Wednesday, January 15, 2014
Eclipse Awards another indictment of Keeneland’s Polytrack
Keeneland used to be a home of champions. Since an artificial surface was installed in 2006, it has become home to oddball results. The winners of its most important main track stakes are nowhere to be found among the Eclipse finalists, which has become the norm. In the past seven-plus years, not one of the winners of the Grade 1 Blue Grass, Alcibiades, Ashland, Breeders' Futurity and Spinster has doubled on Eclipse night.
MIAMI, Jan. 15, 2014--The annual presentation of the Eclipse Awards Saturday brings still another reminder of racingâs dirty little secret.
Itâs the sacred cow status of Keeneland since it installed a synthetic track. Nine Eclipse categories have no surface restrictions. Of the 24 finalists (three have double nominations; Wise Dan has a third for turf), only three competed on Keenelandâs Polytrack. One was Wise Dan, when the Shadwell Mile was taken off the grass. None won. Wise Dan suffered his only defeat when he ran second, Groupie Doll was third in the TCA and Palace Malice was second in the Blue Grass.
Keenelandâs Polytrack has become the home of results out of synch with the rest of racing.
There is far more evidence that Keeneland has become an outlier among American racetracks since putting down fake dirt for the 2006 fall meeting.
Fourteen graded stakes were run on the kitty litter in 2013, including the relocated Shadwell Mile. Not one of the winners is among the final three in any Eclipse category.
As they say in the TV infomercials, but wait, thereâs more. Keeneland annually presents six Grade 1âs, three in the spring, three in the fall. Groupie Doll last year and Informed Decision in 2009 both won the Madison en route to a female sprint Eclipse. The winners of the other fiveâthe Alcibiades, Ashland, Blue Grass, Breeders Futurity and Spinsterâhave produced zero Eclipse champions since Godâs brown dirt was abandoned.
Since the fall of 2006, 38 thoroughbreds have won these five nominally top tier events. Not one has been voted an Eclipse. Over the past three years, only Groupie Doll and Stephanieâs Kitten, who took the Alcibiades in 2011, have even been Eclipse finalists.
Nevertheless, it is considered heresy to even suggest that any be downgraded to a level more appropriate for the influence they have had on the sport. After all, this is Keeneland.
I have a better idea than downgrading the stakes. To bastardize some of the most famous words to come out of an American President's mouth, âMr. Thomason, tear up that track.â
Eclipse categories lack clarity
As long as weâre on the subject of Eclipse Awards, a familiar debate has been reignited.
Gary West, one of Americaâs most respected turf writers, wrote a column arguing that Wise Dan would be a poor choice for Best Older Horse, because his successes were all on turf, which has a category of its own. In his view, Mucho Macho Man or Game or Dude must be awarded the prize.
Since Wise Dan won this award last year, West is in the minority. Moreover, Mizdirection, who never set foot on dirt, is a finalist among female sprinters, a category many consider a main track prize. Obviously, the majority viewpoint is turf counts.
This doesnât make West wrong, as anyone who has supported a losing political candidate will attest. West is doing the right thing, passionately arguing his position in the hope it will become the majority stance in the future. Alas, he went over the top, making it personal. He labeled others who donât see things his way "narcissists." Heâs better than that.
Nick Kling, whose opinions are frequently expressed in Horse Race Insider, presented a cogent response to West in the Troy (NY) Record. Kling opined that as long as there are no specific rules, it is up to each voter to make a decision.
I have to come down on Klingâs side. I voted for Wise Dan for best older horse last year and I did it again this year. He was 6-for-7, all stakes, four of his wins in Grade 1âs, including the Breedersâ Cup Mile.
But if Game on Dude had won the Breedersâ Cup Classic, which would have given him a comparable record, I would have voted for him for Horse of the Year and Older Horse, because all things being equal, dirt is still Americaâs primary surface. But as it is, no one had a year close to the equal of Wise Danâs.
This underlines the subjectivity of the Eclipse voting. Is an Eclipse champion the horse with the most stakes wins; the best winning percentages in graded stakes; the most Grade 1 wins; a Breedersâ Cup champion?
When this yearâs winners are announced, there will be some who fit into each of those categories. But there also will be non-winners (no horse outstanding enough be an Eclipse finalist should ever be called a loser), who fit within those parameters.
Racing is not alone in having debates of this kind. Every few years, when a pitcher has an extraordinary season, there are factions in baseball who argue that since pitchers have the Cy Young Award, they should not be considered for MVP. Occasionally they are over-ruled by the majority.
The Baseball Writers of America Association has had plenty of opportunities to clarify the standards. Instead, voters have been instructed to follow the same guidelines that also should be the rule for the Eclipse Awards. Use your own best judgment.
And donât denigrate those who have a different opinion.
