Wednesday, September 10, 2014
3-year-olds in Horse of Year race for a change
Three-year-old males dominate the racing scene most of the year but recently they have fallen off the radar screen when Horse of the Year has been at stake in the fall. It has been seven years since Curlin won the top prize as a 3-year-old. Shared Belief and California Chrome appear poised to break that streak.
MIAMI, Sept. 10, 2014--Three-year-olds are racingâ€™s glamour division from the first Derby preps in January through the Haskell and Travers in late summer. The Pennsylvania Derby is pushing hard to extend this through the end of September.
However, when the championship races are run in October and November, sophomores have tended to fade from prominence in recent years. Only one 3-year-old male, Curlin in 2007, has been named Horse of the Year since 2001. (Rachel Alexandra also was 3 when she won the title in 2009.)
The drought has an excellent chance of being broken this season. With the premature retirement of Palace Malice, four-for-four in stakes until he misfired in the Whitney, the leading candidates for racingâ€™s biggest prize are Derby and Preakness winner California Chrome and undefeated Eclipse juvenile champion Shared Belief, the only 3-year-old to beat older horses in a significant stakes.
They are on target for their first showdown in the Breedersâ€™ Cup Classic on Nov. 1. A victory for either would clinch Horse of the Year.
But a victory by either is far from a slam dunk. Moreno and Itsmyluckyday, both 4, are making late-season bids of their own. However, with only one Grade 1 victory apiece, one of them would have to run the table of a key prep then the Classic.
They appear to have a tougher path than California Chrome and Shared Belief. None of California Chromeâ€™s ranking contemporaries have indicated an intention to take him on in the Pennsylvania Derby on Sept. 20. Shared Belief has already beaten the best of what there is in the West and figures to be 1-9 in Santa Anitaâ€™s Awesome Again on Sept. 27.
Moreno and Itsmyluckyday have each other to contend with in the Gold Cup in addition to Grade 1-winning 3-year-olds Tonalist and Wicked Strong. Moreno is a definite for the Gold Cup at Belmont. Itsmyluckyday appeared to not be heading that way after winning the Woodward but the absence of Palace Malice and the possibility of capturing Horse of the Year has encouraged owner/trainer Eddie Plesa Jr. to reconsider.
All this being said, it would be folly to overlook the possibility of a third straight Horse of the Year crown for Wise Dan, especially if he runs in and wins an important dirt stakes, which has been mentioned as a possibility. With Wise Dan voter fatigue a factor, it would take a total meltdown by Shared Belief, California Chrome, Moreno and Itsmyluckyday for Dan to rule the thoroughbred world again.
One of the purposes of the Breedersâ€™ Cup Classic was to identify the Horse of the Year but it has been six years since Curlin, then 4, won the Classic and the title. This looks like another streak waiting to be broken this season.
Christie flips again
I suppose some might feel I owe New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie an apology after I criticized his flip flop on allowing sports betting in his state last week (see previous column). Another way of looking at it is he owes me a thank you for the nudge, although Iâ€™m not vain enough to think heâ€™s aware I exist.
In any case, Christie flipped again on the issue Monday. After saying it would not be right to defy federal law, after previously saying â€śLet them try to stop us,â€ť Christie told New Jersey casinos and race tracks that they are free to begin taking bets on sports.
The fact that by next week four of Atlantic Cityâ€™s 12 casinos will have shut down this year, at a reported cost of 8,000 jobs, undoubtedly motivated Christieâ€™s latest change of heart.
It remains to be seen whether the gambling establishments can be up and running by this weekâ€™s NFL games but itâ€™s a certainty they will have their sports betting windows open as soon as humanly possible.
An appeal by the various sports leagues is another sure thing. This could turn into a battle of friendly judges with the leagues finding some to support their position and New Jersey finding others to knock down any injunctions that might materialize. Apparently Christie is back in his â€ślet them try to stop usâ€ť mode.
Speculation that the NFL might move to take the Giants and Jets out of the state and their new billion dollar stadium in the Meadowlands is so ridiculously out of the realm of possibility that it doesnâ€™t even merit a rebuttal.
