Since horse sales are all the rage these days, I figure now’s as good a time as any to talk about a new one. That’s right, a new horse sale. Right here. Right here in Saratoga Springs.
On Oct. 9, Fasig-Tipton, those gavel swinging, horse toting Rasputin’s plan to host another: this one a mixed sale. The demand is brought on by the influx of ting-a-ling, 7-7-7, cherry-cherry-cherry money.
Their catalog calls for 254 horses—104 weanlings, 44 horses of racing age and 103 in-foal mares. That doesn’t add up to 254, but that’s what Fasig-Tipton says.
This drives to the center of what video lottery terminal money does. With incentive programs and performance-enhanced purses, many more horses come with New York state-bred credentials.
“The feed-back we were getting through the early summer was that the significant funding strides made to the New York-Bred program had created a need for this sale,” said Fasig-Tipton president Boyd Browning on F-T’s website. “After discussions with New York’s major commercial breeders and with Jeff Cannizzo, executive director of New York Thoroughbred Breeders, we found an ideal time slot in October to add this sale to the calendar.”
McMahon of Saratoga has 40 horses up for sale. They famously bred 2003 Kentucky Derby and Preakness winner Funny Cide. Trainer Kiaran McLauglin is consigning 17 and Tom Albertrani nine. Vinery Sales put 41 head of horses. There's an A.P. Indy broodmare and two A.P. Indy's of racing age.
This sale makes it hard to argue that VLT revenue isn’t helping the breeders. At least on this level the local breeders benefit.
What can be made of this? Since more horses are up for sale with the state-bred condition, fields should be larger. That is if more days are not added to Saratoga’s already-too long meet. They’re killing the goose. No matter how high you reach up into the alimentary canal of a common migratory bird, you’re only getting dirtier, not to mention turning into a wicked creeper.
The bigger fields are the reward for the horse player. Small pennies, yes, but at least it gives the player a chance to exercise skill that 4 and 5-horse fields don’t allow. Bigger fields won’t make trainers happy. What do they care? Flashing finished second in the Grade 1 Mother Goose in 2009. That’s the beauty of a 3-horse field. The trainer gets his bank. But you-know-who gets to single a 1-20. Yippee.
The rub with extra horses is further watering down of the product.
This is great news for breeders and who can blame them for being able to sell horses in October in Upstate New York? But we’ve seen what racing can be at Saratoga: at times brilliant with its maiden special weights, grass, and grade 1s.
Some people love the nags, but lets hope it leads to more populous races instead of populous race cards.


18 Sep 2012 at 06:30 pm | #
Speaking of small fields, the card for Parx’s big day on Saturday just came out. The $1,000,000 Fitz-Cotillion for 3 year old fillies drew a field of four, with Questing and My Miss Aurelia presumably scaring away the competition.
The conditions are as follows: “By subscription of $250 each if made on or before Saturday, July 7, 2012 or $1,000 if made on or before Monday, September 3, 2012, $2,000 to pass the entry box, $3,000 additional to start, with $1,000,000 guaranteed. The purse to be distributed: $10,000 to all starters with the balance of the purse to be divided: 60% to the winner, 20% to second, 11% to third, 6% to fourth, and 3% to fifth.”
If someone had the foresight to expect a small field, which is not at all unreasonable these days, they could have entered their run-of-the-mill 3 yr old filly for $250 bones, and then paid the $5,000 entry fee, and be guaranteed the $10,000 for each starter pay out and the $30,000 5th place share - just for sending her out for a stroll. And if some other filly in the race scratches or comes up lame or Big Browns it at the top of the strech, they could ring the cash register some more.
How is this possible? I want to get in the business of keeping a stable of sound “stand-in” horses to enter in these $500k+ grade ones and twos. All you need are condition books, an F350 with a horse trailer, a lack of gamesmanship and pride, and the mentality of the guy who mailed in millions of pudding lids for a lifetime of frequent flyer miles. These opportunities seem to be popping up more and more. Who’s with me?!
18 Sep 2012 at 08:20 pm | #
Lover, I once started a horse at Parx this year and was paid for finishing sixth. It was a paltry amount but it was something, anyway.
B, sure hope Wendell doesn’t find out about this; He’s going to hammer you, me, Indulto, all turf writers (except Steven Crist, of course) and the industry at large. I’m just sayin’.
