Friday, February 22, 2008

David Carroll’s Patience Paying Off for Kentucky Derby Hopeful

SARATOGA SPRINGS, NY, Feb. 21, 2008--If you like what youve seen from the undefeated Kentucky Derby prospect Denis Of Cork so far, my best advice would be to wait a little longer. You might only have seen the tip of this leggy, long-bodied, athletic iceberg of a racehorse.

Its not as if the colt didnt show ability from the start. He did, but there were issues that needed attention before his 48-year-old Irish-bred trainer, David Carroll, had him where he wanted him. Carroll knows how to get the best from a good horse. Working six years for Hall of Fame trainer Shug McGaughey, Carroll was the regular exercise rider of Easy Goer among other Phipps family notables.

Denis Of Cork is a Florida-bred son of Harlans Holiday, from the Unbridled mare, Unbridled Girl, and was a $250,000 two-year-old purchase by Mr. and Mrs. William Warren last March. But Denis emerged from the breeze-up sale with bucked shins, a common two-year-old ailment that responds best to time, and thats what Carroll gave him.

Not only did he take a long time to come around but our [Churchill] barn was under quarantine after one of our horses came out of Keeneland sick, said Carroll. We were shut down but that probably didnt matter. We wouldnt have run [Denis] any sooner, anyway.

When Carroll began preparing the colt, he worked him in company with an established stablemate, Blackberry Road, and Denis more than held his own. Finally, the colt was ready and Denis debuted on the final Saturday of the Churchill meet. He won that 7-furlong debut in dramatically impressive fashion.

Yes, I was surprised by his performance. Im not the kind that has to win first time out. I told Calvin [Borel] just let him break, settle, and then finish up with him.

But when I saw him make that [5-path sweeping] move on the turn, I thought he was going to run big. He really got to running and was very impressive. Ian [Wilkes, assistant to Carl Nafzger] came up to me afterwards and said he was surprised, too.

When Churchill closed, Carroll shipped his horses to Fair Grounds, a surface the trainer holds in high regard, but Denis had lost his way, the trainer said. He took a while to settle in and I had to give him time to regroup. Fortunately, Mr. Warren is very patient, always wants to do whats best for the horse.

Finally, after five weeks, the colt began to pick his head up, was doing well, but not as good as immediately before the debut. So, while not at the very top of his game, he made a second start, his first around two turns, in an allowance race on a sloppy track.

He never trained well on an off track, Carroll said. Calvin later said he was slippin and slidin all over the place during the warmup. Before the race I told Calvin just keep him out of trouble, keep him in a rhythm.

Borel kept Denis out of trouble, way out in the middle of the Fair Grounds backstretch. But in order to get first run, Borel moved sooner than he wanted, and the colt struggled even more, but they won anyway. Throw this race out, Borel told Carroll.

He wasnt even blowing when he came back, Carroll explained. It was like he was saying Ill do next time what I didnt do today. And he came out of the race a monster, ready to move forward.

Borel couldnt commit to Denis Of Cork for his next start, the Southwest Stakes. But Robby Albarado came to the barn, worked the colt, and Carroll did the Cajun two-step, replacing Borel with Albarado for Mondays Grade 3. Denis Of Cork might have been 2-for-2 but had no graded earnings, commonly needed to enter the Derby starting gate.

Denis was ready to run, but was he ready to ship again, to a new track and a new surface? He slept well, ate well, settled into his surroundings and I thought hes growing up right in front of my eyes, Carroll said.

Our game plan was simple, I told Robby it looked like there was a lot of speed so just settle and get him in his rhythm.

But I was so mad going down the backstretch, recalled Carroll. The leader ran off with Julien [Leparoux] and I wanted a contested pace. Fortunately, and surprisingly, Denis Of Cork jumped into the race early, racing closer to the pace than expected.

He was there, the rider told the trainer afterward, and not because of me.

At the end of the Southwest, nothing had changed. Denis Of Cork was still undefeated, only this time he finished first twice. One mile races at Oaklawn Park end at the sixteenth pole, but when Denis reached the true finish line no one passed him.

So, is Denis Of Cork good enough to win the Derby?

All a trainer can do is put him in a position, physically and mentally, said Carroll. I only have 22 horses so I have time to observe him, his disposition, his walk, the way he puts his head in the feed tub. He looks to have an air of confidence about him now, and hes put on some weight. Hopefully hes stays healthy, keeps improving.

Hes like a big, tall, high school kid and I think his best races and more improvement are ahead of him, the trainer said. Theres still a couple of things we need to work on, Albarado advised.

Hes so lightly raced, he needs experience, said the trainer who also guides the Derby destiny of a talented, albeit unlucky, Blackberry Road. Well run [Blackberry Road] back in the Louisiana Derby and Robby will ride him, replacing Borel. We just want to change the luck up a little bit.

