FINALLY!
The column could right there and everyone would know what I’m talking about. It would get picked up by all the horse racing wires. The shortest column in the history of the world sums up what racing writers have been typing about for years. I’ve read Randy Moss. I’ve read Indulto. I’ve even written about it myself. The long-awaited, much-anticipated, casually-lated, never-corrugated, neatly-collated, Derby points system. To loosely quote Anchorman's Brick Tamland, "I'd like to extend to you an invitation to the points pants party."
The new system from Yum!hill Downs selects 36 races that qualify for Derby Points, like Schrute Bucks. Thirty-six races, none of which are run under a mile. Perfect. Sorry, Trinniberg.
There are four phases. First late September which has a bevy of prestigious graded juvenile races—including the Breeders’ Cup Juvenile—to February will feature a 10-4-2-1 point system. These are the whoopity-do races. So sorry, Vale of York.
For the next phase of the waxing moon horses win 50-20-10-5 points. Now things heat up, races hold more weight. The Derby is still two months away, but you still need to show.
At last we reach that onslaught of Grade 1s three-to-four weeks out from the Derby. Here we see the Santa Anita Derby, the Wood Memorial, and Arkansas Derby. So sorry, Uncle Mo. 100-40-20-10.
Derby Trial horses who have the gall to think about running one week later in the Derby, get only 20-8-4-2. You’re window is tight, Hierro.
"People understand the Derby is the Super Bowl of racing, but they don't understand what the 'league' structure is and what the series is to get there," track president T. Kevin Flanery told the Louisville Courier-Journal. "We think this is a very easily understandable series and season that the fan can follow. … This is about the future. This is about how people will find their way to the Derby in 2013 and beyond. That's the exciting thing. People will have to make decisions about what the best path is."
The beauty of this is how it devalues the two-year-old races for placement in the gate on the first Saturday in May. What it says is that the Derby will not reward precocity. The money is there, but your Derby ticket won’t be punched. Winning the Breeders’ Cup Juvenile is now akin to finishing fourth in the Wood Memorial.
Jon Miller, president of programming for NBC sports, made a good point in the same Courier-Journal story, “"It builds the storylines, the matchups. Now you'll have these great horses who have already raced against each other before you get to Churchill Downs and the Preakness. You'll have the rivalries built in. Think of Tiger and Phil. Jimmie Johnson and Jeff Burton, Jeff Gordon."
Bodemeister may have faced I’ll Have Another in this scenario prior to the Derby. Imagine the drama unfolding this year had they had a history.
A real ballsy Theo Epstein-trade-Nomar-in-the-middle-of-the-season-move would have been to keep all qualifying to the United States, seeing as the Derby is our race. The UAE Derby, Royal Lodge Stakes and Grey Stakes will be included in the point system. It could also lead to a new game show: “Who Wants to Say No to Your an Arabian Prince!” Hosted, of course, by Regis Philbin. At least the point system essentially renders the $2 million purse of the March-run UAE Derby moot for horses looking to run in the Derby on grade earnings alone. I think the fifth place horse in that race could qualify on earnings alone under the old system.
The committee made a surprising move with regards to the Illinois Derby. 2002 Derby winner War Emblem came out it. I know it was ten years ago, but as recent as 2006 the Illinois Derby winner was the favorite in the Kentucky Derby, that being Sweetnorthernsaint. Without that graded money to pick from, contenders will have to be nominated to several stakes races across the country in order to find a spot to race for points. The pool will be much more competitive and what will the standards be to get into all the 14-horse gates across the country for what will likely be an overflow of entrants? Do the points apply to that too? We’ll see.
The Illinois Derby will all-but lose high-quality three year olds and be nothing but a moderately-rich graded race (though likely not for long now) for mediocre horses running for owners lucky enough to have a horse just bad enough to collect a big check. Oh, well.
There will be time to evaluate the long-term ramifications of this new system, where its deficiencies lie and so forth. But what horse racing has done for its premier race is nothing short of a watershed moment and should be celebrated accordingly.
Brendan O'Meara is the author of Six Weeks in Saratoga.



15 Jun 2012 at 07:51 am | #
It wasn’t broken to start with and this system is a mess. Their race, their rules, but this isn’t going to make anything better.
15 Jun 2012 at 08:00 am | #
Oh, yeah, what a mess, getting the best horses to run in the best traditional preps, instead of playing “ducking for dollars.” It must be a good idea, B, trainers are complaining already.
Schrute Bucks? I learned something today.
