Tuesday, August 18, 2015
Stewards play God, let them take it all the way
Last Saturday's Beverly D produced the same unfortunate result as the Sanford Stakes at Saratoga a couple of weeks ago. A horse, who had no shot to win and wasn't involved in an incident of interference, got put up to first while the victim wound up with the same placing he or she would have had absent the foul. There is no justice in this. Stewards have discretion to decide where to place a horse who has committed a foul. In obvious cases, why not use the same judgment to move a victimized horse up to where he or she would have finished if not for the interference?
MIAMI, Aug. 18, 2015--There has to be a better way.
For at least the second time in two weeks, a horse, who was going to be no better than third, got kissed into a graded stakes win.
Watsdachances was the latest beneficiary in Saturdayâ€™s Beverly D, one of the most prestigious turf races in the world for fillies and mares. She is now a Grade 1 winner, which is worth more long term than the winnerâ€™s share of the $700,000 purse.
In two previous attempts to break through into racingâ€™s highest classification, Watsdachances failed to hit the board, running fourth twice. She was going to improve on that in the Beverly D with a third-place finish until Secret Gesture, who had taken the lead in mid-stretch and was on her way to an apparent victory, got goofy late. She veered sharply to the right, into the path of Stephanieâ€™s Kitten, who seemingly had the place locked up but wasnâ€™t going to catch the leader.
Irad Ortiz on Stephanieâ€™s Kitten made the incident look worse than it was with an overly dramatic stand up and snatch up, a commonplace move for riders hoping they might convince stewards to do what their mounts couldnâ€™t. Ortizâ€™s theatrics probably cost Stephanieâ€™s Kitten the place more than Secret Gesture coming out did.
Meanwhile, Watsdachances was closing on the inside. She was clearly no threat to the first two but with Ortiz more intent on putting on his act than riding to the finish, Watsdachances got up in the last jump to grab second.
There really never was much doubt Secret Gesture was going to come down, even though Stephanieâ€™s Kitten was not going to catch her. So the best horse got put back to third and the horse, who was going to finish third under any circumstances, wound up getting elevated to the win.
A similar situation occurred at Saratoga on July 25 in the Sanford Stakes. Magna Light had the race won when he began some broken field running. He went out about six paths, though arguably clear, then came back in and forced Percolator, running second at the time, to hesitate briefly. Uncle Vinny out in the middle of the track well away from the contretemps nailed Percolator on the line for the place.
Again, it was clear the winner had to come down. But the fouled horse got the same position he was going to get anyway and a horse, who happened to be in the right spot, got boosted to first.
In both cases, bettors got screwed. This was especially true at Arlington, where those who backed Stephanieâ€™s Kitten, the victim, didnâ€™t benefit at all from the DQ.
Everything stewards do involves judgment. There should be a way in instances such as these where they could exercise their discretion and place the fouled horse ahead of one who wasnâ€™t involved in the incident. To be specific, Stephanieâ€™s Kitten should have been given the win, since anyone who saw the race knew she was going to finish ahead of Watsdachances.
It would have been a closer call in the Sanford but Percolator arguably should have been placed ahead of Uncle Vinny.
Sure, this would be playing God. But isnâ€™t that what the stewards do whenever there is a claim of foul? Some of the longest waits for a decisionâ€”is it just me or are these getting ridiculously long even when the outcome is obvious?â€”involve not whether there will be a DQ but how far back to place the offending horse. If stewards can do that, why not how far up they can place a victimized horse. This wouldnâ€™t have to happen in every DQ, just the ones where it's obvious justice isnâ€™t being served.
Better yet, in a case like the Beverly D, where the best horse finished first, let the result stand for betting purposes. Then take the purse difference between second and third money from the connections of Secret Garden and award it to the owners of Stephanieâ€™s Kitten.
Euros are just better
A couple of other thoughts from Arlington Million Day.
Iâ€™m putting a line through American horses in Breedersâ€™ Cup turf races this fall. Not that I don't do that most years. The one exception would be if Wise Dan, who is supposed to launch his comeback next month, returns to his old form.
It was reinforced again that Euro horses are pounds better than the best turfers on this side of the Atlantic. Euros finished first in three of the four major events and the invaders werenâ€™t exactly superstars on their own terrain. European horsemen know they don't need their best to beat our best.
