Tuesday, July 28, 2015
Haskell has big horse but Spa has ‘Dandy’ of a race
American Pharoah will be the center of attention in Monmouth's Haskell this weekend but the best race for 3-year-olds will be the Jim Dandy Saturday at Saratoga. Grade 1 winners Frosted, Materiality and Texas Red are expected along with Holy Bull winner and Florida Derby runnerup Upstart and Bill Mott's star on the rise Japan. On Wednesday, Mott will attempt to extend his remarkable record of success on his birthday.
SARATOGA SPRINGS, July 28, 2015â€”Monmouth has Americaâ€™s best 3-year-old this coming weekend but Saratoga has the best 3-year-old race.
Iâ€™m not going to behave like a politician and say I was for something before I was against it. I wrote a couple of weeks ago that an outstanding horse outweighs an outstanding race. Iâ€™m not going to back off that. This weekend will provide the collaborating evidence.
NYRA would trade every formerly free picnic table now for rent in the backyard for the opportunity to cap attendance (which Monmouth isnâ€™t going to do) for an American Pharoah appearance in Saturdayâ€™s Jim Dandy rather than see The Triple Crown winner draw the biggest crowd in New Jersey racing history to Monmouthâ€™s Haskell on Sunday.
But the Haskell looms a non-competitive exhibition while the Jim Dandy is arguably the best 3-year-old race since the Kentucky Derby. Wood Memorial winner Frosted is scheduled to make his first start since pushing American Pharoah to his completion of the Triple Crown in the Belmont.
Breedersâ€™ Cup Juvenile champion Texas Red, who didnâ€™t make the Kentucky Derby due to an injury, is using the Jim Dandy as his prep for the Midsummer Derby, the Aug. 29 Travers.
Materiality, who pushed his unbeaten record to three in the Florida Derby. will attempt to get back on track after disappointing showings in the Kentucky Derby and Belmont. Itâ€™s probably not prudent to overlook anything coming out of the Todd Pletcher barn these days.
He seems to win even when he doesnâ€™t. The multiple Eclipse winner came up with three big scores over the past week without getting to the wire first. Uncle Vinny got kissed into top money for an incident that didnâ€™t affect him in any way in the opening day Sanford at the Spa.
Magna Light led the field all the way but, as 2-year-olds are wont to do, started acting like a goofball. veering out several paths in mid-stretch then coming back in late. He might have been clear enough to avoid penalty when he came out but he definitely caused Percolator, his closest pursuer, to check and lose the place when he veered back in. This opened the door for Pletcherâ€™s Uncle Vinny, coming down the middle of the track, to finish second without really menacing Uncle Vinny. So instead of running third, Uncle Vinny had a graded win handed to him.
Two days later Pletcher got put up again in the Coaching Club American Oaks when front-running Iâ€™m a Chatterbox came out and brushed Curalina in the shadow of the wire. The DQ was justifiable but it happened so close to the finish it wouldnâ€™t have been the worst â€śas isâ€ť if the stewards had taken that route.
Pletcherâ€™s roll extended to being on the right side of a non-disqualification in the 2014 Delaware Handicap. You might not have heard of this because Delaware kept it on the down low. Princess of Sylmarâ€™s $150,000 second place earnings had been held up for more than a year because of an overage of betamethasone. The permissible corticosteroid is used to treat inflammation from joint disease and arthritis but cannot be in a horseâ€™s system on race day.
Pletrcher and Princess of Sylmarâ€™s owners fought the ruling on complicated grounds regarding the clarity of the rule. Delaware state officials finally decided to drop the charges and release the purse.
Pletcher has not had a drug ruling since 2010. Ergo, he is worthy of being given the benefit of the doubt. But less prominent trainers couldnâ€™t be blamed for wondering if they would have been given the same consideration.
Getting back to the Jim Dandy, another multiple Eclipse winner, Bill Mott, will have an intriguing new shooter to the top ranks of the 3-year-old division. Japan broke through with his first stakes triumph in the Easy Goer on the Belmont Stakes undercard. The place horse, Stanford, figures to be the favorite for Pletcher in Fridayâ€™s Curlin Stakes.