15 Jun 2012 at 08:10 am | #
Great traditional preps like the ungraded Smarty Jones, which by the way is valued equal to the BC Juvie? Now that’s tradition. Finishing 4th in the UAE Derby is equal to winning the Champagne. Now that’s tradition. Winning the Lexington (on synth...) is worth winning the Champagne and BC Juvie combined. Next thing you know someone will start writing about how we should put the TC races on holidays when people are sure to be doing something else....
15 Jun 2012 at 08:56 am | #
Perhaps I should have addressed it better, but the point system is about bringing understanding to the process. Call it “dumbing down the language”, if you will. The original story cited that the vast majority of fans don’t know the criteria for qualifying Derby horses. Graded earnings means nothing. Points hold water to a playoff-hungry sports fans.
If this sport wants to keep 40,000 people happy at the expense of bringing in a million more, then the old system was perfect. At least this new system gives horse racing a chance, even it is at the expense of the Illinois Derby’s “prestige”.
15 Jun 2012 at 09:05 am | #
I agree Brendan that a point system would be able to simplyfy things, but this is a 3 tier plus system that puts the same value on a very prestigious (and televised) race like the BC Juvie and a very recent addition to the long list of ungraded stakes that very few will ever see in the Smarty Jones. It’s too complex. If you want a point system people can actually follow, just have grade 1s worth certain points, grade 2s less, grade 3s less than that. Restict it to 2 turn routes on dirt if you have to, which means sorry Keeneland and UAE Derby, but then those race have been less relevant than the Illinois Derby with the intro of synth.
15 Jun 2012 at 09:53 am | #
What do Sea Hero, Charismatic, War Emblem and Mine That Bird all have in common?
15 Jun 2012 at 10:07 am | #
And Giacomo?
15 Jun 2012 at 10:18 am | #
Who is to say that under the new rules, Sea Hero, Charismatic, War Emblem, Mine That Bird--and Giacomo, too--would not have latered their prep schedule and made the cut anyway?
Revisionist history as an example doesn’t work. This will require new thinking and horsemen will no longer be capable of sitting on the sidalines and plan a two-prep campaign because they won the Delta Jackpot.
People like to knock the Breeders’ Cup for cheapening the traditional races of fall. Analagously, what wrong with making races such as the SA Derby, Arkansas Derby, Wood and Blue Grass the best they can be, too?
That’s when the casual fan, via network TV, really starts paying attention. New fans--if racing is still capable of attracting new fans using the same old, same old--have to come from somewhere.
15 Jun 2012 at 10:22 am | #
What’s up B,
WE’RE HAVIN’ A POINTS PARTY? This is way better than the money system which made races like the Delta Jackpot a win and your in. A playoff system where the stakes get higher and higher leading up to the traditional biggies the Fla, Santa Anita, Arkansas Derbies, Wood and Bluegrass. This will create more fan interest and horse recognition leading up to the Triple Crown.
Who knew that Indulto the after-life horse warrior, would bcome the John Hancock of the Derby qualifying constitution.
Got to give a shout out to the Stony Brook Seawolves from LI,NY. who made it through the playoffs to the College Baseball World Series.
GO SEAWOLVES!!!!!
We’re havin’ a party
Everybody’s swinging
Dancing to the music
On the radio
So listen, Mr. DJ
Keep those records playing
‘Cause I’m having such a good time
Dancing with my baby…
15 Jun 2012 at 10:35 am | #
Let’s say for argument’s sake a nice colt in NY comes along and wins the Saratoga Special, Hopeful, Champagne and BC Juvie. He is voted 2yo of the year by a landslide. He suffers a minor injury when he goes back in training, but is finally in great shape to run in the Wood. In the Wood he gets slammed at the break, the jock loses his irons, but then he makes a tremendous run to get up to 5th in a near blanket finish. The cut of for points is 22, he has 20. Oops, the 2yo champ doesn’t make the field so he has to wait til the Preakness where he wins in a laugher. Then we start wondering what could have been. Some stretching, sure, but not impossible.
15 Jun 2012 at 11:12 am | #
Big OTM AL,
Below are all the 2yr old champs since Spectacular Bid 1978. How many won the derby?
