Tuesday, October 07, 2014
Wise Dan’s People Should Opt for Discretion Over Valor
Horse of the Year has essentially come down to Wise Dan vs. Shared Belief. Dan's usual array of detractors say he should go in the Breeders' Cup Classic against Shared Belief, et al, to settle the issue. But no one is asking Shared Belief to tackle Wise Dan on turf to prove himself worthy. It looks like Wise Dan's people will stick to their guns and keep their two-time Horse of the Year on turf in the Mile. It's the right call.
MIAMI, Oct. 7, 2014--Wise Danâs heart of a champion win in Saturdayâs Shadwell Turf Mile and Close Hatchesâ disappointment in the Spinster has essentially brought the Horse of the Year contest down to Shared Belief and Wise Dan. (California Chrome could grab the gold with a Classic win but his clunker in the Pennsylvania Derby, his only race in four months, doesnât encourage the thought this will happen.)
Nevertheless there is a strange dynamic coming into play. Wise Danâs detractors--the same ones who have been diminishing his achievements for three years--want him to go in the Classic on dirt to earn the championship. Yet no one is suggesting Shared Belief needs to win a turf race to earn the title.
Wise Danâs trainer Charlie Lopresti opened the door a crack after the Shadwell, saying if he and owner Morton Fink were ever to try the 7-year-old gelding in the mile-and-a-quarter Classic, this would be the year. Fink is not enamored with this move but he is not known as a meddling owner who often overrules his trainer. However, in this case, I would side with Fink.
That Lopresti would even consider a Classic run this year has to be partially an acknowledgement that age inevitably will take its toll on Wise Dan and that he would be the ranking older horse in this yearâs Classic against 3-year-olds Shared Belief, California Chrome, Tonalist and perhaps Bayern. That Lopresti would like to shut up those who have been knocking his horse might figure in a little bit, too.
Itâs not as if Wise Dan doesnât have credentials on dirt. He won the 2011 Clark Handicap and was second in the 2012 Stephen Foster, both Grade 1 races.
It was also a tacit admission that Wise Danâs chances for a third straight Horse of the Year are dependent on the outcome of the Classic. Wise Dan could cap an undefeated season with a triumph in the Breedersâ Cup Turf Mile but if Shared Belief wins the Classic, heâs Horse of the Year. Case closed.
This probably also would apply to California Chrome. The Classic would be the Kentucky Derby-Preakness winnerâs fourth Grade 1 win, including three of the four most important races in America.
On the other hand, if someone other than Shared Belief or California Chrome wins the Classic and Wise Dan again scores in the Mile, Dan would be in line for a Triple Triple--Horse of the Year, Older Horse and Turf Horse for the third straight year.
The two-time reigning Horse of the Year taking on the 3-year-old hot shots would be great for racing and NBCâs ratings. But if I were Fink and Lopresti, I would take a discretion over valor approach and Wise Dan would stick to doing what he does best.
Only Goldikova has been able to win the BC Turf Mile three times. Wise Dan could equal that this year and, the way heâs going, itâs not inconceivable he could go for four next year. Thereâs a Horse of the Year every season but that would be a singular feat that might never be matched.
What took so long?
The posse finally has caught up to Doug OâNeill. A 45-day suspension issued by the New York Gambling Commission has set off a dominos effect that could banish OâNeill for a long time.
The NYGC suspension is for a major drug positive in an OâNeill horse who won at Belmont on June 2, 2013. Itâs a travesty that it took more than a year for justice to be served. Worse, OâNeill was allowed to negotiate a deal in which he would serve the days starting Nov. 3, the day after Breedersâ Cup weekend. In other words, the slowest period on the racing calendar. Thatâs not punishment. Itâs a vacation.
That any commission would allow this, especially after OâNeill dragged out his appeals for more than a year, is incomprehensible and unacceptable.
The Breedersâ Cup got wind of the deal and said no way. It has a âconvicted trainers rule,â which stipulates that any trainer with a major drug conviction within the past year cannot enter his horses in a BC race.