After the Easy Goer, Mott said he might have run Japan in the wrong race, suggesting he thought Japan was worthy of taking on American Pharoah in the Belmont. Coming from someone as accomplished and low key as Mott, this is quite an endorsement, certainly enough to consider taking a decent price in a stakes that doesnâ€™t include American Pharoah.
Mott, who won four races in the first three days of the meet, will be the center of attention on Wednesday, his 62nd birthday, because of a streak that has become a closely monitored diversion at the Spa.
Seven straight times and in 15 of the past 20 Saratoga seasons he has won a race on his birthday (July 29 fell on a dark day in some years, including 2014). Mott said he is amused and amazed at the attention it has gotten.
Last time his birthday fell on a race day, 2013, he had five starters and won with the final two. He has no margin of error this year. He'â€™ll have only one chance, First Charmer in the seventh race, a maiden special for New York breds.
First Charmer is 12-1 on the morning line but Mottâ€™s streak has been so thoroughly reported in the Racing Form and local Saratoga papers, it will be a surprise if he goes to the post at even half that price.
Written by Tom Jicha
Tuesday, July 21, 2015
Clearing the boards for Saratoga
It appears American Pharoah is heading for double duty as a stud next year, with a possible trip to Australia on his agenda. So much for him racing as a 4-year-old. Meanwhile, Lasix-free races and winter racing at Aqueduct got boosts during the past week, proponents of synthetic tracks got a chance to say, "I told you so," and another serial jockey cheater was busted again.
MIAMI, July 21, 2015--The dream of American Pharoah racing as a 4-year-old has apparently been dashed. In a story picked up by Equidaily.com, The Daily Telegraph in Australia reports there are secret plans to ship the Triple Crown champion down under next year for Australiaâ€™s breeding season, which begins in the Southern Hemisphere almost as soon as our breeding season ends.
Financially, it makes sense to double down in two hemispheres. Our most recent Triple Crown winners had spotty records as sires. So Coolmore, which takes control of American Pharoah at the end of this year, could bank a big part of its investment before any of American Pharoah's foals hit the ground. It also doubles the chances that he will produce some offspring as brilliant as he is.
As for the boost his continued presence would give American racing, when has that ever mattered to breeders?
Issues that need addressing
This column is going to be almost all about Saratoga for the next six weeks, so let me get some other things off my chest while awaiting Friday the way a kid counts down to Christmas.
Del Mar had off-tracks over the weekend for the first time since Noah. Ironically, the deluge that caused them came in the midst of one of the worst droughts California has ever endured.
Letâ€™s hope this doesnâ€™t trigger a chorus of â€śthey should have kept the synthetic track.â€ť Itâ€™s great to have Del Mar back in the mainstream of racing. A couple of off-tracks every millennium is a small price to pay.
Who needs Lasix?
Gulfstream carded races for 2-year-olds running without Lasix on Saturday and Sunday. They oversubscribed, leading to splits. This would seem to verify that there are a significant number of horsemen willing to run without juice but hesitant to do so because they fear they are giving away an edge.
Better yet, the Lasix-free races outhandled most of the other races. Letâ€™s hope other tracks take note.
Anti-doping bill has long way to go
Along the same lines, itâ€™s encouraging that the optimistically titled Horse Racing Integrity Act of 2015, which would put all drug testing in the hands of the U.S. Anti-Doping Agency, has been introduced in Congress by Rep. Andy Barr (R, KY) and Rep. Paul Tonko (D, NY).
However, itâ€™s a long way to the finish line. Predictably it was greeted almost immediately by a negative reaction from the National HBPA. â€śWe are opposed to any form of legislation that interferes with the Interstate Horse Racing Act of 1978,â€ť Eric Hamelback, the organizationâ€™s chief executive officer, was quoted as saying.
Itâ€™s not clear that the proposed bill would do that but the HBPA doesnâ€™t want to risk losing the extortionate hammer it never should have been given to deny a trackâ€™s right to simulcast--in other words, put it out of business--if it doesnâ€™t get everything it wants. It used this power to keep the Breedersâ€™ Cup from implementing Lasix-free races at its championship event.
Buzzers should be one-and-done
Drugs arenâ€™t the only scourge challenging racingâ€™s integrity, maybe not even the worst. Jockey Billy Patin and his brother, Joe Patin Jr., are under investigation in Louisiana for allegedly using â€śbuzzersâ€ť in recent races at Evangeline Downs.