Written by Tom Jicha
Friday, January 10, 2014
Sham is not a race to be regarded lightly
Santa Anita's Sham Stakes comes up early in Derby prep season but the last three renewals have produced future Breeders' Cup winners. Back in Florida, Gulfstream has a couple of wide open stakes but the return of Revolutionary, third in last year's Run for the Roses, in an allowance might be the most significant race of the day.
MIAMI, Jan. 10, 2013--It doesnât take long for Kentucky Derby season to pick up momentum. From now through May, barely a weekend will go by without a noteworthy 3-year-old stakes.
General a Rod and Noble Moon have enhanced their candidacies with wins in the Gulfstream Derby on New Yearâs Day and Jerome at Aqueduct last weekend, respectively.
A new sophomore or two to keep an eye on will likely identify himself in Saturdayâs Sham Stakes at Santa Anita. Only six will go, but short fields are the norm for this early season event. Nonetheless, a lot of quality has come out of this stakes. The mile race hasnât produced a Classics winner but future Breedersâ Cup winners have emerged from the last three renewalsâGoldencents, Secret Circle and Tapizar. Secret Circle was also a Breedersâ Cup winner going in. So despite its early placement on the calendar, the Sham is not a race to be regarded lightly.
As often is the case this time of year, the field is dominated by newly turned 3-year-olds coming off impressive maiden wins, two in their career debuts. But the most intriguing of the bunch, Ontology, took eight starts to find the winnerâs circle.
However, give the son of Tapit a big asterisk. After running second in his MSW debut, he was thrown into deep water in six straight stakes on dirt, synthetics and turf. Nevertheless, he managed seconds in the Oak Tree Juvenile and Hollywood Juvenile. He also has plenty of two-turn experience, a factor never to be under-estimated when assessing this type of race.
Thanks to the presence of first-out winners Top Fortitude and Midnight Hawk, he might be a bit of a price. Midnight Hawk, another Bob Baffert bullet, might have a little more to offer since his runaway win came at the demanding 7 Â˝ furlong distance at Hollywood, after a rough start and racing greenly. Top Fortitude won his debut by almost three lengths at 6 Â˝ furlongs.
Caveat emptor: Both victories were on Hollywoodâs Cushion surface.
Kristo broke his maiden for John Sadler on Santa Anitaâs dirt track.
Doug OâNeillâs Iâll Wrap It Up has missed the board only once in five tries.
Jerry Hollendorfer, who somehow was overlooked by Eclipse voters, sends out the only two-time winner, Life Is a Joy, a minor stakes winner at Fresno and second in the Cal-bred King Glorious.
Back east, Gulfstream has a pair of highly competitive Saturday stakes, the Grade 2 Fort Lauderdale, a mile and a sixteenth on turf, and the Grade 3 Halâs Hope, a one turn mile on dirt. But an allowance race early on the card with a connection to last yearâs Derby might prove to be most noteworthy event.
Revolutionary, third in the 2013 Kentucky Derby, returns to the races for the first time since a fifth-place finish in the Belmont Stakes. Prior to the Triple Crown, he had wins in the Withers and Louisiana Derby, so he could be a serious presence in 2014.
The regally bred offspring of War Pass and the AP Indy mare Runup the Colors will be attempting to return to his winning ways in the second race, a high caliber optional claimer at a mile, which could turn into a prep for the Feb. 8 Donn Handicap.
Revolutionary is not being given a âgimme.â The seven-horse field also includes Honorable Dillon, who won the 2013 Hutcheson, and Reveron, winner of the 2012 Gulfstream Derby and runnerup in the Florida Derby. However, the latterâs two most recent efforts off an 11-month layoff havenât been close to that quality. Then again, thereâs the third race off a layoff angle to be considered.
Defending champions are back in both the Fort Lauderdale and Halâs Hope.
Mucho Mas Machoânot to be confused with the similarly named MMM horse, who is expected back in next weekâs Sunshine Classicâupset last yearâs edition at 41-1. Having not won since, he could be almost that price again.
Favoritism could come down to Summer Front, back from the West Coast after missing by a nose to Silentio in the Citation, or Slumber, who won back-to-back races at Saratoga a year apart, then came up short in a pair of Grade 1âs to end his 2013 season.
Without much pace, Howe Great, who loves the Gulfstream turf, is an interesting price opportunity. The Team Valor representative wired the Palm Beach Stakes (with Dullahan and Csaba in his wake) on this lawn a couple of years ago.
The Halâs Hope brings back the last two winners, Csaba (2013) and Jackson Bend (2012). Csabaâs affection for South Florida is renowned and Jackson Bend has fired Grade 1 winning efforts around one turn.
But this is a race in which it might pay to shop. Marty Wolfson has Simmstown gunning for three in a row and four out of five. When Wolfson gets them good, they stay good and he's lethal any time there's added money on the line in Florida.
