I couldn’t understand it when national handle figures kept rising each month this winter despite less than stellar racing in New York, even by winter standards, and a perceived decline of this year’s product at Tampa Bay Downs.
True, things were looking up at Santa Anita, where there was no horseplayer boycott this time, and at Gulfstream Park, which had a season reminiscent of racing’s glory days when champions routinely showed up in mid-week money-allowances.
Still, given the continued contraction of racing dates at tracks that were hemorrhaging money and those that hosted abbreviated race cards to accommodate a declining horse population, how could this be?
Then came the scandalous takeout story at the New York Racing Association; the sensational treatment the New York Times gave a “disreputable industry” and an on-going raceday medication controversy that has fair-minded practitioners lining up on opposing sides.
Despite all this, betting volume continued to rise this month when Churchill Downs posted double-digit gains on Derby weekend, a trend that continued in Baltimore on Saturday where Preakness business rose for a third consecutive year and a new attendance mark of 121,309 was set.
But from the Derby came stories that raised questions, making casual fans aware of the winning trainer’s checkered past. Further, the ink on the Preakness chart was hardly dry when a Louisville Courier-Journal story told how the owner of the colt that stands on the precipice of racing history had his company branded by the California Attorney General two years ago as a high-interest lender resorting to “loan-shark tactics.”
There are a number of sure bets to be cashed during the three week run-up to the Belmont Stakes. The woes of the event’s host will be recounted, again, as will Doug O’Neill’s milkshaking travails, again, as well as the strong-armed tactics of Paul Reddam’s company.
The one aspect of the NYRA situation likely to be unreported is the unwitting role that the state played in all this. Several of its regulatory agencies in an oversight role failed to detect the accounting error in a timely fashion. Despite that, the state took temporary control of the NYRA on Tuesday by altering the makeup of its Board of Trustees, an arrangement that will remain in place through Governor Andrew Cuomo's term of office.
Sadly, all of what is to come will prove a distraction to the historical matter at hand because other agenda unflattering to racing are at work here. The industry deserves much of what it gets from critics, but not all of it all the time.
Thoroughbred racing has been waiting for a moment like this to come to fruition for 34 years now and the organization charged with putting on the show is rudderless. It doesn’t have a best face to put forward; that face was fired weeks ago.
The faces responsible for moving the show along now are the trainer of a fun bunch surrounding a gifted, gritty and unflappable colt, and his humble from-out-of-the-blue jockey who allows his mount to do the talking despite giving two brilliant tactical performances under the glare of racing’s biggest spotlight.
On June 9, the huge ballpark on Long Island, a racetrack whose size has become anachronistic, will play host to 100,000 history-starved sports fans that will fill every corner of the behemoth track.
The noise these fans will make at Belmont Park if I’ll Have Another is in winning position at the beginning of a stretch run that begins in one county and ends in another will be positively scary.
The roar will shake the building to its foundation as yet another Thoroughbred attempts to boldly go where only 11 have gone before, and where 11 since 1979 have failed to tread.
For two and a half minutes, the only thing that will matter is who finishes first. If that horse happens to be I’ll Have Another, human warts and all, it will remove the bad taste left when a troubled Big Brown was pulled up with a quarter-mile left to run.
Smarty Jones and Funny Cide also shipped into Gotham with the same chance to make history but both were defeated, one via questionable riding tactics and home cooking, the other by the suitably pedigreed betting favorite. At least both were beaten on the square.
Even in victory, the chances are that I’ll Have Another won’t be racing’s savior. Last year, a study conducted by the austere Jockey Club found that the general public does not hold racing in the esteem it once did so who knows how long the afterglow will last.
The recent Times series added to racing’s current undesirable categorization and there is concern that an historic victory might advance this adverse perception of horse racing in this country because of the possible increase of negativity in mainstream media.
But all year the sporting crowd has been voting with their dollars so that any negative perceptions that exist are trending otherwise thus far. So is it an improved economy, increased and improved network television coverage, or is it something else?
Could it be that what makes horse racing great is that a society that has been tethered to the Thoroughbred since racing began over five centuries ago on the Plains of Hempstead, not far from Belmont Park, has and will remain loyal indefinitely?
Are we learning that the game might be bullet proof after all?


22 May 2012 at 10:20 am | #
What the horseplayer has learned is that the fans are there on special occasions and the lyrics to the song the desperate turf writers produce make the record keep moving.The song remains the same!
