"I thought he'd be racing on the lead or in second, but he broke a little slowly and I had to race behind horses," said Rosario. "They weren't going all that fast, and we were able to move up. I asked him turning for home, and he gave it to me."
Imagining, who had sandwiched front-running victories in the Bowl Game overnight stakes at Belmont Park on October 17 and the restricted Idle Rich stakes at Saratoga Race Course around a sixth-place finish in the Grade 1 Joe Hirsch Turf Classic Invitational, completed the 11 furlongs in 2:18.43.
"[Joel] let him settle in and get to the outside, which is where he wanted to be," said McGaughey who won the 2011 and 2012 Red Smiths with Boisterous. "I was glad to see that; I said to myself when they were going down the backside, 'I hope he punches from here' because it would be something different for him. It was a pretty good bunch of horses; I think we're moving on up."
The victory was the first in a graded stakes for the 5-year-old son of Giant's Causeway, who has now won three of his past four starts. Sent off as the 7-2 second choice, he returned $8.30 for a $2 win bet and earned $150,000 for the Phipps Stable.
"There's a race out in California in about a month, or we may wait until Florida to run him," said McGaughey of Imagining, who is now 7-3-0 from 14 starts with a bankroll of $513,190.
The fast-closing filly Tannery finished third, a nose behind Hangover Kid
and 1 ¾ lengths ahead of 94-1 shot Slip and Drive. Hyper, the 3-2 favorite, never challenged and finished eighth.