But [Denis Of Cork] will run in the Rebel and well keep our options open after that. Ive done my babying with him. Now hes going to have to go out and run, be a racehorse.

Written by John Pricci

Comments (0)


Friday, February 15, 2008

Needed Franchise Fix a Waste of Time and Money

SARATOGA SPRINGS, Feb. 14, 2008--What a waste of time and money, this entire political harangue that gave agita to the thousands of people who fretted about the state of world class racing in New York.

And we're not talking about the near panic that was created here, in this city in the country. We're referring to those who could have afforded the shutdown least: Backstretch workers and mutuel clerks, ushers and hot dog vendors, horsemen not named Pletcher or Mott or McLaughlin, Gomez or Velazquez or Prado.

While its comforting to know that the world's best thoroughbred racing will be conducted in New York without man-made interruption for the next 25 years, and that well healed tourists can begin contacting real estate brokers or making hotel reservations for August, what was really accomplished by all this wrangling, the needless, costly delays?

Just how has this broken model--referenced by all parties and resulting in the passage of VLT legislation six years ago to benefit the states major racetracks and the taxpayers of the State of New York-- been fixed, exactly? Five years of VLT revenues all gone to hell because the people's interests weren't as important as the agenda of Albany power brokers.

What are we supposed to make of benchmarks that require the newly reconstituted New York Racing Association to use its best efforts to reach handle and performance standards? What standards? Are we using attendance figures from the 70s? Handle figures from the 00s? Last years figures from both?

And why was OTB supposedly seeking to opt out of simulcasting NYRA races, according to a story on, when the NYRA races are OTBs volume leader?

That didnt make sense. OTB generates handle sufficient enough to negotiate its own deals. NYC-OTB alone handles a billion annually and basically it sets the price for the other regions. OTB simply wanted the ability to simulcast other tracks in the event of a negotiations breakdown with the local franchise holder.

The NYRA--left for dead over a year ago after Excelsior Racing was awarded a racing and gaming franchise at the states three major tracks by Gov. George Patakis Ad Hoc Committee on Racing--has been resurrected, virtually in tact. Recent history became ancient when voters decided to replace one governor and one political party with another.

Excelsior no longer even exists. Remember when they were supposed to be the ones having very close ties to sitting governor?

And so it turns out the Memorandum of Understanding signed by Gov. Eliot Spitzer and the NYRA had legs, the association playing its land card beautifully. While Senate Majority Leader Joseph Bruno, the major obstructionist in all this, was allowed to save face, make no mistake: The governor and NYRA were the big winners.

According to some of the significant terms of the 25-year franchise extension agreement announced Wednesday--as opposed to the one floated last weekend--NYRA gets a $105-million in operating capital, forgiveness of $120-million in state debt, and added money for purses. The state takes title to all three racetrack properties valued at about a billion dollars. What might it be worth on Jan. 1, 2034?

Each made political gains, too. The interim plan had the NYRA board reconstituted from 28 members to 21, including present political appointees, NYRA retaining 11 of the 20 members.

But the final agreement reduces the NYRA board from 28 to 25. NYRA gets to keep 14 of the 25, better proportional representation which, politics notwithstanding, makes better business sense. Its chairman, Steven Duncker, is limited to one four-year term.

Its a win for the governor because he gets to make seven of the 11 state appointees. Four of the remaining seats will be held by the OTBs collectively, horsemen, breeders, and a union member representing the New York chapter of the AFL-CIO. Added to the NYRA executive board will be one appointee each from the House and Senate.

The state oversight board, created when the serious NYRA problems began a few years ago, will remain and given more power. But the current members will be replaced, another loss for Bruno, as now the governor gets to make the majority of appointments to the five-member board.

It was also a win for this community and for Queens residents as well. NYRA must meet with community advisory boards semi-annually before it can act on future real estate development plans. The loser here was Nassau County, which failed to get either this courtesy or the racino it wanted for Belmont Park.

Horsemen did relatively well. The states breeders will get 1.5% of VLT revenues by year three and purses will increase by 7.5% in that same period. After payouts, NYRA will retain 7% of the VLT revenues, 3% for racing operations and 4% for improvements and renovations. For this, they pay New York State a franchise fee annually.

Wednesdays legislation did not address the NYC-OTB issue in particular or the OTB scenario in the overall. New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg is holding to his threat to shut down all OTB branches within the five boroughs. The former needs to be addressed by June; the latter, a complex matter involving revenues to the counties and jobs, wont be addressed until the earliest mid-2009. After all, this is an election year.

The elephant in the room is the franchise to run the VLT operations, to be determined next month. Two bidders remain: Capital Play, represented by lobbyist Kenneth Bruno, and SL Green, a consortium of investors coupled with the remnants of the original Empire Racing group, to which Kenneths father, Joseph, was tethered. Capisci?

