Wednesday, February 08, 2017
Shed a tear for Hialeah thanks to latest travesty
Hialeah, still beautiful as ever, continues to descend into racing oblivion. The latest travesty is as outrageous as the Metropolitan Museum of Art being transformed into a brothel would be. A quarterhorse meet has been used to justify Hialeah being allowed to operate a slots casino and poker room. Now that is being abandoned in favor of some sort of sham racing where as few as two horses gallop--in a manner of speaking--down a path. The only consolation is, it might not come to pass if decoupling is approved by the Florida legislature this spring.
I havenât been to Hialeah for simulcasting since the Gulfstream West meeting. If Iâm going to watch local races on TV, Hialeah is half the trip for me that Gulfstream is.
The Hialeah experience still gives me a good feeling. Palm trees still sway, the grounds remain breath-taking, flamingos cavort in the infield and the clubhouse has been refurbished. Itâs like revisiting my old neighborhood, which has become, shall we say, not a desirable place to live anymore. But the structures and landscape are unchanged, so going back still rekindles warm memories of what once was.
On my next trip to Hialeah, if there is one, Iâm going to check to see if there is a tear running down the cheek of the statue of Citation. There should be.
According to a dispatch in The Paulick Report, the once most cherished thoroughbred track in the world is about to be reduced to running sham two-horse races to satisfy the legal requirement to keep its casino and card rooms.
This might seem only marginally worse than the Gulfstream West meeting at a venue that is now an empty lot bordering a race track or the low grade quarterhorse meeting Hialeah has used to keep its casino . But Calder, as much as it grew on me over the years, was never the treasure of the turf that Hialeah was.
The latest development all but dashes my dream of thoroughbreds racing under the flamingoes again. I felt that if decoupling were passed, as seems likely this legislative season, the Gulfstream West meeting at Calder would be put out of its misery and Hialeah would move in with a short boutique meeting between Gulfstreamâs summer session and the prime winter meet.
It would make sense. A fall hiatus is beneficial to Gulfstream. It breaks the monotony of running 12 straight months at a single venue with one season bleeding right into the next. But now, as they say in Brooklyn, "Fuhgeddaboutit!"
I still think decoupling is a factor in the farcical meeting Hialeah got approved. Iâm not the only one who feels decoupling is inevitable. If it happens, it will probably be at the end of April, near the conclusion of the 2017 legislative season.
Hialeah announced last year that it was shifting its keep-the-casino quarterhorse meeting from December-February to a June start, apparently hoping decoupling would make it unnecessary. By dumping the quarterhorses for barrel racing or flag fall racing or God-knows-what racing, Hialeah doesnât even have to go through the motions of preparing for a quarterhorse meet.
This is the thanks the scuffling quarterhorse guys get for helping Hialeah to get a casino.
Some things never change in John Brunetti Land.
Too many stakes
The foal crop has dropped in half over the past decade or so. Logically speaking, the roster of stakes worthy horses also has had a decline. Yet, it seems as if the number of stakes races hasnât had a corresponding reduction. If anything, stakes opportunities have increased.
Tim Ritvo was justifiably proud when the Pegasus, even with its million dollar buy-in, and its consolation heat, the Poseidon, drew 21 entries on Jan. 28. âNormally we struggle to get eight in the Donn (the premier handicap race the Pegasus replaced),â the Gulfstream president said.
He might have added that one week earlier, eight older horses ran a mile and eighth in the Sunshine Millions Classic. There was only one repeater between the Classic and the Poseidon, Hy Riverside. Thus, 28 older horses ran for added money within a week.
This Saturday, older horses will go at it again in the Gulfstream Park Handicap. Nine have been entered. Iron horse Hy Riverside is answering the bell again. Awesome Banner and Awesome Slew are back from the Millions. Even with these repeaters, the three-week total of older horses in stakes stands at 34. Subtract Arrogate and Imperative, who shipped in from California to win the Pegasus and Posideon, as well as California Chrome and this still leaves 31.
The question is, are there really 31 older stakes caliber horses in South Florida at this time of year? The answer would have to be no. An argument could be made that there arenât 31 genuine older stakes horses in the country.
I never thought I would be one to call for a reduction in stakes. However, it takes more than dropping an entry slip in the box to qualify as a stakes horse. Fewer stakes, spaced over a longer period of time, would enhance the prestige and caliber of field of all of them.
The Sunshine Millions should be relocated to December. The Halâs Hope could also stay at the end of the calendar year for horses ineligible for the Florida-bred races. The Pegasus and any accompanying race should have January all to themselves.
A race like the Harlanâs Holiday could be wedged into late February or early March. The Gulfstream Handicap would be a nice fit on the Florida Derby undercard. Run the first week in April, it might attract some of the better handicap horses ready to come out of their winter break.
It makes little sense to continue to cram these races within little more than a month.