I can see where people who donâ€™t live in or near New Jersey might dismiss this as â€śwhatâ€™s in it for me?â€ť But this is another of those â€ścamelâ€™s nose under the tentâ€ť issues. In other words, once the camel gets his nose under the tent, itâ€™s only a matter of time until the whole camel is in the tent.
Whatâ€™s happening with marijuana across the nation is an example. It started with medical marijuana being legalized in a few states. It quickly spread. Next recreational marijuana was legalized in Colorado and dozens of other states are looking at following suit.
In every case, the individual states have defied federal law without consequence.
If New Jersey is successful with sports betting, other states with budget woes (almost all of them) are sure to jump on the bandwagon.
A cynic might point out that Christie made his sports betting reversal on the anniversary of BridgeGate, the closing down of traffic lanes leading to the George Washington Bridge. The governorâ€™s announcement was a savvy political move to push an unpleasant reminder off the top of the news.
Hopefully all the lanes of all the bridges leading from New York and other neighboring states to New Jersey will be open when the sports betting windows open. Traffic will be heavy.
Written by Tom Jicha
Thursday, September 04, 2014
New drug rules? How about enforcing the existing ones first
Racing might be the only industry that bad mouths its own product. The talk all summer has been about the negative influence of race day medications. But before new regulations are considered, there has to be more of an effort to enforce the existing rules, which are now treated like an acceptable cost of doing business by too many horsemen.
MIAMI, Sept 4, 2014--Masochistic might be the most aptly named thoroughbred ever. The dubious circumstances surrounding his racing career perfectly sum up racingâ€™s status in dealing with drugs.
Racing might be the only business whose leaders spend more time bad-mouthing their product than selling it. A summer of hysteria regarding race day medications is winding down. It was almost impossible to open a racing publication or website without being confronted by a piece on race day medications and why they should or shouldnâ€™t have to go.
But itâ€™s pointless to attempt to pass new rules and regulations when the ones in place are flaunted as if they are merely a nuisance, an acceptable cost of doing business? It took years and about 75 violations before Rick Dutrow was sent packing.
This brings us to the disgraceful saga of Masochistic and his connections. To briefly recap details I have reported several times, Masochistic was found to have 40 times the recommended dose of a tranquilizer when he made his debut at Santa Anita in a Cal-bred maiden special race on March 15.
He ran fifth of eight at 8-1. His jockey, Omar Berrio, was called in by the stewards and questioned about his less than all-out ride. In their notes, the stewards expressed concern that â€śMr. Berrio prevented his horse from giving his best effort.â€ť
Masochistic wasnâ€™t seen again until Derby Day at Churchill Downs. Off one lackluster effort in a Cal-bred race, he opened at odds-on in an open special weight on a day when it takes tens, if not hundreds, of thousands of dollars to rock the tote board to that extent. Masochistic drifted up to 2-1 and ran like 1-9, winning by 14 lengths.
Then he went back to his home base in California, where he could have made more purse money in a softer spot running against his own kind. This doesnâ€™t even take into consideration the shipping expenses to Kentucky and back.
Masochistic has scored a couple more blowout allowance wins without much urging. His dominance has been such that in his most recent start, Trevor Denman editorialized during his race call that Masochistic is too good for anything less than stakes horses.
Unbelievably, it took until mid-August before his trainer, A.C. Avila, was called in for a hearing about what went on in Masochisticâ€™s debut. He, of course, has been allowed to keep training in the interim. Even more unbelievably, it could be several months before a ruling is issued, according to a report in the Racing Form.
Forty times the legal limit of a tranquilizer, a ride for which â€śstiffedâ€ť is the most appropriate term, a betting coup and itâ€™s taking the better part of a year before a ruling is expected?
Itâ€™s enough to make O.J. Simpson exclaim, â€śWhat the fâ€¦?â€ť
Christie like all the rest
This was going to be a turnaround week for struggling Atlantic City casinos and New Jerseyâ€™s race tracks. The opening of the NFL season was going to mark the introduction of sports betting in New Jersey. That was the promise made by Gov. Chris Christie.
