ELMONT, NY, MAY 1, 2011--For a group that held such promise as juveniles, it’s all become unraveled. Still, no one knows how anything will turn out on Saturday and beyond--all the way to the Breeders’ Cup.
This class has been so snake-bitten that even the fillies have gotten into the act. R. Heat Lightning, who will now miss Friday’s Kentucky Oaks due to a knee issue, can beat half the horses running on Saturday, maybe more. Hope she resurfaces at one hundred percent.
So, almost all the important work has been done--only Master of Hounds possibly notwithstanding--and now all must have another good five days until Saturday. Then, of course, there’s a little matter of the weather, the wildcard when handicapping any horse race, especially this one.
The long range forecast for the Louisville area is chance of showers on Thursday night, chance of showers for Friday--both chances are 4-1 shots according to weatherforyou.com--and the promise is partly cloudy for Saturday.
Remember, too, that virtually no track plays as fairly as Churchill Downs does when it’s wet, and Butch Lehr has a well deserved reputation for getting a surface to dry out in virtually no time flat.
As if there weren’t enough questions surrounding Derby 137 already. All that’s left now is Wednesday’s post position draw--is there a really good reason it has to be held as late as 5 P.M.?--which is always significant given the 20 entrants.
Wonder what would happen if Midnight Interlude ever drew the rail?
A look at HRI’s Derby Power 10, Week 12 edition:
1. Dialed In (36) For the Derby’s tenuous divisional leader who sports one timed workout in the five weeks since he won the Florida Derby, it’s only gaining familiar with the surface that remains. That and 19 rivals.
2. Uncle Mo (27) Depending on the answer to one question yields how highly one rates his chances for victory. Can he replicate his Juvenile performance over the same track on which it was made. If not, he has very little chance; if so, his rivals have very little chance.
3. Archarcharch (22) Extremely versatile in terms of running style, his consistency, toughness and incremental improvement gives the Arkansas Derby hero a big chance to smell the roses. Seems to handle Churchill and energy level remains high.
4. Nehro (19) Bandwagon horse thanks to his last two starts, troubled trips and flying finishes, especially his Arkansas Derby. With three races closely spaced, interesting to see how he handles Derby stress.
5. Mucho Macho Man (16) Coming in six weeks fresh, an historical no-no, but has been training up a storm with old school style. Said it last week and it’s worth repeating: He’s more honest than Abe Lincoln.
6. Toby’s Corner (15) Had his final purposeful work at his home base in Fair Hill and comes in very under the radar despite winning the high profile Wood Memorial. Training having great season and jockey may be getting very close to breaking through.
7. Soldat (12) Worked his way back into the Derby picture with two strong workouts at his Palm Meadows base. It’s almost certain he will run back to his Fountain of Youth, not his Florida Derby, but will it ultimately be enough to matter?
8. Midnight Interlude (9) Historical profile works against him but not his Herculean Santa Anita Derby score. After one disappointing trial, his second work at Churchill Downs was more like it. But he’s still a tough read.
9. Pants On Fire (8) Louisiana Derby winner is consistent, courageous and fast working. Another not flattered by historical trends but the karma is good with regular rider Rosie Napravnik, the first female to win the Fair Grounds riding title.
10. Master Of Hounds (5) His pedigree indicates that he will run as far as they write races, he’s shown quality in classy competition and hails from world class connections. But this race is difficult enough without having to transition to dirt.


03 May 2011 at 06:30 am | #
I made my Derby pick almost a month ago: Stay Thirsty....flying under the radar..loved his work the other day with Mo,Mike thought his work was an A+..watch the work again,when Mo comes up to him he pins his ears down and says to him, not today..this guy is ready to run a big one...he has been training with the ((best) one for a long time now,and I think he finally decided enough is enough not gonna take your s*** anymore....hope I am right because I have a nice future bet on him..I will be at CD on Wed & Thursday talking to people and gathering info for this week end…
good luck to everybody.......
03 May 2011 at 06:37 am | #
Russ, trust me, you can do too much research in this game. “Study long, study wronjg, the saying goes. Stick to your guns and take the horse you like for whatever reason. It’s the Derby and anything goes--and you’re right about ST’s last workout.
Have a safe and speedy journey..
JP
03 May 2011 at 07:49 am | #
JRP,
It is indeed a shame R Heat Lightning is injured and out.
Hmmmm...Eskendereya, the probable heavy Derby favorite last year. R Heat Lightning, probable heavy Oaks favorite this year.....
Does this mean Pletcher DOESN’T beat Baffert on the conditioning factor?
03 May 2011 at 08:32 am | #
Stupidity, Duplicity or simply an Agent Provacatuer?
JRP,
It is indeed a shame Jaycito and The Factor are out.
Hmmmm...Jaycito and The Factor, one time Derby favorite this year......
How could anyone with reasonable intelligence opine that this would have anything to do with which trainer was a superior conditioner of horse flesh?
TTT
03 May 2011 at 08:37 am | #
TTT,
“Methinks thou doth protest too much.”
signed,
Bill S.
03 May 2011 at 08:53 am | #
Some prefer the training methods of “Burn ‘em up Before Breakfst Bobby,” and others prefer the training methods of “Perfect Practice Pletcher.” To each his own. Two legendary trainers in the game.
If you believe something to be true, it is worth saying a hundred times: “In the morn, slow steady and long, and in the afternoon you won’t go wrong.”
“Pletcher beats Baffert on the conditioning factor.”
Got to believe we are whipping a dead quarter horse here, and boring the hell out of the good patrons of Horse Race Insider, but I’m game, I’ve got nothing but time.
TTT
03 May 2011 at 09:10 am | #
TTT,
One thing’s for sure. If you’ve been betting Pletcher horses in the Kentucky Derby you sure have more time than money.
signed,
Pittsburgh Phil
03 May 2011 at 09:24 am | #
Don’t bet on trainers, I bet based on the barometric pressure at sea level, of course, a method I learned from “Track Facts.”
signed,
Diamond Jim Brady
03 May 2011 at 09:39 am | #
TTT,
That last post was your best in weeks. Two thumbs up.
signed,
Gene Siskel
03 May 2011 at 09:55 am | #
Always nice to get compliments, especially from persons who carry so much weight in this game.
signed,
Jenny Craig
03 May 2011 at 12:48 pm | #
TTT,
THAT was funny!! Not very nice, but funny.
03 May 2011 at 12:56 pm | #
Wow, Goer. Just arrived back at the Spa from Long Island only to read your post. Too bad. I like that horse; was definitely using him, albeit in a exotic saver role. Damn tough game.
T,
Another line from you recalling Red Sox fan in Yankees Avis commercial: “Wicked cold, guys, wicked cold.”
Meanwhile, I’ll say this and only this about Baffert and Pletcher: When I bet one of their horses, everything else being equal, I do so with a lot of confidence. I’m pretty sure that’s all any of us can reasonably expect.
JP
03 May 2011 at 04:08 pm | #
Gary,
I thought it was funny also.
Not as funny as, ““Pletcher beats Baffert on the conditioning factor,” but still, pretty funny.