One thing for sure, apart from all the idle chatter,is that I’ll Have Another will win the Belmont Stakes by a large margin and become a Triple Crown winner. The competition he will face is weak.
22 May 2012 at 10:53 am | #
Tim, agreed that the modern game is event driven, and that there’s too much unappealing racing being offered. This comes as news to no one. It’s been written, and commented upon, many times in this forum.
As for I’ll Have Another’s chances of a Triple Crown sweep, his resume is much better than some of the recent failures since 1979. However, when it comes to your assessment of his competition, I couldn’t disagree more. This is a good crop of 3-year-olds, a notion we’ve held since early in the Derby prep season.
22 May 2012 at 12:06 pm | #
Tim may be right, but it would not surprise me if Union Rags sent him and Mr. O’Neill back to California with their tails between their legs. People seem to give up on horses that have not “won,” when there are so many reasons why a horse loses one or more races, beyond its control.
If I’ll have another beats this large field, and especially Union Rags, this degenerate will not be saying it’s a hollow Triple Crown victory, and he will have earned his place with the immortals.
TTT
22 May 2012 at 12:57 pm | #
Preeeeech, Welcome back babe!
Hey I STARTED THE JOKE that the game is bullet proof months ago. With all the bad press, horses were still selling for six and seven figures. Higher purses from slots brought more quantity(field size) and better quality of horses for the horseplayer. Have I mentioned before the game is exciting and fun to handicap the race puzzle.
TTT, you need to eat some crow babe, you guaranteed Bodemeister would win. Give IHA and connections respect, they deserve it.
Tim, getting the LED out?
It’s not good for the sport that Bodemeister won’t continue the rivalry in the Belmont, but can understand it. Baffert has a substitute Paynter who is rapidly developing and can be IHA’s main danger.
I heard that seats for the “Test of Champions” sold out in three minutes yesterday. Where are you now Wendel?
and the beat goes on… RIP Robin Gibb…
I started a joke,
which started the whole world crying,
but I didn’t see that the joke was on me, oh no.
I started to cry,
which started the whole world laughing,
oh, if I’d only seen that the joke was on me.
I looked at the skies,
running my hands over my eyes,
and I fell out of bed,
hurting my head from things that I’d said.
Til I finally died,
which started the whole world living,
oh, if I’d only seen that the joke was on me....
22 May 2012 at 01:42 pm | #
So much for a TTT guarantee. Hope you at least boxed some exactas as insurance.
22 May 2012 at 02:19 pm | #
I acknowledge my shortcoming, and it won’t be the first time I eat crow, but maintain that Bodemeister is the better animal. It’s tough to cut it on the front against the best 3-year olds in the country, and I’m saddened he will not be in the Belmont so that I can be vindicated. No excuses. Please send all requests for refunds 2 15 Easy Street, Tap City, Nevada 073456930.
Thanks.
TTT
22 May 2012 at 02:41 pm | #
Cat, I knew one of our loyal readers mentioned that beofre but couldn’t remember who. Guess I should have known it had to be you.
I wandered around, finally found somebody who, cause nobody else gave me a thrill, for all your faults I love you still…
22 May 2012 at 03:25 pm | #
TTT,
But I bet the farm because of your guarantee. How do you refund my cows, pigs and chickens. Shoulda known better, I forgot you were a sucker for speed.
Bode could not hold on, hold on. IHA sent a message to you. Lava Man sent a message to you.
Now the Baffert and Zayet families are heartbroken. Only Paynter can vindicate camp Bode now. You heard it here first, tell em a Tobasco Cat sent you…
and the beat goes on…
I can think of younger days when living for my life
Was everything a man could want to do.
I could never see tomorrow, but I was never told about the sorrow.
And how can you mend a broken heart?
How can you stop the rain from falling down?
How can you stop the sun from shining?
What makes the world go round?
How can you mend a this broken man?
How can a loser ever win?
Please help me mend my broken heart and let me live again.
22 May 2012 at 03:53 pm | #
Sorry Cat; I lost the farm years ago; been down in a small shack along the Mohawk River, just me and my laptop; a ma and pa operation.
TTT
22 May 2012 at 04:53 pm | #
I hear ya TTT,
The greedy bastards sent me to Japan to breed. I covered 100 mares a day until the heart gave out. Died right in the hay.
