Saturday, March 02, 2013
Vyjack answers another question in Gotham; bad day for Pletcher
Saturday was another disappointing day for Team Pletcher's Kentucky Derby hopes. Overanalyze ran a dull fifth in the Gotham, putting him in jeopardy of missing the cut under the new Kentucky Derby points system. Vyjack has no such worries. He remained undefeated and showed a new dimension, racing from far back under Joel Rosario, to turn the Gotham into a tour de force. His 50 points is more than enough to earn a spot in the Derby starting gate. Meanwhile a new Derby hopeful might have emerged from the seven furlong Swale at Gulfstream. Clearly Now closed strongly to win stylishly enough to have his trainer, Brian Lynch, think about putting him back on the Derby Trial. A Pletcher colt disappointed here, too, as Forty Tales ran fifth as the even-money favorite.
By Tom Jicha
HALLANDALE, FL--The Swale used to be a significant stepping stone toward the Kentucky Derby, the co-feature on Florida Derby Day. That was in an era when trainers didnâ€™t regard a three-race or more prep agenda as animal abuse. Triple Crown contenders would get their 3-year-old campaign started in the seven furlong Swale, then move on to a couple of two-turn stakes.
More significantly, the new Kentucky Derby points system, which dismisses races at less than a mile, hadnâ€™t been created. All of this made this yearâ€™s Swale seem to be merely an early season gauge of outstanding sophomore sprinters.
The Swale still might turn out to be just that. But hold the phone. It took Clearly Now only 1:23.19 to perhaps vault himself back into Derby consideration. â€śThereâ€™s always that temptation, isnâ€™t there?â€ť jubilant trainer Brian Lynch said in the Gulfstream winnerâ€™s circle. â€śEspecially the way he finished today.â€ť
Clearly Now surged from mid-pack of the 11-horse field to take the lead in the lane, then draw away to a decisive length-and three-quarter margin, which was extending with every stride. In so doing, he remained perfect around one turn, winning for the third time in as many tries. But itâ€™s not as if he is without two-turn credentials. He finished third in Woodbineâ€™s Display, then came south to do the same in the Holy Bull. Granted, he was more than 13 lengths behind Itsmyluckyday and Shanghai Bobby. However, those two were breaking the course record and there were seven behind Clearly Now.
If Clearly Now does jump back on the Derby trail, it will almost certainly be in the Florida Derby on March 30, Lynch said. Itsmyluckyday and Shanghai Bobby and several other promising colts also are targeting Gulfstreamâ€™s premier event. â€śWherever you go, itâ€™s a gunfight,â€ť Lynch said.
While Lynch allowed himself a few moments to dream the dream, he quickly came back to earth. â€śThereâ€™s the points system (Clearly Now has none). Also, thereâ€™s the question of whether he wants to run that far. This might be an ideal distance for him and he might be a lovely miler on the turf.â€ť
About 1,200 miles up the coast in Aqueduct's Gotham, Vyjack continued to provide the correct answers to questions about his ability to handle a distance. Moreover, he showed a new dimension that encourages the notion that the son of Into Mischief will run as far as he has to and do it faster than those lined up against him.
In winning his first three starts at six furlongs, seven furlongs and a mile and 70 yards, Vyjack raced close to the pace. Joel Rosario, who replaced Cornelio Velazquez because of his ability to get horses to relax, did just that. Rosario allowed Vyjack to dawdle at the rear of the 11-horse field down the backstretch in the mile and a sixteenth stake. Going to the far turn Vyjack still had only three horses beaten but Rosario had put him into overdrive.
Rather than break their momentum, Rosario swung Vyjack five wide at the top of the stretch and he gobbled up foes like Pac Man. They hit the wire in 1:44.09 a drawing away 2 1/4 lengths in front.
West Hills Giant, a 33-1 shot whose only victories were in New York-bred races, held the place over maiden winner Elnaawi. However the margin and style of Vyjackâ€™s triumph left the impression that in this bunch there was him and then everyone else.
The Todd Pletcher Derby bandwagon, which had been seemingly running downhill since late last season, hit another pothole as Overanalyze, game winner of the Remsen in November, could do no better than fifth in his season debut. The Remsen is moving toward negative key race status, as runnerup Normandy Invasion also disappointed last Saturday at the Fair Grounds.
