting the demographics--young people--racing desperately needs to cultivate to secure its future.
For some unfathomable reason, racing refuses to market itself in this manner. T-shirt and hat giveaways, dollar beer and hot dog days are useful promotional tools but the core product, gambling, has to be the lure.
âOur races are like a fantasy game every few minutes. You can bet as little as 50 cents or a dollar, win hundreds, maybe thousands, and the payoffs are immediateâ should be a universal marketing campaign.
Once you can get new fans in the door, they might discover the aesthetic beauty of the game and learn the names of the outstanding competitors, which might contribute to bringing them back.
The panel in Arizona had âracingâs identity crisisâ as its theme. Racing doesnât have an identity crisis. It has a self esteem crisis. Itâs ashamed to admit what it is, a gambling sport.
With so many casinos popping up all over the map that they are cannibalizing each other (see Atlantic City), lottery tickets available at the checkout counter in supermarkets, poker all over cable TV and legalized sports gambling coming soon, there is no reason for racing to apologize or back away from what it is. The sooner it accepts this, the better.
Wood, Blue Grass downgrades a start
The Wood Memorial has the Blue Grass Stakes to thank for being downgraded from a Grade 1 to a Grade 2.
The Blue Grass Stakes has the Wood Memorial to thank for being downgraded from a Grade 1 to a Grade 2.
The Graded Stakes Committee could not have downgraded one of the tradition rich stakes at racingâs most prestigious venues without the other screaming murder so loud the O.J. jury would have heard it. By knocking down two, the Committee was able to fall back on results, which should be the only criteria.
The most recent winner of the Wood Memorial to double in the Kentucky Derby was Fusaichi Pegasus in 2000. The last horse to run in the Wood then win the Derby was Funny Cide in 2003.
Outwork , the 2016 winner, ran 14th in the Kentucky Derby then was retired. The field he beat included Trojan Nation, a maiden when he ran second, Adventist, Matt King Coal, Shagaf, Tale of Svall, Flexibility and Dalmore.
Frosted, the 2015 Wood champion, gives the race some cachet but his big triumphs didnât come until he was 4. The Wood field that year was only marginally superior to 2016: Tencendur, El Kabeir, Daredevil, Tiz Shea D, Toasting Master and Lieutenant Colonel.
If the Wood wasnât NYRAâs prestige Derby prep, it would have been downgraded long ago. The same goes for Keenelandâs Blue Grass. Strike the Gold in 1991 was the last winner to encore in Louisville. Street Sense, almost 10 years ago, is the last Blue Grass participant to wear the roses on the first Saturday in May.
Brodyâs Cause, last springâs winner, ran seventh in the Derby and sixth in the Belmont before being retired.
To belabor a point I love to make, the glory days of the Blue Grass were when it was 10 days out from the Derby. The Wood was at its peak when it was run two weeks in advance of the Derby. Then again, today's trainers are so much smarter than Ben Jones, Sunny Jim Fitzsimmons and Charlie Whittingham, who didn't have the advantage of getting advice from guys producing sheets in an office miles from the track.
Part of the Blue Grassâ downfall is self-inflicted, a victim of Keeneland having a synthetic track from 2006-14. Many top contenders shied away from using the kitty litter surface for their horseâs final Derby prep.
A bigger problem than the downgrading of a couple of races with such rich histories is the false equivalency it creates. The Wood Memorial and Blue Grass are now the same grade as the Nashua, which had a four-horse field. Three had one win apiece. The other was a maiden, who won the race. There are numerous other examples of over-rated Grade 2âs.
The entire process needs to be revised. There should not be a Grade 1 race for juveniles other than the two Breedersâ Cup events. The vast majority of these stakes are no more than entrance level allowances.
Any juvenile race in which the majority of starters have only a maiden win should not be eligible for grading at any level.
Similarly, stakes for any age with five or fewer starters should be reduced by at least one grade unless at least two of the starters have wins at that grade or higher.