Now OâNeill is facing tough sanctions in his home state of California. The guy with the nickname âDrug OâNeillâ for his many violationsâthe New York violation is his 19th, according to the Racing Form--got a 180-day suspension in California in 2012 for a 2010 offense (another justice delayed is justice denied joke) but 135 days were waived if OâNeill had no further offenses for 18 months. The New York finding fits within that period.
California has not announced if it will enforce that stipulation, which should have been done the same day New York issued its ruling. More justice delayed.
But then, thatâs California. Trainer A.C. Avila has yet to face the music for the Masochistic shenanigans last March in which the horse was found to have 40 times the recommended dose of a tranquilizer in his system and the stewards all but said Masochistic was stiffed by his rider when he finished off the board against Cal-breds. Next out, he beat open maidens by 14 on Derby Day at Churchill Downs, a betting coup for the ages.
The Jockey Club can wring its hands until they are raw about drugs fouling the sport but as long as trainers know they can drag out appeals, negotiate penalties downward and serve suspensions at their convenience, nothing is going to change.
Written by Tom Jicha
Tuesday, September 30, 2014
Espinoza got off easy with only seven days
Santa Anita stewards wasted no time in slapping Victor Espinoza with a seven-day suspension for his ride on Sky Kingdom in the Awesome Again in which the regular rider of California Chrome's sole purpose seemed to be to get Shared Belief beaten. Espinoza's defenders say he was only race riding but the fact that he has chosen not to appeal is revealing.
MIAMI, Sept. 30, 2014--Justice was swift but not as severe as it might have been for Victor Espinozaâs ride in the Awesome Again. Within 24 hours, the Santa Anita stewards came down on Espinoza with a seven-day suspension. Considering the magnitude of the event, I would have made it more.
Iâm flabbergasted reading comments on Horse Race Insider and other sites that there are those who think Espinoza did nothing wrong. The fact that Espinoza has chosen not to appeal says all you need to know.
The defense goes he was only race riding. My response is where does race riding end and irresponsibility and tampering with a race begin? Espinoza allowed Sky Kingdom to drift more than halfway out on the track in the first turn, then stayed out there down the backstretch. Would it have been race riding if he took Shared Belief to the outside fence?
Mike Smith, Shared Beliefâs Hall of Fame jockey, who knows the difference between race riding and something more sinister, was so ticked at Espinoza that he was quoted as saying in the jockeysâ room as Espinoza walked by, âKeep going or Iâll take your head off.â
In my opinion, Espinoza made no attempt to help Sky Kingdom win. Indeed he finished last. Espinoza was all in toward one purpose, to get Shared Belief beaten. His possible motivations made his actions more deplorable. Foremost, Espinoza is the regular rider of California Chrome, whose lock on the 3-year-old championship has been unhinged by Shared Belief.
The power of wins in the Kentucky Derby and Preakness in addition to the Santa Anita Derby is such--as they should be--that the only way Shared Belief could overcome them was by running the table of the Awesome Again and Breedersâ Cup Classic to go with the Pacific Classic and Los Alamitos Derby.
If not for the brilliance and tenacity of Shared Belief, Espinozaâs ride could have clinched the title for California Chrome. I believe that even if Shared Belief finishes ahead of California Chrome in the Classic but doesnât win the race, the 3-year-old Eclipse will go to California Chrome.
Jockey Club Gold Cup winner Tonalist could put in a claim with a win in the Classic but even under those circumstances I still feel that the streak of the last 16 Kentucky Derby-Preakness winners also wearing the divisional crown will remain intact.
Apparently Bob Baffert still harbors aspirations that Bayern could cop the Eclipse. There is no other rationale for pointing the speedster with distance limitations to a mile and a quarter in the Classic. He would have only one serious threat in the Dirt Mile, Goldencents, who might go in the Sprint.
Kelso winner Vyjack is staying in the East to await the Cigar Mile. Itsmyluckyday also will skip the Mile after his disappointing Kelso and prepare for either the Cigar or a winter campaign at Gulfstream.
Espinoza was riding for Baffert in the Awesome Again. A defeat by Shared Belief would have advanced Bayernâs standing, too.