Overanalyze's failure comes on the heels of a potential career-ending injury to Violence in last weekâ€™s Fountain of Youth and an also-ran performance by Palace Malice in the Risen Star. With points, not money, the new criteria, Pletcherâ€™s once loaded barn of Derby contenders is in danger of running out of time and races to make the Derby cut.
With the cutoff estimated to be at about 40 points (no one knows since this is the first time), Team Pletcher is going to have to begin to step it up, starting next Saturday with Verrazano in the Tampa Bay Derby. As brilliant as he has been in two runaway wins, Verrazano has zero points. If he doesnâ€™t grab the 50 for first in Tampa, heâ€™ll be part of a mad scramble in the final phase of Derby preps, where circumstances might force Pletcher to run multiple entries, each in need of a win or second.
Saturday just wasnâ€™t Pletcherâ€™s day. His Forty Tales, sent away at even-money in the Swale, never really fired and wound up fifth, almost four lengths behind Clearly Now. The best that can be said of this from Pletcherâ€™s standpoint is that Forty Tales was never considered a Triple Crown contender.
The 50 points earned by Vyjack effectively puts him into the Derby starting gate. This affords his connections the luxury of picking his next stop. In the aftermath of the Gotham, they indicated it would be the Wood, which could wind up loaded. However Vyjackâ€™s people donâ€™t have to worry about wringing him out to win, possibly compromising his chances in Louisville.
Though the way he won the Gotham, Vyjack might not have to overextend himself to go into the Derby undefeated.
Written by Tom Jicha
Friday, March 01, 2013
Common sense is one-for-two
(UPDATE: The Breeders Cup announced its new policies hours after this column was published. Updates within.) The Breeders' Cup appears on the verge of backing off its edict that Lasix will not be allowed in any race during the 2013 renewal. This is a sensible example of discretion being the better part of valor. Prohibiting Lasix in the juvenile races last fall resulted in more than a 20 percent drop in entries for those races. A similar decline throughout the card would jeopardize Breeders' Cup. Unfortunately, common sense is an also ran in South Florida, where Gulfstream and Calder remain on a collision course that will have the two tracks racing head-to-head on weekends year round.
March 1, 2013
Common sense apparently is going to rule at the Breedersâ€™ Cup.
Alas, the same is not the case in South Florida.
The Breedersâ€™ Cup, at a meeting on Feb. 22, gave indications that it is considering backing away from its edict that Lasix will be banned throughout the card at this yearâ€™s renewal. The catalyst was what happened last year when the anti-bleeding medication was not allowed in the 2-year-old races. Entries were down more than 20 percent from the previous year and handle dropped correspondingly. (Update: the ban in 2YO races remains in effect. Older horses can continue to race with Lasix. Try explaining the logic of that in 50 words or less.)
Similar declines in the non-juvenile races this coming November would be catastrophic to the bottom line, already hurting from diminished stallion and nomination fees. Lesser fields also would detractâ€”or detract further--from the eventâ€™s status as a season-ending championship. When that goes, televisionâ€™s interest in covering the event will go into a freefall, too.
The Breedersâ€™ Cup intentions were noble, a pushback toward a return to the days of thoroughbreds racing on hay, oats and water, as they do in most of the racing worldâ€”at least theoretically. The thinking, or hope, was that If horses had to race â€ścleanâ€ť in the championship events, this policy would filter down to the rest of the season.
With few exceptions, this hasnâ€™t happened. Juveniles raced up to the Breedersâ€™ Cup on medication, got off it for the one race, then immediately got on it again. Or they just skipped the Breedersâ€™ Cup.
This figures to also be the case if the Breedersâ€™ Cup stands firm and enforces the Lasix ban on all races. (Update: Which is why they haven't.)
Horsemenâ€™s organizations across the nation have argued vehemently against the Breedersâ€™ Cup decree. Owners and trainers could make a solidarity statement by skipping this yearâ€™s Breedersâ€™ Cup. So whatâ€™s the point of endangering one of the best things to happen in racing during the past century in pursuit of an unattainable goal?
