That’s a shade over 22 percent on a surface rated fast for the first two days of racing at the new meeting, and the New York Racing Association tack of scratch-me-if-you-can is raising eyebrows everywhere.
It is fresh sand and loam that horses are racing on now--and this after every horseman we spoke with in the last 10 days said to a man and woman that there was nothing wrong with the winter track over which there have been 18 breakdowns since November 30, 2011.
As we speak, the New York Times is preparing a series on horse fatalities. As Turo Escalante might say--if he still had a voice, that is--“what a surprise,”—yet another negative story from the paper of record just in time for Kentucky Derby Madness.
The sad part is that that the impending series is timely and newsworthy, and it comes a time when the industry is being buried under an avalanche of bad news. For anyone who loves this game—and that’s everybody associated with it, on any level—that pit in your stomach is a.k.a. fear.
The scratch of 32 horses in two days when field size is already on the small side is not a coincidence and, despite the protestations of the New York Racing Association, it is unusual and way above the norm given ideal racing conditions.
But erring on the side of caution--whether or not the Big Brother in Albany is on your case--is a good thing and the right thing to do. And everyone had better pray to God Almighty that all the Triple Crown horses come home safely!
Here’s the pity of it all: No athletes are under as much scrutiny as the Thoroughbred race horse, especially the Triple Crown horses. But, damn it, accidents do happen.
In a partial study released by the Jockey Club this morning involving 1,160,045 starters, the fatality rate among injured horses last year was 1.88 per thousand, the exact same ratio as in 2010, and better than the 1.98 recorded in 2009.
Here’s some A-B-C type information for the people who want to see the sport of Thoroughbred racing die: While one fatality out of one trillion for those tethered to the Thoroughbred is too many, a less than two percent mortality rate is realistically not beyond the pale.
If NYRA said that its examiners were doing anything differently for the last two days, it would be an admission that they have not been doing enough since November 30. And that would be unacceptable, of course.
But to have a leading racing organization qualify its actions, for erring on the side of caution in a game as well monitored as this one in regards to animal welfare, is beyond sad.
After all, it’s not as if horsemen are placing bounties on the horses of rival trainers just to win a purse.
Instead of celebrating the fact that Havre De Grace, the third consecutive female Horse of the Year, is ranked #1 in the latest official NTRA poll and well on her way to a title defense, the industry and the media covering it has been distracted by what’s happening off-track.
For one thing, there are those casino-yes, racing-no statehouses that are more interested in bottom lines than jobs, green space or an American way of life.
For another, the cancellation of an entertaining HBO drama series because a horse reared up, fell over backwards, and struck its head the ground, necessitating that it be euthanized, is another hit in the battle racing has with the mainstream, whether the arena be sports or gambling.
In an excellent piece of reporting, Ray Paulick of Paulick Report wrote a comprehensive story that left little doubt as to the agenda, both real and imagined, of the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals group.
Paulick’s story went a long way in exposing the animal-rights group for the frauds they are, their real agenda being the checks they cut for themselves in the form of salary.
One of their stated objectives is to bar animals from participating in the entertainment industry. Just this past Tuesday, “Late Show” host David Letterman complained to a guest about how PETA has made his life, and those of his staff, difficult regarding the show’s occasional but long-standing and popular feature, “Stupid Pet Tricks.”
As any Letterman viewer knows, these are harmless, amusing stunts taught the animals by their devoted owners. Does any reasonable person truly believe that asking a dog to perform a sophisticated equivalent of sitting up and begging is somehow harmful?
If that’s the case, parents should be required to avert the gaze of their children when the circus rolls into town. And perhaps you had better think twice about teaching your old dog any more new tricks, stupid or otherwise. Hypocrisy knows no bounds.


22 Mar 2012 at 01:42 pm | #
People are like sheep to the slaughter, believing the propaganda that is put out there, in so many forms, based on personal and corporate agendas. A guy approached me in my hotel last week, and said words to the effect, “too bad about that HBO show Luck, I hear they cancelled it because horses died, and they realized that racing is cruel to animals.” I told him, it is sad if you believe that fairy tale, and turned and walked away. If this kind of thing is not disputed, this will become what everybody really thinks about horse racing, especially those who know nothing about the game whatsoever, and should keep their mouth shut.