If the name Billy Patin rings a bell, he was suspended for five years for allegedly using a battery in riding 30-1 Valhol to victory in the 1999 Arkansas Derby. How and why he was ever re-licensed is unfathomable.
But itâ€™s not unprecedented. Roman Chapa has been suspended for five years for the second time for the same alleged offense in a race in Texas last January. Chapa also got nine months in 2007 for allegedly using a nail on a horse.
These should be one-and-done offenses. A horse is more likely to put his life in jeopardy by doing something erratic when being hit by a machine or a nail than he is for a drug overage.
CDI up to its usual tricks
The Arlington Millionâ€™s days appear numbered, likely in low single digits. Churchill Downs Inc. failed in its attempt to get fewer than eight-race cards approved at Arlington but itâ€™s revealing that it even tried.
The only thing keeping the Chicago area jewel from suffering the same fate as Hollywood Park and Calder at the hands of CDI is the presence of Richard Duchossois, father of the track and the Million and a major CDI stock holder, who will be 94 in October.
Parx break a boon to Aqueduct
Any chances winter racing at Aqueduct will be curtailed or discontinued in the near future probably ended with the announcement that starting in the upcoming winter, Parx will institute a break--Dec. 22 to Feb. 13 in 2015-16â€”as part of a scaling back of its racing calendar from 210 dates to 156.
With the only other racing north of Florida at Laurel in Maryland, NYRA should have plenty of horses to fill its cold weather cards. It might even be able to return to five days a week.
The DQ debate continues
California held a hearing on creating new guidelines for disqualifications last week. Surprise! They couldnâ€™t agree. The same old debate arose. Is a foul a foul or should the impact it had on the race be the deciding factor.
Iâ€™m in the corner of those who go with the latter. The counter-argument is this forces the stewards to play God. But isnâ€™t this what they are doing in any case?
One area where there seems to be a consensus is a horse should not be taken down unless the vote of the stewards is unanimous. Let's hope this comes to fruition and is adopted everywhere.
A third pre-BC race for Pharoah?
Getting back to American Pharoah, Ahmed Zayat says he would like to take him to Saratoga for the Travers on Aug. 29 if all goes well in the Haskell on Aug. 2. I donâ€™t doubt his sincerity but I canâ€™t see it happening unless the game plan for only two races before the Breedersâ€™ Cup Classic is abandoned. The Travers is nine weeks from the Breedersâ€™ Cup, so Bob Baffert would probably want to find another race in the interim.
If this happens, Zayat and Baffert get my Eclipse votes for Owner and Trainer of the Year in addition to the 3-year-old and Horse of the Year titles. Not that they wonâ€™t get them anyway.
How many hours until Saratoga?
Written by Tom Jicha
Tuesday, July 14, 2015
A big horse outweighs big races
Monmouth is preparing for the biggest crowd in its history (including the 2007 Breeders' Cup) when American Pharoah goes in the Haskell on Aug. 2. Huge throngs showed up to see him merely parade at Churchill Downs and Santa Anita. This extraordinary star power is more important than ever to racing with California Chrome, Lady Eli and Main Sequence bowing out with injuries over the past few days. If there is a way to keep the Triple Crown winner on the track as a 4-year-old, it must be explored.
MIAMI, July 14, 2015--A great horse trumps great racingâ€¦and itâ€™s not a close call. The American Pharoah experience establishes this beyond debate. Huge crowds have shown up at Churchill Downs and Santa Anita just to see him paraded.
Now Monmouth Park is preparing for the biggest day in its history on Aug 2 when American Pharoah returns to the races in the Haskell. As many as 60,000 fans are expected, dwarfing even the 2007 Breedersâ€™ Cup. (Note to NYRAâ€™s Christopher Kay: There will be no cap on attendance, no matter what.)
In fact, Monmouthâ€™s biggest crowd was not for either of the Breedersâ€™ Cup days but for the 2003 Haskell when another peopleâ€™s horse, Derby and Preakness winner Funny Cide, made his first post-Triple Crown appearance. (Alas, he ran third to Peace Rules and Sky Mesa).
To the credit of Ahmed Zayat and Bob Baffert, they have not held up Monmouth for any enhancements to the $1 million Haskell purse. They will get $75,000 apiece in bonus money because American Pharoah won three Triple Crown races but this is available every year to owners and trainers of the winners of the Derby, Preakness and Belmont.