Christie likes to present himself as a different kind of politician, one who doesnâ€™t pull punches and says what he means and means what he says.
It turns out heâ€™s no different than all the rest, which is hardly a shock. The New Jersey governor went back on his word and sold out important constituencies by vetoing a bill, passed by overwhelming majorities in the Assembly and Senate, which would have enabled sports betting.
It was considered one of the last best hopes to keep Atlantic City from devolving into the sorry state it was in before it became the Eastâ€™s first mecca for casino gambling. The stateâ€™s racetracks, especially Monmouth Park, also would have benefitted.
Squeezed by neighboring states New York, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland and Connecticut legalizing casino gaming, New Jersey casinos are falling faster than sand castles on the beach at high tide. The Showboat closed this past Sunday. On Monday, the $2.4 billion Revel went belly up. The Trump Plaza is shutting down on Sept. 16. Earlier this year, the Atlantic City Hotel and Casino called it quits. They desperately needed a drawing card like sports betting that competitors in nearby states donâ€™t have.
It was Christie who ignited the push for sports gambling. Knowing full well that Congress passed a bill in 1992, the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA), which prohibited the expansion of sports betting, Christie arrogantly challenged the federal government in May 2012 to stand in his way. â€śIf someone wants to stop us, let them try.â€ť
Given the feds non-response to several states defying the laws against marijuana, he probably would have been on solid ground.
Subsequently, the Supreme Court this past June upheld the PASPA but left open a loophole. New Jersey could not specifically legalize sports betting but it was within its states rights to repeal laws outlawing it. New Jersey legislators jumped at the opening, only to have Christie, the man who said let them try to stop us, veto it.
â€śIgnoring federal law, rather than working to reform federal standards, is counter to our democratic traditions and inconsistent with the Constitutional values I have sworn to defend and protect,â€ť he said.
The flip-flop is easy to explain. Christie was facing a campaign for governor in 2012, so he played to New Jersey residents, who have indicated in straw polls that they overwhelmingly are in favor of sports gambling in the state. Now he is an undeclared candidate for President. Expansion of gambling is not necessarily a winning issue nationwide, especially with New Jersey being the only beneficiary.
Whatâ€™s more, Christie has been critical of the Obama administration for looking the other way when it comes to the legalization of marijuana. He would look like a world class hypocrite if he championed ignoring the federal laws against sports gambling.
Apparently he doesnâ€™t mind being known as only a state class hypocrite.
Written by Tom Jicha
Tuesday, August 26, 2014
‘Belief’ and ‘Chrome’ could be the new Alydar and Affirmed
Shared Belief's dominant score in the Pacific Classic answers the last question about his brilliance. He has won on synthetics and dirt. He has won at six furlongs and a mile and a quarter. He is the first of his generation to take on and put down older horses in an important race. But he still has one obstacle to overcome en route to a divisional Eclipse and Horse of the Year: Kentucky Derby and Preakness winner California Chrome. That showdown is expected to come in the Breeders' Cup Classic. Even casual fans should be excited about that.
MIAMI, Aug. 26--Nothing excites the masses and mitigates the negatives afflicting racing as much as the emergence of a potential superstar. In the case of Shared Belief, â€ťpotentialâ€ť might be short-changing him.
With his dominating triumph in the Pacific Classic on Sunday, Shared Belief has done everything necessary to qualify for the grandest superlatives.
He is already a champion, the 2013 Juvenile Eclipse winner.
He is undefeated and yet to be seriously tested. His almost three-length win Sunday was the closest call he has had. Previously no horse had come within four lengths of him at the wire.
The runner up at Del Mar, Toast of New York, came into the race with formidible credentials himself. His four synthetic starts produced three wins and a second, including a score in the UAE Derby.
Show horse Imperative, whose credits include a win the Charles Town Classic, was five back, a neck better than Game On Dude, this yearâ€™s Big Cap winner and the big horse in the West the past three years. The rest, most of them older stakes winners, were strung out to Carlsbad.