The Florida Derby, Santa Anita Derby and Arkansas Derby, the remaining Grade 1 spring races for 3-year-olds, are admittedly preps for the Triple Crown and the top prospects strive to avoid each other. Ergo, none should be higher than Grade 2. Preps for these racesâthe Fountain of Youth, Rebel, etc.--should not be higher than Grade 3.
The Derby, Preakness, Belmont, Haskell, Travers and now the Pennsylvania Derby, which earned its upgrade, should be the only Grade 1âs restricted to 3-year-olds. A coveted sprint, such as the Kings Bishop and maybe one or two others, is an exception worth discussion.
Until changes along these lines are made, the grading system will be nothing more than a promotional tool for breeders so misleading that it would not be tolerated in other forms of business.
Written by Tom Jicha
Thursday, December 01, 2016
It’s prime time at Gulfstream and more of same at Del Mar
Gulfstream's prime season, home of the finest winter racing in the nation, opens Saturday with a new focus, the $12 million Pegasus on Jan. 28. But the makeup of the field is still in doubt with everyone crossing their fingers for a California Chrome-Arrogate rematch. On the other coast, California stewards again demonstrated they have no regard for the betting public by failing to do what they should have when debris interfered with 10 of 13 horses in the Jimmy Durante.
MIAMI, Dec. 1, 2016--How appropriate that the giveaway Saturday at Gulfstream Park
is a 2017 calendar. There might be four weeks left in the current year for society at large but opening day of the prime winter meeting signals that as far as Florida racing goes--racing on the East Coast for that matter--itâs time to turn the page on 2016 and look ahead to the new year.
The Claiming Crown has become cemented as the opening day fixture. Light on star power, itâs arguably the best betting day of the yearâfull, competitive fields shipping in from hither and yon.
Once the Day One festivities are out of the way, the coming season will be unlike those that have preceded it in a significant way. For the first time, the focus of the meeting will not be on the Florida Derby on April 1 but the ground-breaking Pegasus, with its uniquely funded $12 million purse, on Jan. 28.
There are still naysayers, who believe it wonât happen, not without justification. Eight weeks out, there are only a couple or three committed starters. Iâve also had my doubts but I think itâs too far down the road to call it off. The embarrassment would be suffocating.
The saving grace is one of those definitely pointing for what will be the worldâs richest race is California Chrome, the worldâs richest thoroughbred. As long as he makes the race, it will be a definite go even if it means hustling the backstretch for a few sacrificial lambs. If California Chrome and his Breedersâ Cup conqueror Arrogate both start, it wonât matter who else shows up.
However, Arrogateâs oil rich connections are not among the 12 subscribers, who put up a million apiece to buy a guaranteed slot in the gate. No one doubts that if they want to come to Gulfstream, a way will be found.
Frank Stronach owns a starting berth, presumably ticketed for his Woodward winning Shaman Ghost. Stronach has so much of his personal prestige on the line, it would be more important to arrange a California Chrome-Arrogate rematch than to take a shot with his colt.
It will be unfair to judge the Pegasus as less than a success if fewer than 12 start. The Donn Handicap, the Grade 1 it replaces, drew only eight last winter. Santa Anitaâs Big Cap, the winterâs other premier race for older horses, attracted nine. The Breedersâ Cup Classic also had only nine starters as did the Pacific Classic. Saratogaâs Whitney had only six. Only five loaded into the gate for the Jockey Club Gold Cup.
Quality outranks quantity. The Pegasus will be a better race with fewer than a dozen starters. Itâs hard to conjure more than half that number that have even a puncherâs chance against the Big Two.
It would be a shame if some no-shot horse, in for the guaranteed $200,000 consolation prize, does something goofy to compromise or eliminate one of the favorites. Bayern doesnât fall into the filler category but it should not be forgotten what he did to California Chrome and Shared Belief in the 2014 Breedersâ Cup Classic.
An interesting sidelight is either California Chrome or Arrogate will be named 2016 Horse of the Year when the Eclipse ballots are tabulated. Gulfstream bills its winter session âthe championship meetingâ but the winner will be the first reigning HoY to compete at Gulfstream since St. Liam in the 2007 Donn Handicap.