18 Sep 2012 at 08:33 pm | #
#1: Yet another example of how casino dole is being wasted. Won’t be long before the Pennsylvania politicians cut Parx’s percentage that is received from the casinos yet again.
When compared to the management of racetracks, even I appear relatively sane.
18 Sep 2012 at 09:05 pm | #
B ---- Great time to be an owner/trainer in NY.
lova --- lova your idea - wish I had the $$$
corrow—gonna have a field day with this and it’s even at his favorite track.
Parx at least got a field of 8 for the Penn Derby.
There’s a Pick 4 with four stakes too (good size fields in 3 of 4 legs). Pick your single for the Cotillion.
That casino money must be flowing good down there, the second race is for two year old maidens and has a purse of 90k!
18 Sep 2012 at 09:35 pm | #
It’s easy to blame the government, NYRA, the industry, track management, NYRA, slots, Magna, NYRA, NBC, NYRA and NYRA when situations like the white guy after a swim in Lake Ontario size field assembling for the Fitz-Cotillion arises.
But where are the so-called small, local, “backbone of the industry” trainers in this race? I don’t see any of the normal excuses applying here. Parx is as central a location as you can get for blue collar tracks and trainers. Folks from PEN, FL, MTH, CT, LRL, PIM, BEU, PID, DEL, and yes, even SUF!!!! can easily ship their horse into Parx the morning of the race. Are they too pride filled to enter their horse to shoot for fourth? Would they rather sit back and watch Questing romp and complain about how if they had a Sheik in their corner it would be them in the winners circle every other weekend and not KMac?
Horse racing can be brutal and unfair. But Parx is going out of their way to throw some money back to the guys who make horse racing horce racing. Unfortunately none of those guys will be in the starting gate on Saturday. And in a rarity for horse racing, on this day, in this instance, they have no one to blame but themselves.
18 Sep 2012 at 11:16 pm | #
#5: It would apparently cost a local owner $6,000 to enter a plodder in the stake race. It can readily be assumed that several stake horses from around the country will be entered, thus the reluctance of the local owners to enter a nag.
Parx is not going out of their way to throw money back to the local owners, trainers, and jockeys; if they were, the stake race, or numerous other races, could have conditions written so that only owners who provide horses for the entire meet qualify.
Parx management is simply trying to be ‘big man on campus’ for one day, using money not earned but received as a gift for the purse. Be assured that all executive pension payments have been made, and the pension is up-to-date, before any checks are written for the stake race.
You want an example of slot machine money being tossed around as if it were candy, check out the purses of the stake races on West Virginia Derby day at Mountaineer.
18 Sep 2012 at 11:40 pm | #
WMC,
The conditions state that it is only $250 to nominate, with the $2k coming to enter and the $3k to start - all of which is mitigated by the $10k that all starters receive in the end anyway, regardless of how many horses enter. I may be reading this incorrectly, but that’s how I understand it.
So outside of travel costs and any potential psychological damage that could be done to your nag by having Questing crush her spirit, Parx, on this particular day for this particular race, is paying trainers and owners to simply run their horse. I’m with you on management being Romneyish the rest of the year, but here’s a spot where, despite their best efforts, a track is actually offering a win-win situation to their rank and file trainers and owners.
19 Sep 2012 at 12:30 am | #
Digging the convo today, fellow Carryoverians!
We’ll see where all this leads. I think we all know: to a dark, dark place PA coal miners wouldn’t waste a canary on.
19 Sep 2012 at 02:41 pm | #
Hey Lova,
One reason for not “cashing” in on a $4.5K payday in a such a race is the prospect of forfeiting entering your horse in a race it has a legitimate chance to win--which is a $20K+ pay day for the owner, and a 10% payday for the trainer. Sorry, but the Cotillion doesn’t have the cache of a TC race, and the long shot of getting black type does not outweigh the need for us small guys to pay the bills.
eric s.
19 Sep 2012 at 02:45 pm | #
Mr. B.
I received the catalog (unsolicited) in the mail yesterday, and had to chuckle at seeing all the Bernardini’s that Darley is trying to unload. Given their reputed acumen in evaluating horseflesh, not sure why one would give them stable tip money for their rejects:)
eric s.