Shared Belief demonstrated he is multi-dimensional and able to overcome adversity. The son of Candy Ride had never been worse than third at any call in his previous five races. After a troubled start in the Pacific Classic, he was sixth down the backstretch, racing between horses. Mike Smith joked that Shared Belief gave the others a head start.
The Pacific Classic was run on a synthetic surface, Polytrack, but it was the third different artificial surface over which Shared Belief has triumphed.Unlike many synthetic specialists, he proved just as dominant on real dirt in the Los Alamitos Derby.
Prior to his ten-furlong score Sunday, he had won at six furlongs, seven furlongs, a mile and a sixteenth and a mile and an eighth.
Although Toast of New York also is a 3-year-old, Shared Belief is the first major North American 3-year-old to be tested by older stakes horses in a meaningful event.
There are no questions left for Shared Belief to answer.
Shared Belief is a gelding, so he could be around to energize the racing scene for years. Itâ€™s a bonus that his majority owner is Jim Rome. His sports talk show is one of the nationâ€™s most popular. Rome will be talking up Shared Belief to the young males racing needs to reach.
It had to be a disappointment to Rome that foot ailments kept Shared Belief out of the Triple Crown but he could be going for his own unique triple in the Breedersâ€™ Cup. His filly Mizdirection won the Turf Sprint, beating males, the past two years.
Perhaps the best part for racing is that Shared Belief has an outstanding rival, California Chrome, to stir interest among even casual fans. Alydar made people appreciate Affirmed more. Muhammad Ali and Joe Frazier had each other. Magic had Larry Bird.
For all that Shared Belief has accomplished, if the Eclipse balloting was held now, California Chrome would be voted the 3-year-old championship, just as the last 16 winners of the Kentucky Derby and Preakness have been. California Chrome has the Grade 1 Santa Anita Derby to go with his Triple Crown heroics. The Pacific Classic was Shared Belief's first Grade 1.
That election wonâ€™t take place until after the Breedersâ€™ Cup Classic, when assuming good health, the two extraordinary 3-year-olds will face off for the first time. Not only divisional honors will be up for grabs but Horse of the Year as well, should either win.
V.E. Dayâ€™s upset in the Travers effectively took all the Eastern 3-year-olds out of the running.
Even if only one of the Westâ€™s stars makes it to Santa Anita on Nov. 1, a win against older horses such as Palace Malice, Moreno and Will Take Charge, would clinch the two awards. Not even a late-season streak by two-time defending champion Wise Dan would change that.
Shared Belief and California Chrome are each expected to have one tune-up before their showdown. Shared Beliefâ€™s will most likely come against older competition in the Awesome Again on Sept. 27. This will give him a trip over Santa Anitaâ€™s dirt track.
California Chromeâ€™s connections will follow the money to the Pennsylvania Derby, which is limited to 3-year-olds, a week previously.
The Parx race has a million dollar pot but thereâ€™s an additional lure for California Chromeâ€™s owners, Steve Coburn and Perry Martin, who are in the process of squandering a lot of the good will they enjoyed on the Triple Crown trail.
First there was Martinâ€™s boycott of the Preakness because he wasnâ€™t treated well at the Derby. Then Coburn went bat-dung crazy because fresher colts denied California Chrome the Triple Crown. Next they demanded $50,000 from Del Mar for California Chrome to parade on Pacific Classic Day. (In retrospect, imagine how embarrassing it would have been for California Chrome to just parade before his rival Shared Belief put on a real show in the big race.)
For taking their colt across country to a race that can only tarnish his luster should he not win as an overwhelming favorite, they will get what amounts to a $100,000 appearance fee. This is on top of anything California Chrome earns.
Trainer Art Sherman also gets an extra hundred grand when California Chrome leaves the starting gate. It will be interesting to see the reaction from Coburn and Perry when they realize they are splitting $100K while Sherman gets the full amount all for himself.
Written by Tom Jicha