TTT
22 Mar 2012 at 01:57 pm | #
Absolutely right, T, the industry has to stop apologizing for what it is. We’ve learned that reaction doesn’t work; the time for proaction is now. Racing has made progress in this area of late, but it must continue leaning forward.
22 Mar 2012 at 02:02 pm | #
Uggh. What a sad state of affairs. This is no time for racing to be defensive. Pro-active yes, defensive no. Racing is not Man’s highest moral pursuit. But it is not cruel in its essence and its redemptive aspects - the bonds it creates between man and horse and the sharing of the game’s risks across species, not to mention the economic good and the several positives it contributes to the American way of life - must be unashamedly communicated in the face of the onslaught it faces. The opportunistic progressive-left, led by PETA and The New York Times, thrives on the victim/oppressor paradigm. Racing needs to be unequivocal in its defense of the game and unafraid to place the horse and its treatment by the game in the context of the greater societal treatment of animals. In that context, racing, despite its failings - failings of individuals not the game’s nature - is clearly, to those with any kind of perspective, humane.
Now, the pro-active part....horsemen need to acknowledge that some changes need to be made to the game. Less racing, less medication, and a better plan for using and distributing the slots windfall need to be front and center. The proliferation of gambling will make the industry increasingly less important to the politicos. Racing will need to make its case to the public. I hope it strikes the right tone in doing so.
22 Mar 2012 at 02:12 pm | #
Preach,
You do your best work when angry, another great write. But…
“We Have Nothing To Fear But Fear Itself”.
PETA did not cancel the HBO series Luck, the lack of viewership did. It was just a built in excuse for HBO. Actors like Dustin Hoffman and Nick Nolte don’t work for chicken scratch. It comes down to the allmighty dollar. Just not enough of die hard day to day horseracing fans left to be interested in a show like that. Believe me I’m as pissed off as any for the shows cancellation, for it was just getting better as it moved along.
I also think PETA as they will try their hardest, won’t end horseracing. It use to be that horseracing was the only legal game to gamble on outside of Vegas. Times have changed, and there’s casinos everywhere now. For whatever the reason people who like to gamble have alternatives, and horseracing has become an afterthought. Bottom line the industry needs to survive on it’s own. The billionaire farms like Juddmonte, Darley, Winstar etc. need to work with the tracks to subsidize purse structure. Takeout needs to be lowered to attract newbies and keep existing base. Some small tracks will have to close and unfortunately jobs will be lost. I could go on but when push comes to shove, I believe the “Kings” of the sport will fix this.
22 Mar 2012 at 02:19 pm | #
Cat,
Agree with you about the real reason for the cancellation. That is, I don’t think if this had been a hit along the lines of The Sopranos that three horse deaths would have deterred HBO from going forward. But you miss the point, the narrative that’s out there is that PETA killed it and that racing is barbarous.
22 Mar 2012 at 02:50 pm | #
Kyle,
“You can please some of the people all of the time, you can please all of the people some of the time, but you can’t please all of the people all of the time”.
Bottom line is that horseracing will always be barbarous if you will to some of the people. For other open minded thinkers, the love relationship of man and thoroughbred will forever be recognized.
22 Mar 2012 at 03:04 pm | #
I wish I could share your confidence, Cat. Racing is not healthy. And the weaker it gets the more succeptable it is to these kinds of attacks.
22 Mar 2012 at 03:46 pm | #
Kyle,
It’s my nature to be confident, I would not have survived playing this game for 35 years if I wasn’t.
Yes there’s alot of negativity out there and rightfully so. Let me spin some positives.
1-The Ky. Derby drew a record attendance just last year(168,000 plus) and this years crop looks as good and exciting as ever.
2- Horses are being bred and sold for 6 and 7 figures still.
3- It’s a huge global sport, look at the purses for the Dubai carnival, and you can’t even bet there.