Now it’s just me, nagging Winning Colors and an I-phone. Keep stayin alive brother....
the beat will go on…
Well, now I get low and I get high
and if I can’t get either, I really try
Got the wings of heaven on my shoes
I’m a dancing man and I just can’t lose
You know, it’s all right. It’s OK.
I’ll live to see another day
We can try to understand
the New York Times’ effect on man
Whether you’re a brother or whether you’re a mother,
you’re staying alive, staying alive
Feel the city breaking and everybody shaking,
and we’re staying alive, staying alive
Ah, ha, ha, ha, staying alive, staying alive
Ah, ha, ha, ha, staying alive ...
22 May 2012 at 06:10 pm | #
Here is the difference IMO. Years past you could go to Belmont on any Saturday, and see 30-40K people at the track. On a BIG day like a Triple Crown maybe 65-80K Non TC on the line 60-70K. Now on a Sat. you might get 5K. Big day TC 100K+ Non TC 65-70K. Only thing that never changes is the 2 buck mutual. It use to be the only game in town, now you can toss cabbage in every direction. Coin flip in the Super Bowl generates more handle than the TC all put together.
22 May 2012 at 07:10 pm | #
John:
Fifty-Seven Years ago some of the wealthiest, most influential men on this planet set aside self-interest and put together a deal that saved racing in the great State of NY. On May 22, 2012, the vision of those great 20th Century industrialists was desecrated and rendered moot by a cabal of feckless politicians and the incompetent off-spring of the same men who founded the Greater NY Association.
Once upon a time, another incompetent politician “waved” a worthless piece of paper at a hopeful world and declared that we had ‘Peace’ in our time. However, history intervened and we had 50 Million dead within a few horrific years.
I am not even remotely trying to equate WWII to whatever occurred today, except to the extent that the “peace” achieved this afternoon will prove no more lasting than that agreed to by the foreign minister of Great Britain in 1938!
23 May 2012 at 07:44 am | #
WOW!!!! Preach, What’s going on here?
One day after reading your Thoroughbred horseracing proving bullet proof, a great feel good article, I awaken to news on the DRF website that:
1)NYRA now stands for Not Your Racetrack Anymore?
2)Thistledowns race #5 yesterday under wagering investigation, after 1-5 shot goes to 5-1 after the race starts. $12.00 win price and $6.00 exacta. $100,000 bet on a race that usually attracts $10,000. Hmmmm money bet on offshore account? Manipulation anyone?
3)Doug O’Neill trainer of I’ll Have Another, 2/3 the way towards triple crown, faces possible six month suspension for past possible horse drugging positive incident. Just what the game needs heading into the Belmont.
4)Rick Dutrow has day in court for his horse drugging alegations.
5)Kent Desormeaux drinking incident results in him losing the Belmont mount on Dullahan. Javier Castellano to ride.
In other Belmont news; Johnny V. will replace Leparoux on Union Rags.
23 May 2012 at 08:48 am | #
Gents,
Totally understand reservations on government’s role in NY racing, but let’s please not try to forget how it got to this point. I’m not saying it’sa good thing; I’m saying let’s wait and see how it begins to shake out. There will be lots of people looking over GOv. Cuomo’s shoulder and this is an election year after all.
Cat,
Sadly, all your news items are true.
DH,
Sadly, again, those days are gone but year-round racing in one place was never a good idea. It served the horsemen and state coffers well, not the bettors/fans. TO me, year-round racing was the beginning of the end of making the sport special.
When I was at St. Johns, March 20 was a special day; Opening Day at Aqueduct.
Framarco,
Indeed, industrialists (robber barons, some might say) had an excellent vision, but then it became a bit of a private club that catered to their own interests, not the public’s, IMO.
Thanks gents, good, and also amusing, stuff, per usual.
23 May 2012 at 09:22 am | #
All this negative publicity; think that a few of the guys should turn it into a positive for themselves; Desormeaus should get an endorsement deal from Budeweiser, O’Neill from McDonald’s, and Albarado from Everlast.
TTT
23 May 2012 at 04:24 pm | #
Gonna wear my bullet proof vest tomorrow at Big Sandy :(
26 May 2012 at 02:00 pm | #
That Kent D. won’t be involved in the Belmont is good news, IMO. And I don’t understand how anyone can maintain that Bodemeister is the better animal after the Preakness. The better animal should win when it get things it’s own way. And one says that there’s too much unappealing racing being offered, what does tha mean? Cheap horses? Small fields? To me it’s a bunch of races on a card with an odds-on favorite.