Strike One makes his stakes debut for under-rated Brendan Walsh off a pair of Churchill wins.
Neck ân Neck, a leading 3-year-old in 2012, is third off a layoff for Ian Wilkes.
Uncaptured, who left Kentucky in the fall of 2012 as one of the Derby horses to watch, didnât live up to that billing but did get home first in a leg of the Canadian Triple Crown.
Not to be overlooked is Lea, whose connections canât seem to figure out his best surface. His last three have been on synthetic, dirt and turf. But he opened his season with a solid win on a wet main track (there has been a lot of rain this week in the Miami area) and heâs first time Bill Mott. Deuces have been spent less wisely.
Written by Tom Jicha
Wednesday, January 01, 2014
Saying goodbye and looking ahead
Thoughts, complaints and suggestions to improve racing in 2014 and beyond
Miami, Jan. 1, 2014--Clearing the decks of random thoughts to get a fresh start on the new year:
How sadly ironic
is it that fewer than three days after Calder unveiled its 2014 stakes schedule, it had to cancel the LaPrevoyante Stakes last Saturday for lack of interest. Stakes are canceled everywhere from time to time for lack of entries, usually inconsequential dirt races. If there ever has been a graded stakes on the turf jettisoned, I canât recall it. âThis was a business decision based entirely on economics,â Calder general manager John Marshall said. How Churchill Downs is that? Looking ahead, the 2014 stakes schedule amounts to more of a wish list than a game plan.
Speaking of wishful thinking
, it would be great if someone who cares about racing made Churchill Downs Inc. an offer it canât refuse to rescue the most cherished name in racing from the bottom-line vultures who have alienated everyone in the game; horsemen, media and, especially, fans.
that gives horsemenâs organizations the power to deny simulcast rights to racetracks on any whim has to be amended or repealed. Among other abuses, it is being used to keep the Breedersâ Cup from experimenting with a ban on race day medications. Tracks and the Breeders' Cup should be able to operate within reason without fear of being extorted by horsemen acting like thugs. The law was passed when no one had any appreciation of how simulcasting would become critical to the existence of the sport.
Go to any track
on any racing day and just about every horse on the card will be running on Lasix. This means that every horse in North America is a bleeder or the drug has uses that have nothing to do with its supposed benefit.
Iâm still waiting
for the hammer to come down on Eric Guillot for his meritless claim that Luis Saez used an electrical device in the Travers. If Guillot doesnât suffer serious sanctions for his irresponsible behavior, no jockey should ever be fined for a frivolous claim of foul. Those impact only one race. Guillot struck at the integrity of the game on one of its biggest stages.
The computer geeks
who concocted the infamous Fix Six at the 2002 Breedersâ Cup, are out of jail. Why not give them a chance to redeem themselves by putting them to work on the Obamacare website.
Iâve always wondered
how much simulcast business Del Mar loses because of its atypical 2 p.m. first post, which is 5 p.m. in the East. We might get an indication with the new fall meet. The onset of dusk after daylight savings time ends will dictate an earlier first post.
to Hollywood Park, any race track, is sad but I wonât miss the addition of Betfair to the trackâs name. The first time I saw BHP in a workout line before the amended name became commonplace, I had no idea what it referred to. I thought it was a training center. Same goes for the new BSR for Fairplex/Pomona. The Racing Form should serve the public, not the egos of corporate racetrack owners. Think of where this could lead: NYRABel, TSGSA and CDICrc (or the even more absurd CDICD).
Dear fellow racing media
: Please consign âon the other side of the pondâ to the trash compactor of history. It was cute the first 750,000 times it was written but it has become the clichĂŠ of choice of lazy journalists.
If you do that
, I promise to no longer report the quotes of owners and trainers, who say they see no reason why their 3-year-old, bred to be a sprinter and built like a sprinter, canât get the Derby distance.
A Triple Crown winner
would be great for myriad reasons, not the least of which is it would put a stop to all the cockamamie columns and letters suggesting ways to revise the best thing racing has going for it.
people to get involved more than self interest. There has to be a way for the Breedersâ Cup to join with a brewer, car company or supermarket chain to distribute free lottery-type scratch-off cards tied to the results to bring people to racingâs second biggest day? (Nothing tops the first Saturday in May.)
NYRA CEO Christopher Kay
is the undisputed winner of the double-talk of 2013 award. Speaking at the year-end University of Arizona symposium, the camera-ready executive said, âAttendance doesnât spend money, people do.â Huh? Is this guy a member of the National Rifle Association? If Iâm interpreting him correctly, you have to wonder why NYRA continues to have giveaway days at Saratoga, which goose attendance figures by including thousands of people who arenât even on the grounds for the racing program.
My wish list
for 2014 will be fulfilled if a way can be found to get Hialeah back into the South Florida thoroughbred rotation.
Written by Tom Jicha