Bring back the Donn
With a second edition of the Pegasus likely, Iâd like to reiterate my call to attach the Donn name to the Gulfstream Park Handicap, which is kind of a generic anyway.
Without the Donn family, there would be no Gulfstream Park.
If the Pegasus indeed comes back and the Donn is not used for a stakes for the second straight year in 2018, it will be stripped of its graded status and likely be forgotten about. That would be a pity.
Miami, February 9, 2017
Written by Tom Jicha
Thursday, February 02, 2017
Woody’s revered record facing a challenge
Woody Stephens' five consecutive Belmont Stakes winners is a record that could stand for all time. However, it is fair to ask if Bob Baffert is approaching an equally superlative achievement. He has won three straight Breeders' Cup Classics and has Arrogate for a potential fourth. After last Saturday's Pegasus, you have to wonder, who is going to beat this superhorse?
MIAMI--Some records are so revered, they are considered almost unassailable: Joe DiMaggioâs 56-game hitting streak; Wilt Chamberlainâs 100-point game; the Dolphinsâ perfect season. For racing fans, Woody Stephensâ feat of five consecutive Belmont Stakes winners fits into this category.
Literally, Woodyâs mark might never be surpassed. Since Woodyâs remarkable run from 1982-86, only D. Wayne Lukas has won as many as three consecutive Belmont Stakes. No one else has gone even back-to-back.
However Arrogateâs sensational triumph in the Pegasus raises the question of whether we might be on the verge of a racing achievement at the highest level that is the equal or better of Woodyâs.
Itâs a long way from February to November. At this point last year, no one outside Bob Baffertâs inner circle had heard of Arrogate. But right now the grey colt would have to be considered a short price to give Baffert his fourth straight Breedersâ Cup Classic victory. Arrogateâs connections say this is his No 1 target for 2017. Everything else will be counting backward from the Nov. 4 Classic at Del Mar, according to Baffert.
Barring injuryâgranted, a big leapâwhoâs going to beat him? What the son of Unbridled Song has done in his last three races has been other-worldly and, in a strange development, it has gotten even better since Saturday.
Respected clockers, including Craig Milkowski of Time Form U.S., Randy Moss and Bruno DeJulio, have challenged the official clocking of 1:47.61. Milkowski has concluded that Arrogate ran nine furlongs in 1:46.53, better than Leaâs track record of 1:46.86. This would give Arrogate a second track record in three starts, to go with his 1:59.36 in the Travers.
Gulfstream is promising an official review. Whether Arrogate gets credit for another record is almost irrelevant. âSuperhorse,â Milkowski wrote.
Andy Beyer has revised upward his âfigâ for Arrogate from 116 to 119. This puts it in line with his 120 for the BC Classic and 122 for the Travers, figs in a different stratosphere.
Certainly no older horse weâve seen can keep up with Arrogate, especially with California Chrome gone. Heâs killed the best that can be lined up twice now. As for last yearâs 3-year-old crop, the winners of all three Triple Crown races have gone to the breeding shed. Gun Runner and Connect, the best of those who didnât show up for the Pegasus, finished a time zone behind Arrogate in the Travers and Classic.
What about new 3 year-olds?
Maybe thereâs a newly turned 3-year-old, who will be ready to challenge by yearâs end. Juvenile champion Classic Empire launches his campaign this Saturday in the Holy Bull. The only time he has been beaten was when he wheeled at the start. Undefeated McCraken cranks it up a week from Saturday in the Sam F. Davis at Tampa Bay Downs. Also undefeated Mastery is being pointed toward a March race, according to Baffert. It could turn out the biggest threat to Arrogate is another Baffert.
Do four Breedersâ Cup Classics in a row equal five Belmont Stakes? I would argue yes. The Belmont at a mile and a half is a one of a kind race, often diminished by shortcomings of the breed as well as the attrition of the grueling Triple Crown campaign. Of Woodyâs five winners, only 1984 Derby winner Swale took part in the first two legs the Triple Crown events. The other four skipped one or the other, some both, to be pointed specifically for the Belmont while others of their generation knocked themselves out in the Derby and Preakness.
The Breedersâ Cup has become the year-end championship, run at Americaâs classic distance. It is targeted for the entire season by almost everyone in the game, including some of Europeâs best.
I am not minimizing Woodyâs accomplishments. Others had the same opportunities and didnât come close. I am merely putting them in the context of this debate.
This is not to say the Baffert conveyer belt of superstars might not provide him with a fifth straight or more Classic champion.
To this point, the two streaks have only one significant bond. Both have been done entirely with 3-year-olds. This was a prerequisite, of course, of Woodyâs feat. Baffert has beaten all comers of any age with Bayern, American Pharoah and Arrogate.