The same canâ€™t be said of Monmouth management, which is jacking up every price it can. Admission is normally $3 grandstand, $5 clubhouse. On Aug. 2, it will be $6 and $9. This isnâ€™t awful for the biggest day of the year. Almost every track does it.
However, what Monmouth is doing with parking is unforgivable. General parking is normally $6, according to the Monmouth website. Valet is $10. On Haskell Day, it will be $20 general, $40 valet.
The disingenuous justification by Robert Kulina, president of the company that runs the joint, is insulting. Stealing a page from Kay, who says he is charging for Saratoga picnic tables, which have always been free, as a service to fans, Kulina said the steep hike in parking is for the fans' sake, to encourage people to car pool or take mass transportation to the track.
â€śHorse-pucky,â€ť as Col. Potter used to say on M*A*S*H. Kulina knows many, if not most fans canâ€™t convene a crowd of fellow race-goers to car pool. If this was truly the goal, every car with four or more fans would get a break in price.
Mass transportation is even less of an option for many. Weâ€™re talking the Jersey Shore, not the west side of Manhattan. If an atypically large number did take mass transit, the Long Island Railroad nightmare at the 2014 Belmont would be a day at the beach by comparison.
Kulina knows every spot will be filled in his lots and heâ€™s going to gouge fans for as many dollars as he can.
Getting back to the reason for the anticipated record crowd, American Pharoah, it underlines the value of star power to racing. Loyalists are attracted by great races. The masses are drawn by great horses.
Unfortunately, racingâ€™s biggest stars keep dropping.
Shared Belief was a superstar in the making. Weâ€™ve lost him for at least the rest of this year. Even if he returns, it will take time to rebuild his reputation.
California Chrome was another crowd magnet. It was announced Monday that heâ€™s gone, too, for at least this year. The only upside to this downer is that he is so unfashionably bred, he might come back as a 5-year-old in a bid to strengthen his allure to breeders.
It also was revealed Monday that undefeated Lady Eliâ€™s racing career is probably over and she is fighting for her life because of laminitis. Fans donâ€™t get as excited by great fillies not named Rachel Alexandra or Zenyatta but Lady Eli is still a dispiriting loss to the sport.
Fans awoke Tuesday to learn that double Eclipse winner Main Sequence has a tendon injury and has been retired. Thatâ€™s two Breedersâ€™ Cup champions and a Kentucky Derby winner lost within a couple of days.
Thankfully, racingâ€™s biggest star is still on the track. If there is a way, any way, to get the people who will take control of American Pharoah to race him as a 4-year-old, every effort should be made.
He could generate $10 million or more in the breeding shed next year but with a $10 million race in Dubai (the sheiks might go for a couple of million just to get him there) and a $6 million Breedersâ€™ Cup Classic sandwiching numerous other seven-figure purses that would be thrown at him, it might be possible to match his 2016 earning potential as a stud.
Even Canterbury Downs is willing to put up a $2 million pot to get him to Minnesota.
Iâ€™ll bet Frank Stronach would considerably sweeten the purse of the Donn to get American Pharoah to South Florida next winter. How about a Stronach-owned tracks Triple Crownâ€”the Donn, Santa Anitaâ€™s Big Cap and Pimlico Specialâ€”with a seven-figure bonus for a sweep that would move the total haul close to $5 million.
NYRA throws around casino-driven purse money as if itâ€™s trying to launder cash. If it can come up with $2 million for a couple of turf races for 3-year-olds on July 4th weekend, surely it could come up with just as much for a real spectacular featuring a Triple Crown winner. Which do you suppose would bring more people to Long Island, the Belmont Derby and Oaks or American Pharoah?
Then thereâ€™s TV money, a relative pittance for even the most prestigious races outside the Triple Crown. But put American Pharoah in the field and the telecast moves from second tier cable channels to the major broadcast networks, with a corresponding hike in license fees.
Of course any chance to keep American Pharoah racing for another season would be dependent on a surrender of selfishness and prioritizing the good of the game by his ownership group.
â€śYou may say Iâ€™m a dreamer but (I hope) Iâ€™m not the only one.â€ť
Written by Tom Jicha