This isnâ€™t even an example of protecting the public. Lasix use is noted on the program and in past performance publications. Bettors learned to deal with it years ago. There were inexplicable form reversals when the medication first came into vogue but now that its use is commonplace, bordering on universal, itâ€™s a minor handicapping factor.
In fact, having horses who have been racing with Lasix their entire career come off it for one race is actually a diservice to fans. Besides, as every player knows, it isnâ€™t the medications on the program that produce form reversals.
Whether or not the Lasix ban is lifted there is likely going to be undeserving casualty, the Juvenile Sprint. (This has happened.)
If so, it will be an over-reaction made in haste. The Breedersâ€™ Cup is dismayed that the inaugural running last November produced only five starters. As a result, it generated the least handle of the 15 races. (Duh!)
To argue that this was a product of lack of interest on the part of horsemen is disingenuous. It can be traced almost entirely to the Lasix ban.
There is widespread consensus that there are too many â€śBreedersâ€™ Cupâ€ť races, and that this cheapens the ones that matter. However, a sprint for 2-year-olds makes far more sense than the Marathon. For every race in America at extended distances (anything beyond 10 furlongs on dirt), there are hundreds, if not thousands, of sprints for young horses. The Juvenile Sprint deserves at least one more chance to establish itself without the ban.
LUNACY IN SOUTH FLORIDA
: Getting back to South Florida, the deadline for amending dates requests for the year that starts July 1 came and went on Feb. 28 without Calder or Gulfstream blinking. As of now, this means the tracks will engage in a suicidal head-to-head confrontation on weekends starting in July.
Gulfstream initiated this conflict, its primary motivation being an attempt to save a dying mall on the racetrack grounds, which is a ghost town outside the racing season. This is a classic case of sending good money after bad. The mall is unsalvagable and South Florida racing has been put into jeopardy. There simply arenâ€™t enough horses or fans to support two tracks racing simultaneously.
Phil Combest, president of the Florida HBPA, was quoted in the Blood Horse saying, â€śThe idea of racing head to head is crazy and nobody will benefitâ€¦The future of Florida racing is at stake.â€ť
Although the tracks are now legally committed to racing the dates they requested, there is still hope that sanity can be restored. Loopholes in the law allow Calder and Gulfstream to re-petition the state if an agreement is reached in the coming months. The drawback is Gulfstream owner Frank Stronach, who is behind the dates grab. People who tell him things he doesnâ€™t want to hear have a tendency to get fired.
However, the Florida legislature meets in the spring and can come up with any remedy it so chooses to save the sport. To borrow a line from another business crisis, thoroughbred racing in Florida, a multi-billion dollar industry that employs tens of thousands, is too big to fail.
The idea that the state will allow it to fall into peril to save a doomed shopping mall is unthinkable.
An obvious solution is to have the state resume setting racing dates as it used to do until the 1980s. When the new way doesnâ€™t work, itâ€™s time to return to the old way.
Written by Tom Jicha
Friday, February 22, 2013
The Derby Winner: Aura and Majesty Forevermore
HRI BULLETIN: Gulfstream's Rainbow Pick 6 was hit Friday. The Pot o' Gold was worth $3,591,245.44.
There is still something magic about the winner of a Kentucky Derby.This was reiterated when the biggest non-Florida Derby Day crowd since Gulfstream was rebuilt came out to see Animal Kingdom on Donn Handicap Day. What a wonderful world it would be if more owners recognized what a Derby winner means to the sport and kept their horses in training through their 4-year-old seasons. OK, I'm a dreamer.
February 22, 2013
Allow me a John Lennon moment. Allow me to Imagine a world where Kentucky Derby winners arenâ€™t retired before their 3-year-old season is out.
The magic of a Derby winner was never more apparent than Donn Handicap Day at Gulfstream. The Donn might be the centerpiece race of the season for older horses but it became just an afterthought because Animal Kingdom was making his first start as a 5-year-old (and alas, last in the U.S.) in the Gulfstream Park Turf Cup.
What felt like the biggest non-Florida Derby Day crowd ever at the new facility (accurate attendance figures are impossible in the racino era) made it clear why they were there. It was to see a Kentucky Derby winner.
They were 10 deep around the spacious walking ring, lining up early to be sure to get a look at Animal Kingdom. They cheered as he circled the walking ring.