4- Lasix is being abolished for this years BC juveniles.
5- Stars like HDG, Animal Kingdom, Calebs Posse, Mucho Macho Man etc. are running as 4 year olds.
22 Mar 2012 at 04:42 pm | #
John:
The barbarians are at the Gate (Hempstead Tpke and Plainfield Ave) and it will take a Herculean effort to stop it. Is racing so barbaric? What about bullfighting or for that matter, the entire Circus that is Westminster? Aqueduct is on its last legs, thanks to the largesse that is the Genting casino. It has worked out too well. Son of Mario will never relent now that he sees the dollar signs from Casino Gambling-as opposed to the 90s, the odds of the Constitutional amendment going thru are 3-5.
We have the ultimate shotgun marriage of slots money and PETA zealotry combining to destroy racing. Only a fool believes that the slot money will last very long. Moreover, PETA smells “blood"-pardon the ridiculous pun. NYRA must take the lead and demand accountability. The horsemen better understand that there is a WAR going on and war requires sacrifices-including the ultimate one. Less racing, lower takeouts and TRUE transparency in the medical treatment of the animals MUST be the absolute minimum changes that should be made immediately. Otherwise, the tragedy of the inner track of 2012 will be their Final Battlefield!
22 Mar 2012 at 05:49 pm | #
more positives…
6- Zenyatta and Rachel A. gave birth to healthy colts.
7- Preach picked a winner today!
I’ll think of more, time for Veal parm dinner, screw PETA
23 Mar 2012 at 10:56 am | #
8- Alpha coming to NY for the Wood, will face Gemologist.
9- Calebs Posse, Calibrachoa, Shackelford and Jackson Bend will run in the Carter.
23 Mar 2012 at 11:39 am | #
10- Zenyatta to be bred to Tapit
11- Lucky Chappy worked in company with Royal Delta today in Dubai.
23 Mar 2012 at 12:45 pm | #
Hope our readers appreciate your updates, Cat. Lucky Chappy might be interesting UAE prospect; what’s unusual it seems is the the former is Motion, the latter, Mott.
Go get’em boys!
23 Mar 2012 at 01:44 pm | #
It is hopeless! Just about all of the commentators at HRI, IMO don’t known which end of the horse farts.
Neither does anyone, from the contributors to the commentators, understand that it is all about gambling, about cashing tickets.
Just this week Andy Beyer and Bill Finley wrote commentary that told newbies that racing at Delaware Park and Philly was DREARY, and that fans HATE to bet on CHEAP horses. Two turf writers, who have been around a long time, still doing nothing positive to get people out to the track, be it Beulah, Philly, Finger Lakes, or Saratoga; their commentary, as I have said numerous times at HRI already, is detrimental to the growth of Thoroughbred racing. In their minds, Thoroughbred racing involves only horses that qualify for stake races.
Isn’t it finally wonderful? For years and years I had to read and endure the articles written by turf writers, without the ability for rebuttal. Daily Racing Form allowed me to write to the Editor as much as I wanted, but they would only publish four of my inane emails a year (at the maximum); their reason being that I should not be monopolizing.
Thoroughbred horses incur injuries, so be it. So do human beings, (aka athletes). What’s PETA’s take on sport’s injuries - we are animals, aren’t we?
23 Mar 2012 at 02:08 pm | #
12- Bodemeister worked awesome this morning! 46 4/5 without blinkers, while rating and taking dirt. Blinkers off next start.
Don’t fear the PETA
Don’t fear the corrow
Love is more powerful than death.