A fabulous day for TSG & racing
Getting back to the Pegasus, it was great to hear Belinda Stronach rave about the South Florida vibe and how she hopes to bring the worldâs richest race back to Gulfstream in 2018. But all this was said in the euphoria of what was a fabulous day for The Stronach Group and racing.
It remains to be seen if it will be as easy this coming year to get a dozen entities to ante up $1 million months ahead of time on the if-come.
One lesson learned is that by January there are not 12 horses worthy of such an event. Three of this yearâs dozen went off in excess of 100-1. A fourth, Eragon, the South American substitute for Runhappy, should have been 1,000-1. He trailed throughout. A GPS device would be needed to tabulate how far he finished behind Arrogate.
So the possibility of a slot in the starting gate becoming a sellersâ market asset is unlikely to come to pass. Itâs a debatable point whether the possibility of having Arrogate go for an encore next January is a plus. It certainly is for the race, not so much for getting others to sign on.
The ancillary revenue streams promised to share-holders are probably a long way from amounting to much, if anything. The TV ratings, which Tim Ritvo said was crucial to future finances, were nothing special. The 1.23 Nielsen rating translated to about two million fans. Compare this to the 12 million who dependably tune into the Kentucky Derby.
The ratings were roughly comparable to the Breedersâ Cup, which has been around since 1984 and still doesnât command a dime for TV rights. Sponsorships, another potential source of revenue for subscribers, will have to continue to pay the freight to get the Pegasus on TV.
If there is a bright spot, it is the $40 million plus handed Saturday, a little less than half that on the Pegasus. Share-holders have been promised a piece of this in the future.
If somehow a Japanese horse could be lured to the race, this could almost double and actually amount to something for share-holders.
There is a reason Japanese race horses have become as in demand as a fun date in prom season. The Japanese bet about $20 million on the Arc when one of their horses is competing. Itâs not unreasonable to expect that much or more on the Pegasus if one of their local heroes was in the field.
This is why Ritvo took a party to Japan hoping to get a Japanese horse for the inaugural Pegasus. Itâs why the Kentucky Derby has set aside a slot for a Japanese 3-year-old and NYRA has put up a $1 million bonus for a Japanese horse who wins the Belmont.
A more equitable distribution of the Pegasus purse also is mandatory. As it was, only Arrogate, who took home $7 million and house horse Shaman Ghost, who won $1.75 million for second, turned a profit. The $1 million Neolithic got for third was merely the break-even mark; less than that when you subtract jockey and trainer fees. Finishing third should be profitable.
The $7 million will stay to maintain the Pegasus as the worldâs biggest payoffâat least until the sheiks in Dubai pony up some more oil money. But the other $5 million needs a redistribution table; maybe $2 million for second; $1.5 million for third; $1 million for fourth and the rest set aside as expense money for the also-rans. Awarding $250,000 for fourth through last runs against everything horse racing is supposed to be.
Nothing is perfect the first time it is attempted, as Ritvo said. There was far more good than not at the inaugural Pegasus. Letâs hope this is sufficient to ensure many more Pegasuses in the future.
Written by Tom Jicha
Thursday, January 26, 2017
Two-horse Pegasus can still be a good betting race
If Arrogate or California Chrome don't win the Pegasus, it will be the biggest upset since, well, Upset beat Man O War. It's conceivable either of the big two could throw in a clunker or run into trouble. Stuff happens. For both to come up short is inconceivable. Still there are ways to make the Pegasus an interesting betting proposition thanks to multiple horizontal and vertical wagers. But the best strategy is to enjoy these two superstars meeting for the final time.
MIAMI, Jan. 26--The NBA has 30 teams. Outside local loyalists, it would be hard to find anyone who doesnât expect either the Cleveland Cavaliers or Golden State Warriors to win this yearâs championship.
This is analogous to Saturdayâs $12 million Pegasus. Anything can happen in a horse race but it requires a surplus of imagination and optimism to work up a credible case for anyone but California Chrome or Arrogate. One is the newly crowned Horse of the Year, the other was just named the worldâs best race horse. In the Breedersâ Cup Classic, which had a tougher field top to bottom, they put 10-plus lengths on the rest.
To borrow an expression, the others donât breathe the same air. For one of them to beat either of the stars would be a gargantuan upset. To beat both would be cause to think about throwing away the Racing Form and resort to picking names or jockey colors.
For the hardcore, there are still ways to make it an interesting betting proposition. Of course, thereâs the multi-race bets, Pick 3âs, 4âs, 5âs and the Rainbow 6. But even if youâre not alive, there are wide-open exactas and trifectasâthe back end of the superfectas and super hi 5. Do what you will with the top two then put your next two or three below them.
You have to wonder about the race within the race. How many of the 10 field-fillers will just lay back and gun for the $1 million show money. It doesnât matter after that, since fourth through 12th gets the same $250,000.