Gulfstream was savvy enough to have the field go around three times. There was a cacophony of cameras and camera phones clicking.
It was like the good old days when thoroughbred racing challenged the major team sports for attention. Believe it or not, there was a time when racing was bigger than the NFL.
Those who didnâ€™t get a spot near the walking ring packed the apron and cheered when Animal Kingdom took the track. In the opening flash, he was a ridiculous 1-9, although that moderated to 4-5 by post time. It didnâ€™t matter that Point of Entry, who wound up winning, had far stronger credentials.
Wouldnâ€™t it be great if more sportsmen owners recognized what a Derby winner means to the game and kept their horse in training, making a circuit of major races around the U.S. as a 4-year-old?
You may say I'm a dreamer but Iâ€™m not the only one.
As long as Iâ€™m dreamingâ€¦
The Kentucky Derby it needs to join the Breedersâ€™ Cup Classic as a prime-time TV attraction ASAP.
NBC would do it in a heartbeat. The Derby, which out-rates many prime-time shows and everything on Saturday night, falls during TVâ€™s May sweeps ratings period.
The Run for the Roses springs from the gate at about 6:40 now. Whatâ€™s another two hours? Most of the undercard would still be run in daylight and the first race wouldnâ€™t have to be run in the a.m. There is no better way to showcase racing than to present its biggest attraction before the largest possible audience, which is prime-time.
A remedy for running Day One of the Breedersâ€™ Cup on Friday, a workday for most, is to move the event to Thanksgiving weekend. Millions have the day off. Fans could cut a deal with their spouses. Shop your brains out. Iâ€™m going to the track.
There are only one or two significant football games to compete with on both Friday and Saturday, as opposed to countless big games the first Saturday in November.
As for the weather, Churchill Downs has run a big closing weekend for years over the Thanksgiving weekend without problems. If the NFL can stage what is destined to be dubbed the Stupid Bowl at the Meadowlands in February, racing in late fall shouldnâ€™t be an issue. Moreover, itâ€™s not an issue in warm weather sites, where most future Breedersâ€™ Cups are likely to land.
A final benefit would be that NYRA, Keeneland and Santa Anita wouldnâ€™t have to shoe horn dozens of big money stakes into the first and second weekends of their fall meetings. If thereâ€™s a downside, I canâ€™t see it.
Saratoga, the former â€śAugust place to beâ€ť should truly become â€śthe summer place to beâ€ť by running from July 4 to Labor Day.
As part of the package, the schedule could be trimmed-- as it should be anyway given the shortage of horses--to five days a week. Going a taxing six days a week, Saratoga runs 40 days now. A more vacation-like five-day agenda, from July 4 to Labor Day, would add only five dates.
North country hotels and restaurants, which would bitch to their representatives in nearby Albany about a reduction in the racing week, would probably drop their objections if they were compensated with a longer season.
South Florida racetracks need to get together to have the legislature abolish the antiquated 7 p.m. curfew for thoroughbred racing.
It was created decades ago at the behest of greyhound tracks and jai alai frontons to protect their monopoly on evening gambling. Today, the dogs and jai alai have become just an excuse to operate slots and card rooms. Indeed, the night time operations are trying to get the obligation to maintain pari-mutuels eliminated. Thanks to simulcasting, horse races provide more handle than the pups and cesta guys. They would undoubtedly welcome an opportunity to take action on quality horse racing.
Frank Stronach says he wants to put up lights at Gulfstream but has hesitated because of the curfew. Night racing could be a way to mitigate the potential conflict with Calder if Gulfstream goes ahead with its plan for summer racing.
Another Stronach idea, the original concept for the Sunshine Millions, didnâ€™t turn out as well as hoped because California-breds are no match for Florida-breds. The Sunshine State won all nine showdowns before the inter-state format was abandoned and transformed into each state running its own state-bred set of rich races.
How about a new competition between Florida-breds and New York-breds late in the year when there isnâ€™t much going on? Gamblers at both venues are familiar with the horses at the other and with slots money boosting purses for New York-breds, itâ€™s only a matter of time before the Big Apple herd can compete with any stateâ€™s horses.
Written by Tom Jicha