2011 Hansen Mike Maker K. Hansen/Sky Chai Racing
2010 Uncle Mo Todd Pletcher Mike Repole
2009 Lookin at Lucky Bob Baffert Mike Pegram/Karl Watson/Paul Weitman
2008 Midshipman Saeed bin Suroor Godolphin Racing
2007 War Pass Nicholas P. Zito Robert V. LaPenta
2006 Street Sense Carl Nafzger James B. Tafel
2005 Stevie Wonderboy Douglas F. O’Neill Merv Griffin
2004 Declan’s Moon Ronald W. Ellis Jay Em Ess Stables
2003 Action This Day Richard E. Mandella B. Wayne Hughes
2002 Vindication Bob Baffert Padua Stables
2001 Johannesburg Aidan O’Brien Michael Tabor & Sue Magnier
2000 Macho Uno Joe Orseno Stronach Stables
1999 Anees Alex L. Hassinger, Jr. The Thoroughbred Corp.
1998 Answer Lively Bobby C. Barnett John A. Franks
1997 Favorite Trick Patrick B. Byrne Joseph LaCombe
1996 Boston Harbor D. Wayne Lukas Overbrook Farm
1995 Maria’s Mon Richard E. Schosberg Mrs. Morton Rosenthal
1994 Timber Country D. Wayne Lukas Gainesway Stable, et al.
1993 Dehere Reynaldo Nobles Due Process Stable
1992 Gilded Time Darrell Vienna David Milch, Jack & Mark Silverman
1991 Arazi Francois Boutin Allen E. Paulson & Sheikh Mohammed
1990 Fly So Free Flint S. Schulhofer Tommy & Elizabeth Valando
1989 Rhythm Claude R. McGaughey III Ogden Mills Phipps
1988 Easy Goer Claude R. McGaughey III Ogden Phipps
1987 Forty Niner Woody Stephens Claiborne Farm
1986 Capote D. Wayne Lukas Beal, French, Jr. & Klein
1985 Tasso Neil D. Drysdale Gerald Robins
1984 Chief’s Crown Roger Laurin Star Crown Stable
1983 Devil’s Bag Woody Stephens Hickory Tree Stable
1982 Roving Boy Joseph Manzi Robert E. Hibbert
1981 Deputy Minister Bill Marko Centurion Stables & Kinghaven Farms
1980 Lord Avie Daniel Perlsweig SKS Stable
1979 Rockhill Native
15 Jun 2012 at 11:14 am | #
Well then, let’s just ban 2yo racing then as clearly it has no meaning.
15 Jun 2012 at 11:25 am | #
What I cite is history. What you want to engage in is revision and hypotheticals. Maybe Lukas could have run Charismatic a week ealier in the Blue Grass; maybe Mack Miller could have prepared Sea hero differently, maybe if Giacomo knew he needed to run 2nd or 3rd in The Santa Anita Derby...but...horses are not machines. Sometimes they are just ready when they are ready. The facts are, some if not all those Derby winners would have been excluded under this system. I’m not even really knocking it. Just stating the facts.
15 Jun 2012 at 11:32 am | #
BTW, 7 of the 11 TC winners were 2yo champs. Sorry, but I have to be against any system that could potentially exclude a 2yo champ from the Derby.
15 Jun 2012 at 11:49 am | #
Big Al,
All of the TC winners were in the no lasix era. Also in the classic distance stamina breeding era. Since they started breeding for speed and using lasix, the game changed for the worse.
BTW...In all other sports, it’s not how you start the season, but how you FINISH. Playoffs create excitement building to a championship. But to each his own.
15 Jun 2012 at 11:55 am | #
Actually they were in eras of much smaller foal crops where the probability of a single outlier is greater. Foal crops are shrinking now toward 70s levels. I firmly believe this has much more to do with it than the all to commonly repeated reasons you cite and that we will see a TC winner very soon because of it.
And also in all other sports a win counts the same whether it is the first game of the season or the last, so that is a bad analogy.
15 Jun 2012 at 02:32 pm | #
Cat,
Who didn’t know that JP is the combined Ben Franklin, Thomas Paine, AND Paul Revere of points-based Derby eligibility.
15 Jun 2012 at 03:44 pm | #
I,
Always thought Preach was more the Samuel Adams type. Which reminds me...it’s Friday happy hour!
15 Jun 2012 at 07:20 pm | #
Thanks for the credit, boys, but I really don’t deserve accolades for being the first. Actually, the first time I saw a reference to points-based/ graded-stakes corollary was penned by Steven Crist. Just can’t remember if it was writtend in DRF or the Racing Times. My best guess is the latter.
15 Jun 2012 at 07:23 pm | #
This is a record amount of comments for 2.0. A milestone! Bravo, fellas, bravo! Spirited, yet classy discourse. I salute you!
I’m so fired up, I think I’ll go watch “Gladiator”.