Keen Ice is an obvious fit for a big minor share. He doesnât have the speed to test the big two, so burnout is less of a threat, he will be running late and heâs had a race over the track. Alas, a standard trifecta including him might pay single digits thanks to his giant killer reputation for running down American Pharoah in the 2015 Travers.
If youâre looking for ticket-makers, you could do worse than Breaking Lucky and Semper Fortis. Both are in sharp hands and have run races good enough to get on the board here. A superfecta box with the big two on top and what amounts to a three-horse box with Keen Ice, Breaking Lucky and Semper Fortis in the third and fourth slots might be a good way to go.
But the big two make this a race to watch and savor. To waste the experience of seeing the superstars coming down to the wire by focusing on the battle for fourth or fifth is sinful.
Likewise, the riders of the also-rans will get $1,000 apiece unless they have a private arrangement, according to Tim Ritvo, COO of The Stronach Group and President of Gulfstream Park. He says all have been advised that they will be expected to go all out to get the lesser spots.
This is merely one of the issues surrounding the Pegasus. But few things are perfect right from the get-go. Secretariat got beat in his first start. So did American Pharoah and Arrogate. You fix what wasnât quite right and go on from there.âLike anything else, you get better with practice,â Ritvo said
The equality of purse money beyond third and paying back to last was a sweetener for stakes-holders and is something that will be reconsidered for the future, Ritvo said. When the $1 million buy-in was conceived there was no confidence a dozen players could be enticed. âMr. Stronach was prepared to buy three shares,â Ritvo said. But the 12 slots were gone within a week. Stronach kept one, which he will use on Shaman Ghost.
Much has been made of each share-holder putting up $1 million. Thanks to the $250,000 guarantee, the ante is really $750,000. This is still a lot of cash but Ritvo tried to put it into an interesting perspective. âThrough the years, people have bought million dollar horses, always looking to get into the big races. What we did was say, âWhy not buy the spot in the gate then try to find your horse?â So we kind of reverse engineered the process.â
The original share-holders also have right of first refusal for future renewals of the Pegasus and the potential to share in the proceeds for media rights. This might be overly optimistic. The Stronach Group is paying NBC to carry the race from 4:30-6 p.m.This is the norm. Only the Triple Crown races command rights fees. All other races, including the long established Breedersâ Cup, pay to be on TV in one form or another. Sponsorships are used to cover the cost.
This is why Ritvo said the most important metric on Saturday isnât crowd size or handle but TV ratings. âWeâre hoping in the future there will be a bidding war between the networks to carry the race?â It will be a greater accomplishment than creating the worldâs richest race if The Stronach Group can ever get TV to pay a rights fee.
In the latest example of Murphyâs Law (If something can go wrong, it will) the worst nightmare for the Pegasus--a standout horse drawing a bad postâcame to fruition when California Chrome pulled the No. 12 pill.Over the past decade, the only horse to win a mile-and-an-eighth race from No. 12 at Gulfstream is Big Brown in the 2008 Florida Derby. Big Brown, who went on to win the Derby and Preakness, didnât have an Arrogate inside him.
Chromeâs trainer, Art Sherman, has such faith in his horse, the draw didnât faze him. âHeâs overcome about every post. He drew the 1 in the Pacific Classic and nobody was winning from there but you saw what happened. Then in Dubai he was on the outside, the 11. It might as well have been the 12. He is just a push button horse. You can get your position coming out of there because heâs got enough early speed to put him in any place you want to.â
The short run to the first turn at nine furlongs has been viewed as problematic since the Pegasus was announced, Ritvo acknowledged. A mile and a quarter was considered. The feeling was a mile and an eighth would attract milers stretching out and mile-and-a-quarter type horses. I'll say it one more time. Why not a mile-and-three-sixteenths, the same distance as The Stronach Group premier race, the Preakness?
One miler stretching out that the Pegasus people had to have in mind was 2015 Eclipse Sprint Champion Runhappy, whose owner James McIngvale was an original subscriber. âMattress Macâ spent 2016 trying to get Runhappy to stretch out with the Pegasus the target. He wound up wasting a year of a great horseâs career and having to settle for Argentinian import Eragonâa miler.
Some feel the No. 1 post could be disadvantageous to Arrogate, if he doesnât break sharply. Money Mike Smith, who will be aboard, doesnât share this concern.âIt worked good for us in the Travers. You hope it works again.â
Heâd take any post over the one California Chrome wound up with. âThe post I didnât want to draw the most is the 12. The 1 isnât the post I would have chosen, either, but it is what it is. Heâs sharp right now. Heâs been training aggressive in the morning, so heâs going to be aggressive leaving there.â
He better be. âChome is on his game,â a supremely confident Sherman said. âHeâs as good as Iâve ever seen him. Itâs going to be a great race.â
Minor issues notwithstanding, kudos to The Stronach Group for making it happen.
Written by Tom Jicha