Written by John Pricci

Comments (2)


Friday, February 08, 2008

Back to the Kentucky Derby Futures

SARATOGA SPRINGS, NY, Feb. 7, 2008--

The first of three Kentucky Derby Future wagers is underway. The 23 currently top-rated three-year-olds have been listed with early line odds, but its All Other Three-Year-Olds that have been installed the 5-2 favorite.

This in keeping with tradition. Future bettors generally cover the unknown bases early and, unless extraordinary value is available on a favorite by the time Pool 1 closes late Sunday, will await Pools 2 or Pool 3 before zeroing in on their preferences. Its a sound approach.

With the assistance of Equiform performance figures, HorseRaceInsider is providing a thumbnail sketch of the 23 top-rated sophomores plus one; the talented and long-winded filly, Country Star. Contenders are listed in alphabetical order with early future odds, their dosage index in parenthesis, followed by their career best, relevant Equiform performance rating:
20-1 (4.00) ANAK NAKAL, 72.75: Nick Zito trainee showed improved early speed earning a new pace top while winning the Grade 2 Kentucky Jockey Club Stakes at 2 over the Derby track. He showed good energy distribution in both prior starts. Plenty of room for forward development.

20-1 (3.00) BLACKBERRY ROAD, 72.5: Top-figure rating was earned finishing second to Anak Nakal, indicating a preference for the Churchill surface, a la Street Sense. Only negative is hes had many chances to break through with a better rating.

50-1 (4.33) BOB BLACK JACK, [78.25, 6F]: Therein lies the rub. He looks and acts like a sprinter and is bred for speed top and bottom of pedigree. The question? How did he crack the Top 23?

30-1 (2.11) COLONEL JOHN, 73: Showing good energy distribution throughout his career, his best figure was his last when he finished a troubled second in his juvenile finale, the G1 Cash Call Futurity. Bred to run all day top and bottom, added maturity figures to help. Dreaming if you think 30-1 will be available on Sunday.

5-2 (2.08) COUNTRY STAR 72.75: The filly is available in the all others category [8-1 in Kentucky Oaks futures]. Bobby Frankel trainee never has taken a backward step in three career starts. By a hot, young sire theres plenty of room for development. Frankel usually errs on the side of easiest path to the biggest purse, but this is the Derby. Hes always said that nicked up Empire Maker should have beaten Funny Cide in 2003. Maybe hell try to avenge that defeat with one of his daughters.

12-1 (3.67) COURT VISION, 72.5: Best figure was earned at Churchill Downs before soft win going 9 furlongs in extremely troubled Remsen. Has had three closely spaced workouts recently indicating seasons debut may be imminent. Owns enough pedigree and since Saratoga 07 Bill Motts productivity has been nothing short of remarkable. Odds seem relative to futures timeframe, but deserving of anticipated heavy action.

20-1 (2.60) COWBOY CAL, 75.5 [73.25, 9F]: Taking the Barbaro route via two dominating turf-stakes wins, he boasts pedigree indicating hell run long and successfully on dirt, too. Difficult to assess the odds on the Todd Pletcher-trained sophomore, but then you might say the same about many of this years colts coming from synthetic-track preps.

20-1 (3.00) CROWN OF THORNS, 72.75: Despite coming off two sprints into the mile and a sixteenth G2 Lewis Memorial, he rated well enough and kicked clear decisively. Of greater significance is that his soft win--defined as a victory in which the pace and final figure were lower than that earned in a prior start--showed much better energy distribution. This gives Hall of Famer Richard Mandella enviable depth. Early price seems low.

30-1 (1.80) DENIS OF CORK, [72.25, 7f]: Regular readers know weve been high on this colt since his debut at Churchill Downs, and earns kudos for the guts shown winning his troubled-trip second start over a sloppy Fair Grounds track. The 70.25 earned was a soft win and hes eligible to go forward in a big way off the compressed debut figure. Interesting to see where Calvin Borel, at the moment holding three Derby options, stays lands. Players should require every bit of 30-1.

15-1 (4.33) EL GATO MALO, 75.5: Undefeated in three starts by a combined 16 lengths, hes more than talented and fast enough at this stage to be regarded a serious Derby contender, as far as he goes. Hes long on adaptability but a little short on temperament, although hes eligible to settle down with more experience. But its a short pedigree that makes short price unappealing.

15-1 (4.14) ETCHED, 73.25 [74.25, 7f]: Visually there might not have been a more impressive juvenile to race last season. He drew off rapidly with a blinding middle move to win his debut then did the same when able to relax off slower fractions in taking the G3 Nashua mile in soft win style while distributing his energy more like a seasoned veteran. But hes being prepared in Dubai, so who knows?

