ELMONT, NY, June 6, 2011--Interesting piece penned by Steven Crist recently on how under the right circumstances the Belmont Stakes winner that also won another leg of the Triple Crown series often has emerged with a divisional Eclipse Award at year’s end.
History certainly has proven to be on the side of a would-be champion that was a Double Crown winner. In the last 15 years, 10 3-year-olds won two legs in the series and every one was named divisional champion. since the inception of Eclipse Awards, 21 of 23 Double Crown winners was voted 3-year-old champion.
The two non-Double Crown winners performed extraordinary feats to snatch the title away from the division’s leaders. In 1972, Key to the Mint won the Travers and beat his elders thrice, taking the Brooklyn, Whitney and Woodward.
Twenty-two years later, Holy Bull finished his season with victories in the Met Mile, Dwyer, Haskell, Travers and Woodward, giving him two victories over older horses. Interesting, too, these colts had the Midsummer Derby in common.
Not only does Eclipse history favor winners of the Double Crown but this season there are two colts that might have the talent to win the remainder of the championship tests. In doing so, however, they could beat each other in the process thereby negating their own chances.
Two nine furlong winners; Wood victor Toby’s Corner, and Peter Pan hero Alternation, might catch up to the group if their returns show any semblance of the talent they demonstrated before going on hiatus; the former because of injury, the latter by design.
With these interesting possibilities in mind, a look at the HRI Power 10, Week 16 edition, per usual an amalgam of achievement and promise.
1. Animal Kingdom - Got a taste of Big Sandy over the weekend, including a purposeful workout Monday morning. His half mile in :47 4/5, out 5 furlongs in a minute, with a double gallop out in 1:14 1/5 had everyone smiling. A little unlucky not to be going for the whole enchilada four days from today.
2. Shackleford - One of those rare throwbacks that not only demonstrates uncommon courage but actually seems to thrive on work. Will be dangerous on or just off the Belmont pace. "He galloped great this morning," said Dale Romans Monday morning.
3. Nehro - Could be the second choice on Saturday if the wise guys have their say. He never has failed to improve his figures on the Equiform scale his entire career. Will that trend continue? "He worked an easy half in :50 1/5," said assistant trainer Toby Sheets outside barn 58. "He got loose and galloped out good, excellent."
4. Dialed In - If the past is prologue, Mr. Zito will gladly accept a Midsummer Summer as a healing salve for a Derby disappointment. One of the few trainers that would have little problem using a million-dollar race as a Travers prep.
5. Mucho Macho Man - New shoes and a new rider for Saturday and that combination sure looked good in Sunday’s work. But we’re dubious about whether he can maintain the energy level needed for Saturday’s test.
6. Toby’s Corner - Eddie Castro and agent Mike Gonzalez were trackside Sunday morning awaiting a glimpse of Animal Kingdom. Castro believes that if Toby was healthy on May’s first Saturday, Motion would have finished 1-2. He did not delineate between the exacta and quinella.
7. Astrology - As mentioned in Week 15, made a game surge to finish third at Pimlico and is pointing to the Haskell and Travers. Might have something to say about the title depending the results of those two races and, of course, Saturday’s classic.
8. Uncle Mo - We now know what the health issue was. It is a serious one and remains a concern. The good news is that he’s responding to treatment. There’s no timetable for his return but the connections are hoping August 1.
9. Alternation - Now on R & R following a relatively hectic early season, he put it together in the Peter Pan, outrunning the talented Adios Charlie late. Connections have the Travers in their sights, most likely via the Jim Dandy.
10. Master of Hounds - Coolmore is having a terrific spring across the pond. Colt has been doing a lot of traveling but he gets plenty from his down time at home. Saturday’s classic has been circled on the calendar for some time.


07 Jun 2011 at 07:32 am | #
Preach,
Nice follow up to the Crist piece which I also read. Not to take anything away from what Holy Bull did which was fantastic, but IMHO Tabasco Cat was ROBBED of the Eclipse award and Jeff Lukas deserved better.
Not only did Tabasco Cat win 2/3 of the Triple Crown beating the Ky. Derby winner Go For Gin in the Preakness and Belmont, he came within a neck of winning the Breeders Cup Classic and BTW finshed ahead of Holy Bull in the Derby. Yes Holy Bull beat the Cat in the Travers but the Cat might have been worse for the wear after the grueling Triple Crown.
The bigger story and what Tabasco Cat will be remembered for those who don’t know is the human element involved. TRAGICALLY before his 3 yr old campaigne Tabasco Cat got loose from his stall and as Jeff Lukas tried to coral him, ran Jeff over.
Jeff Lukas’s horse training career was all but ended that day even though he courageously tried to comeback from a severe head injury. More importantly his marriage was ended as well. Today he lives a normal persons life in a small town away from the fanfare of horse racing.
Jeff’s father Wayne said at a dinner honoring his son that he felt prouder of him than any racing accomplishment.
If not for the Tabasco Cat incident Jeff Lukas could very well have gone on his own and been one of if not the best trainer ever, just ask Todd Pletcher and Kieran Mcloughlin his students about it.
If the Triple Crown is the biggest thing in horse racing, then the emphasis for results in the series should be applied to the divisional Eclipse award.
Thoughts anyone?
07 Jun 2011 at 09:44 am | #
It’s hard to believe it’s been 17 years since Jeff’s injury.
Another part of the story for those who don’t know it was Wayne’s reaction. Instead of getting rid of the horse he took direct control of Tabasco Cat and turned him into a premier three-year-old.
It’s one of the under-reported stories in the recent history of Thoroughbred racing. I wonder how many remember?
07 Jun 2011 at 04:21 pm | #
Wayne Lukas, like Burling Cocks back in the day, was a trainer of trainers; Pletcher, McLaughlin and many others, of course. But when it was Wayne’s turn to dominate, he always sent Jeff with the first division, and it had nothing to do with nepotism. Jeff was a superior horseman, developing many of his father’s young champions. And he was a good guy, too. Thanks for bringing that up, Cat.
You’re right, Nick. It was business and personal for Wayne and the colt. Can’t imagine what that must have been like going to the barn every morning in the immediate aftermath.
Goer, it’s interesting that Hounds has gotten more support than I would ordinarily expect.
07 Jun 2011 at 05:26 pm | #
Don’t see what is so difficult to understand that D. Wayne took over the colt; what did you expect the guy to do, take him somewhere and torture him? You don’t give horsemen enough respect as humanitarian’s; they are not butchers, not the ones I’ve met and dealt with. D. Wayne would probably be the first to tell you he wants no medal for doing the right thing. They know the risks involved in this game; a colt with a temper is always a danger, even if you don’t turn your back on them, some will bite your ear off just as soon as look as you, just as Top Turf Teddy would. God bless Tabasco Cat and Jeff Lukas.
TTT