On reflection, of all the suggested motivations for Espinozaâs ride, the one I put the least stock in is he was trying to help Baffertâs uncoupled stable mate Fed Biz. Espinoza gets up on a fair number of Baffert horses but heâs not the barnâs go-to guy. I donât think Espinoza cared who won as long as Shared Belief didnât.
Shared Belief, a gelding owned by sports talk star Jim Rome, could give racing such a boost for years to come itâs disheartening to think that anyone would go to the lengths Espinoza did to dim the luster of his star power.
Going all out to beat him on the square is one thing. Thatâs what jockeys are supposed to do. What Espinoza did is something else. He deserves the sanctions and scorn he is getting.
Racing as it was meant to be returns
After last weekendâs orgy of world class stakes action at Belmont and Santa Anita itâs hard to believe there are still championship caliber horses who havenât had their final Breedersâ Cup preps. But Keeneland has five more Grade 1âs among nine graded stakes on opening weekend starting Friday.
Better yet, much better yet, real dirt is back after seven years in the synthetic wilderness. I have often pointed out how winners of major Keeneland stakes on kitty litter were non factors in races on mainstream dirt courses. This should no longer be the case.
If Beholderâs bid for a third straight Eclipse is to be thwarted, it likely will be by Close Hatches, the probable favorite in Sundayâs Grade 1 Spinster. Not to be overlooked is Donât Tell Sophia, who is three-for-four in 2014, including Churchillâs recent Locust Grove. Her lone loss was a third behind Close Hatches in the Azeri but Donât Tell Sophia was hindered by a quarter crack, which forced her to run with a bar shoe. That problem is history.
Juveniles also have their final Breedersâ Cup preps at Keeneland and Belmont. The opening day feature in Kentucky will bring out what is expected to be a full field of fillies in the Alcibiades. Colts will get their chance Saturday in the Breedersâ Futurity.
Back at Belmont, the Grade 1 open Champagne and Frizette for fillies are set for Saturday with 2-year-old sprinters of both genders getting their chances on Sunday in the Futurity and Matron.
American Pharohâs dominant win in Santa Anitaâs Frontrunner makes him the one to beat in the BC Juvenile but the filly division is still looking for a leader. Angela Reneeâs win in the Chandelier was workmanlike but she was well beaten by Easterners in a couple of Saratoga stakes.
Keenelandâs five Saturday stakes also include the return of Wise Dan in the Shadwell Turf Mile. Dan suffered his only defeat of 2013 in this race last fall but it carried an asterisk. It became the Shadwell (fake dirt) Mile when a monsoon forced the race off the turf.
Horse of the Year is still Shared Beliefâs to lose but if he comes up short in the Classic and Wise Dan takes the Shadwell and a third BC Turf Mile, another Horse of the Year laurel is a strong possibility.
Written by Tom Jicha
Saturday, September 27, 2014
Shared Belief steals the show on a day of stars
Shared Belief was awesome again in the Awesome Again. Overcoming a nightmare trip, he was more awesome than ever in gutting out his seventh straight win. In spite of Tonalist 's facile score in the Jockey Club Gold Cup, Shared Belief heads toward the Breeders' Cup one of the biggest favorites on racing's biggest day.
If there were any doubts about the brilliance of Shared Belief, they were dispelled Saturday in a race whose title, Awesome Again, could not have been more appropriate. If anything Shared Belief was more awesome than ever.
His head margin over front-running Fed Biz was his closest call yet but it said more about him than any of his six previous daylight scores. You never really know what kind of heart a horse has until he has to gut it out in the final yards. Shared Heart has a heart bigger than California.
Shared Belief demonstrated in the Pacific Classic that he could overcome adversity. In the Awesome Again, he did things that are the stuff of legends.
Jockeys always ride to beat the favorite but what Victor Espinoza aboard Sky Kingdom did to get Shared Belief beat should be looked into by the stewards. Espinoza floated Shared Belief about eight wide into the first turn. According to Trakus, Shared Belief was pushed 24-plus feet off the rail. Thatâs almost a first down.
Espinoza continued to keep the undefeated favorite wide down the backside before he finally began his fade to last. This allowed the others to sneak through inside them and ensure Shared Belief would be almost as wide around the final turn.