All our times have come
Here but now they’re gone
Seasons don’t fear the reaper
Nor do the wind, the sun or the rain..we can be like they are
Come on baby...don’t fear the reaper
Baby take my hand...don’t fear the reaper
We’ll be able to fly...don’t fear the reaper
Baby I’m your man…
Valentine is done
Here but now they’re gone
Romeo and Juliet
Are together in eternity...Romeo and Juliet
40,000 men and women everyday...Like Romeo and Juliet
40,000 men and women everyday...Redefine happiness
Another 40,000 coming everyday...We can be like they are
Come on baby...don’t fear the reaper
Baby take my hand...don’t fear the reaper
We’ll be able to fly...don’t fear the reaper
Baby I’m your man…
Love of two is one
Here but now they’re gone
Came the last night of sadness
And it was clear she couldn’t go on
Then the door was open and the wind appeared
The candles blew then disappeared
The curtains flew then he appeared...saying don’t be afraid
Come on baby...and she had no fear
And she ran to him...then they started to fly
They looked backward and said goodby...she had become like they are
She had taken his hand...she had become like they are
Come on baby...don’t fear the reaper
23 Mar 2012 at 02:47 pm | #
Wendell, Wendell, Wendell,
You’re not keeping up again.
You mentioned articles written by Andy Beyer and Bill Finley and said, “I had to read and endure the articles written by turf writers, without the ability for rebuttal.”
Well, Wendell, the Beyer article on slot tracks allows comments from readers just like yourself. At this moment there are 72 comments from readers.
Bill Finley’s columns also allow reader comments.
Hence, you could have commented to either of their opinions just as easily as you do here.
I’d also point out Mr. Pricci offered you space for to write here, which you turned down.
Bluster away Wendell, but don’t make up fiction as you go along.
23 Mar 2012 at 03:11 pm | #
Mr. Kling: Read my comment again, “for years and years .....” I am aware that since the internet came into being one could comment following a turf writer’s commentary, in most cases. I, as were thousands of other horseplayers, was muzzeled for, again, years and years without the ability to challenge a turf writers commentary.
Yea, I should have accepted Mr. Pricci’s offer. This site would now be extremely famous if I had.
And, many constant contributors would have been chastised for their innoucous dribble.
23 Mar 2012 at 03:16 pm | #
Wendell,
I believe you mean drivel. Dribble is what you do with a basketball or what water does when it escapes slowly from a hole or other outlet.
23 Mar 2012 at 03:39 pm | #
Mr. Kling: The word drivel is probably more appropriate, but you can’t flunk me by using the word dribble. According to the dictionary I have in front of me, dribble can mean ‘a tiny or insignificant bit or quantity’. Note the word ‘insignificant’ which can be applied to much of the reader comentary at HRI, including mine.
I only got C pluses in just about all my courses in college. Spent to much time at Lincoln Downs and Narragansett Park, but I saved a lot of money on text books, as I rarely purchased one - borrowed from the little ladies that were in abundance.
But, your right, I intended to use the word drivel.
Time for a beer. BTW, I have moved up in class, from Schlitz to Fosters. Like going from lowly claimers to allowance nags.
23 Mar 2012 at 04:45 pm | #
more positive news…
13- Casper lives! Never a SCARY moment, Abdel’s Ghost by a #&%$ hair! Someone knows which end of the horse farts. ABC always be cashing!
It’s Friday night fish. Does PETA allow you to eat fish? Calamari over pasta on the menu. Washing it down with Guinness black and tan.
and the beat goes on
24 Mar 2012 at 05:01 am | #
Wendell,
Congratulations on your good taste in beer.
I gave up drinking a long time ago, but Schlitz was THE man’s beer in the mid- to late 1960s.
Can’t fault you for switching to Fosters. As a friend of mine once said, there was nothing better for lunch than a good sandwich and one of those Fosters “oil cans.”
24 Mar 2012 at 07:36 am | #
Wendell, I’m begging you, please make HRI famous and cure the industry’s ills. I can’t wait. The offer still goes.
04 Apr 2012 at 12:23 am | #
John, don’t overestimate the power of the N.Y. Times. It is a shadow of its former self, badly run, and in the event that something goes right, Pinch will be right there to steady the wheel so the ship hits the rocks again.
If someone like Judy Miller (or going back into the hallowed past, Homer Bigart) were the author of the articles, then I’d be concerned; but as we all know, she’s gone, and the Drapes of the world can’t create the same waves, while working for a company where the morale of the journalists is shot (thanks to the $20M+ CEO Robinson “settlement").