30-1 (1.67) GEORGIE BOY [73.5, 7f]: Interesting horse if you can forgive geldings short both-sides pedigree. But hes never taken a backward step in five career starts, culminating with a G1 win in Del Mar Futurity. Hes been working swiftly and diligently for Kathy Walsh, who has a deserved reputation for stretching horses out effectively.

20-1 (2.43) GIANT MOON 74: Undefeated in four career starts including the Whirlaway, his top figure 74 was a reversal, meaning hes learning how to run. Trainer Rick Schosberg is giving the colt the good-horse treatment. Hell be tested in earnest in the G3 Gotham. Bred to run all day, he needs to learn to settle better. Not enough price as quoted.

20-1 (1.50) INTO MISCHIEF, 73.75: Picked a good time, the G1 Cash Call, to learn how to distribute his energy. He showed some uncommon grit in that victory and hell need all of that for Mandella. His pedigree is simply too sprint oriented. Would be bigger price than this on Derby day.

15-1 (3.00) MAJESTIC WARRIOR, [75.25, 7F]: Made lots of fans with unlikely impressive victory in G1 Hopeful. True, the pace was extraordinarily hot and the leaders killed each other off. But Mott runner came from so far back it rendered seeing disbelieving. But no one truly knows what to make of his malady-plagued Champagne. Ability? Obviously. Classic distance aptitude? Not completely sold.

30-1 (2.00) MONBA, 72.5: Love his development. Good energy distribution from day one and not a backward step in three lifetime starts, never flinching as distances increased. His last was an excellent fourth following super-wide trip in the Cash Call, going in the right direction at the end and galloping out strongly. Owns a Churchill win and very likely to get faster. Hell have to. Early-line odds seem fair, relatively speaking.

12-1 (4.14) PYRO, 77: Figures really jumped when he started going long--or were they a function of chasing rapid War Pass in the G1 Champagne and Juvenile? Probably both. But hes fast, finishes well, has enough pedigree and the right connections. Were sure prolific Steve Asmussen learned much after taking Curlin through last years chase. The colt sits atop many Derby Top Tens, so the price isnt out of line. No need to wager until after Saturdays Risen Star.

50-1 (1.67) SIGNATURE MOVE, 69.75: Two-for-two going long but recent soft win was painfully slow, as was his prior. Thus far, hes been a pace presser that hasnt proven much in a limited campaign. If you like him, add a zero to early-line odds.

20-1 (3.00) SMOOTH AIR, [75, 7f]: A remarkable colt. Hes never taken a backward step in five lifetime starts--highly unusual--and showed class and grit winning G2 Hutcheson. From low profile connections, hard trying colt is light on classic pedigree. He figures to win another prep somewhere along the way but the Derby seems a bit much. His odds will be thrice this quote by Sunday, as they should be.

20-1 (2.00) TALE OF EKATI, [75, 7F]: Picked up more than one set of eyebrows when he won the Futurity in style with excellent change-of-pace performance, then caught a sloppy Monmouth Park track. He has strong bottom-side pedigree and Barclay Tagg guides him, both good things. But talented colt is an unknown two-turn quantity and his odds, in that context, should be higher.

12-1 (4.09) WAR PASS, 79.25: Virtually impossible to knock. Undefeated in four starts, improving his performance figures with each start, earned almost same figure as Street Sense in taking the Juvenile. As everyone knows, he is sired by sprint champion Cherokee Run and his Mr. Prospector side is not all that much better. Given his obvious talent and the fact hell likely win a prep or two, 12-1 is probably much better than youll see Derby day. And isnt that what this exercise is supposed to be about?

20-1 (1.22) YANKEE BRAVO, 70.5: Yet another undefeated three-year-old, he was most impressive winning California Derby from extreme outside post, showing poise and professionalism that belies a three-race career. Patrick Gallagher has managed him beautifully this far and Alex Solis seems really impressed with him. But too many questions to answer given relatively short odds.

20-1 (1.67) Z FORTUNE, 74.25: Undefeated New York-bred showed a new off-the-pace dimension winning his last and earning a lifetime best figure; his three victories having come at three different dirt venues. Hes already done the unexpected and has Asmussen in his corner but is a little light on both sides of his pedigree. Hes handled everything thrown his way.

15-1 (2.64) Z HUMOR, 74.25: Third in the Champagne, he was a dead-heat winner of the Delta Jackpot. By Distorted Humor from an A. P. Indy mare, pedigree is no issue, and with three recent workouts within a 14-day day period hes probably close to his seasons debut. Given the higher profile of some of his rivals here, he might fall between the parimutuel cracks. That would make him worthy of closer inspection.

Written by John Pricci

Comments (0)


Page 126 of 137 pages « FirstP  <  124 125 126 127 128 >  Last »