âThey tried some tactics on us,â winning rider Mike Smith said, being as charitable as possible.Smith estimated Sky Kingdom had Shared Belief stuck in the nine path.
Why would Espinoza ride as if his only goal was to get Shared Belief beaten? Here are a couple of things to consider. Espinoza was riding half of Bob Baffertâs uncoupled entry. Thanks to Espinoza, the other half, Fed Biz, was able to skim the rail on the lead and almost held on for the upset.
Then thereâs the fact that Espinoza is the regular rider of California Chrome, the colt whoâs trying to hold off Shared Belief for the 3-year-old title.
All of this does make you think.
How ironic it was only a week ago when Espinoza complained other jockeys in the Pennsylvania Derby were riding to thwart California Chrome.
There was an outstanding performance by a 3-year-old at Belmont, too. Tonalist moved to the head of the Eastâs 3-year-old class with a smart win in the Jockey Club Gold Cup. With blinkers off, he rallied from farther back than usual and split horses inside the eighth pole to get home ahead of Zivo and Long River.
The race was marred when Tonalistâs summer-long rival, Wicked Strong, was dropped by Moreno moving into the far turn. Wicked Strong was in a contending position when the mishap occurred, so thereâs no telling what the outcome might have been if the Wood and Jim Dandy winner had been able to run his race. Moreno was disqualified from fourth and placed last.
This was Tonalistâs first win over older horses but it is a distinction that doesnât have its usual cachet. With Palace Malice, Will Take Charge and Mucho Macho Man on the sidelines and Moreno and Itsmyluckyday misfiring, the older division is shallow in talent.
The attrition among older horsesâGame on Dude, the pride of the West the past few years is also gone-- sets up a Breedersâ Cup Classic in which the three or four top betting choices could be 3-year-olds. Shared Belief will be a strong favorite. Thereâs no doubt about that.
Then thereâs Tonalist and California Chrome, back home in the West. It could be four 3-year-olds heading the Classic if Baffert decides to try 10 furlongs again with Bayern. Maybe Shared Beliefâs performance Saturday will coax Baffert to think better of that. The Dirt mile makes much more sense.
The potential travesty of Beholder capturing three straight Eclipses without ever winning a graded race anywhere but Santa Anita moved another step closer to fruition when she outran five foes in the Zenyatta. This race was effectively over when Iotapa, Beholderâs only serious competitor, missed her break.
Belle Gallantey won the East Coast equivalent, the Beldame, but itâs difficult to get too excited about her victory despite her more than eight length margin. John Velasquez aboard Stopchargingmaria opted to let Belle Gallantey gallop unchallenged on the lead in pedestrian fractions. The race was over by the halfway point.
If someone is to dethrone Beholder, it is more likely to be Close Hatches, who has her final Breedersâ Cup prep in the Spinster on real dirt at Keeneland on Saturday.
Saturdayâs biggest disappointment had to be Itsmyluckyday in the Kelso. If Eddie Plesa was looking for an easy spot to get ready for the BC Classic, he picked the wrong race. River Rocks, going for his fourth straight, and Braedster sandwiched Itsmyluckyday most of the way, setting the race up for Vyjack, who sat a dream trip just behind the leaders and well ahead of the rest. Vyjack probably isn't going to Santa Anita. His connections are pointing for the Cigar Mile.
Stephanieâs Kitten didnât disappoint for a change in the Flower Bowl. Johnny Velasquez kept her in the clear on the outside, but not too far outside, then pounced in the stretch to break a four-race winless streak for Ken Ramsey's filly. But you have to think there will be a couple or three Euros she might find too tough to handle at the Breedersâ Cup.
The same could be true of Turf Classic winner Main Sequence, who won his third straight Grade 1 since coming over from Great Britain. Give him and Graham Motion a lot of credit. All three wins have been in photo finishes. But he wasnât the same terror on the other side of the Atlantic.
Private Zone is heading back to the BC Sprint after repeating in the Vosburgh. A year ago, he ran tenth at Santa Anita after winning Belmontâs premier sprint. The field he beat Saturday doesnât suggest heâs the one to beat this year.
Written by Tom Jicha