Coincidentally, another Horse of the Year also ran and won the same afternoon at Gulfstream. Curlin, who would go on become HoY in 2007 and 2008, broke his maiden on the undercard. It would be the only time he competed at Gulfstream.
Another SoCal abomination
The latest abomination in California racing, not ruling last Saturdayâs Jimmy Durante a no-contest after debris in the first turn scattered and/or spooked most of the field, isnât infuriating because it happened. Heinous decisions by Southern California stewards have come to be expected.
Itâs the pervasive attitude of the people in charge of the game that the bettors, without whom there is no racing, arenât a low priority, they are a no priority. Among other things, this âif you donât like it, too badâ thinking is how fans are raped for inexcusably exorbitant takeouts to service the bottom lines of the tracks and the owners.
To get back to the Jimmy Durante, Saturday was an atypical blustery, rainy day at Del Mar. At some point just prior to the stakes or after the field was sprung in the two-turn event, several good-sized protective pads that cover drains came loose and blew onto the course. They went unnoticed until the field raced toward them in the first turn.
This had the same chaotic effect on the riders that suddenly seeing something in the roadway does on drivers. Some scattered, some figuratively hit the brakes.
Drayden Van Dyke, who rode the eventual winner, Journey Home, was quoted as saying, âThis was the craziest race Iâve ever been in.â Hall of Famer Mike Smith, said, âIt was pretty scaryâŚMy horse jumped one. I know other horses altered course.â
The Racing Form chart gave first turn trouble calls to 10 of the 13 horses.
Clearly, California Horse Racing Board Rule 1514 should have come into play. âThe stewards may declare a race âno contestâ if mechanical failure or interference during the running of the race affects the majority of the horses.â Ten of 13 constitutes a majority the way I was taught math.
The stewards opted to do nothing because they didnât think it was appropriate to make it a no contest, according to Scott Chaney, âHad the race been declared a no contest, all wagers would have been refunded and no purse money would have been paid.â
In other words, the people who nominally (laughably) are supposed to protect the public were intent on protecting the trackâs cut of the pool and the ownersâ slices of the purse but had no regard for the bettors.
Business as usual at SoCal tracks.
Written by Tom Jicha
Thursday, November 24, 2016
Give thanks for a great weekend of racing
The Eclipse championships were mostly settled at the Breeders' Cup but this weekend still offers a cornucopia of quality racing. Aqueduct and Churchill Downs have stakes laden agendas as they wind down their 2016 seasons and Gulfstream West wraps up business, hopefully for the final time, with a pair of added-money events. I see at least four opportunities to make a score without resorting to the chalk. On the not-so-positive side, the first Kentucky Derby futures bet, the worst wager in racing, launches in advance of the 2017 Run for the Roses.
MIAMI, Nov. 24--Thanksgiving has settled into its role as the anti-climactic weekend of the racing season. Most of the championships have been decidedâthis year more than ever. However, plenty of quality races are still out there as New York and Kentucky fire their last big shots of 2016 and Florida sets the table for the championship season at Gulfstream, which opens with the Claiming Crown a week from Saturday.
The absence of the big stars diminishes the likelihood of tough-to-beat odds-on favorites, so betting opportunities abound. Iâm going to take a swing at four of these stakes, two at Churchill on Friday and a couple more Saturday at Gulfstream West (Calder). I donât think any of my selections will go to the post as chalk.
Hoppertunity and Effinex, coming out of fourth and seventh-place finishes in the Breedersâ Cup Classic, respectively, will probably vie for favoritism in the Grade 1 Clark, but the horse to beat in my opinion is Noble Bird. The Mark Casse trainee has demonstrated hints of brilliance throughout his career; he appears at the top of his game, coming off back-to-back stakes wins for the first time; and he has shown an affinity for Churchill Downs. He won his only Grade 1 in the 2015 Stephen Foster (Hoppertunity was third) and prior to taking Keenelandâs Fayette last month, he captured the Lukas Classic under the twin spires. He also ran second in the Alysheba on Derby Day 2015.
Iâm looking for a slight reversal in Fridayâs co-feature, the grassy Mrs. Revere. Harmonize and Hawksmoor ran 2-3, in that order, behind Time and Motion, the best 3-year-old turf filly in America, in the QE II at Keeneland. Hawksmoor did the dirty work, pressing Catch a Glimpse then taking the lead in the stretch before Time and Motion and Harmonize ran her down late.
That was the U.S. debut for Hawksmoor, a Grade 2 winner in Europe. She goes out for the first time Friday for Arnaud Delacour, the latest super trainer to emerge from the Mid-Atlantic region.
A trainer angle also figures into Saturdayâs Tropical Turf Handicap.
Christopher Clement has a pair, who will be well supported, injury plagued War Correspondent and gallant old New Yorker Lubash, who won this race in 2014 but will turn 10 in little more than a month.
Clement is masterful at bringing back horses from a layoff but War Correspondent has been a money-burner on the occasions when Clement has been able to get him to the races, which has happened only four times in 2015 and 2016. When last seen, he finished eighth as the favorite in the Tampa Bay Stakes in February.
Iâm going with Rose Brier, a winner of four of six in 2016, most recently a restricted stakes at Laurel in late September. The tipping point for me is heâs conditioned by Jane Cibelli, who can really light them up in Florida. Whatâs more, Rose Brierâs regular rider, Trevor McCarthy, who rode five winners at Parx on Tuesday, all of whom paid at least $9, is coming south for the ride. Cibelli must have convinced him Rose Brier is live.
Strike Charmer, who ended Lady Eliâs unbeaten streak in the Ballston Spa at Saratoga, will probably be solid chalk in the co-featured My Charmer but Isabella Sings is ripe to spring an upset. Last winter, Isabella Sings almost stole the Hillsborough Stakes from Tepin before getting run down late. Todd Pletcher, who has had a hot hand at the Gulfstream West session, sent her to Florida early with this race in mind and she wonât have to hold off Tepin if she can get loose on the lead.
The best thing about the My Charmer and Tropical Turf is they are the last stakes of the Gulfstream West season and hopefully the last stakes ever run at the former Calder Race Course, which is now a vacant lot with a track. The feeling is something will be done legislatively within the next year so that racing never has to return to such a disgraceful setting. This would be something for which every racing fan could be thankful.
Worst bet in racing
The Kentucky Derby futures wager is the worst bet in racing, maybe all of sports. It was bad when it started early in the New Year. It got even worse when the first edition was advanced to November. Clearly this is a bid by avaricious Churchill Downs to siphon money from the vulnerable while memories of the Breedersâ Cup Juvenile are still fresh.
If a Derby futures bet almost a half-year out is to have any sporting or entertainment value, players should be paid if their selection makes it to the starting gate on the first Saturday in May. It still would be a challenge.
Maybe it was a reminder from the racing gods to reinforce the folly of the bet when 48 hours before it opened on Thursday, prophetically named Not This Time, one of the horses who figured to take a lot of action, was retired with a soft tissue injury.
As much a godsend as the scratch was for those ready to send it in on the fast closing Breedersâ Cup Juvenile runner-up, it has to be heart-breaking for Dale Romans, who said last summer that Not This Time had the potential to be the best horse he has ever trained.
Noticeably absent from the remaining 22 individual interests, headed by Breedersâ Cup champion Classic Empire and the ubiquitous field, is South Florida summer sensation Three Rules.The winner of his first five starts fizzled at the Breedersâ Cup but he beat as many as beat him after being wide all the way. He also had a grueling van and plane trip from South Florida to California, which had to sap him somewhat.
Moreover, Gormley and Klimt, who finished behind him in the Juvenile, are included in the first Derby future field, which includes 10 other horses who have won only once.
Three Rules might not win the Derbyâemphasis on might not
âbut barring injury heâll have a better 3-year-old season than more than half those in the future field. Donât let the Breedersâ Cup fool you. This colt can run.
Written by Tom Jicha