Letâ€™s not forget that Main Sequence, who shipped to the United States and won four Grade 1 stakes in a row to clinch the Eclipse as Americaâ€™s top turf horse last year was on a 10-race losing streak when he arrived on our shores. His strongest European credential was a Group 3 win.
The Pizza Man saved Uncle Samâ€™s squad from a shutout but the five Euros he ran past had a total of three Group wins among them. Two were in Germany, not exactly Europeâ€™s major league.
Moreover, The Pizza Man is an ultimate horse for course. The Million was his 10th win in 13 starts over the Arlington turf course. Unless the Breedersâ€™ Cup is shifted from Keeneland to Arlington, he wonâ€™t be on any of my tickets.
Since I try not to miss opportunities to note that overly conservative trainers are the bane of racing and a major reason for short fields, it needs to be pointed out that Secretariat winner Highland Reel was coming back in 17 days from a stakes win in England. He also had to overcome a trans-Atlantic flight and quarantine.
Highland Reel is conditioned by Aidan Oâ€™Brien. What does he know about training horses?
Written by Tom Jicha
Tuesday, August 11, 2015
NYRA wants guarantee but fans don’t get one
It remains uncertain whether American Pharoah will run in the Aug. 29 Travers at Saratoga. Bob Baffert has been sending mixed feelings. However, by instituting a crowd cap of 50,000, NYRA is assuring the biggest Travers crowd in a dozen years whether or not the Triple Crown winner shows up. Meanwhile, fans are being essentially forced to buy tickets in advance not knowing whether they will get to see the champion.
MIAMI, Aug. 11, 2015--NYRA is up to a new old trick with its attendance cap of 50,000 for the Travers. There is no guarantee American Pharoah is going to show up but Christopher Kay wants a guarantee that heâ€™ll get an American Pharoah turnout.
The NYRA CEO did the same thing with the Belmont Stakes. The 90,000 cap for the Belmont wasnâ€™t put into place after American Pharoah won the first two jewels of the Triple Crown. It was announced only a few days after the Kentucky Derby, when the possibility of a Triple Crown bid was still only a fond hope.
The limit was disingenuously billed as a service to fans, a move to avoid the nightmarish experience more than 100,000 fans experienced at the 2014 Belmont. If this was true, it was an indictment of management being unable to come up with a crowd control plan despite having a full year to do so.
Itâ€™s not as if more than 100,000 hadnâ€™t attended previous Belmonts. It happened three straight times between 2002 and 2004 as War Emblem, Funny Cide and Smarty Jones tried to complete the elusive sweep. More than 120,000 supposedly were on hand for Smarty Jonesâ€™ bid. But Kay's NYRA admitted it was incapable of handling a crowd bigger than three-quarters as large.
In fact, the cap was an attempt to guarantee paid attendance of at least 90,000 just in case there was no Triple Crown on the line. â€śBuy your tickets now or you could be shut out of an historic event.â€ť
There has never been a crowd of 90,000 in years without a Triple Crown possibility. The closest was 85,811 in 2012 and comes with an asterisk. Iâ€™ll Have Another scratched the day before the race, so many big event race-goers showed up unaware there was no chance history would be made.
Attendance for previous Belmonts without a Triple Crown on the line averaged just a bit more than 50,000. So the business built on gambling decided it didnâ€™t want to gamble on the crowd.
The same tactic is being utilized for the Travers. Ahmed Zayatâ€™s hope that American Pharoah would run in the Travers was barely out of his mouth when NYRA announced the 50,000 cap, urging fans to buy tickets immediately to avoid being shut out.
Although the 60,000 barrier was exceeded for the Travers in 2001 and 2003, there hasnâ€™t been a crowd of 50,000 since. Last year it was 46,557, down from 47,597 in 2013. The latter was the biggest attendance since 48,899 showed up in 2004.
Just as a Triple Crown bid was uncertain when the Belmont cap was announced, it is far from a certainty that American Pharoah will run on Aug. 29. Zayat made it clear the decision is entirely up to Bob Baffert.
The trainer has been sending mixed signals. â€śWeâ€™re trying to make it but heâ€™s going to have to really convince me,â€ť Baffert told the NYRA publicity department Monday . â€śI have to be all in and feel really confident, because if he comes here I know heâ€™s going to have to run hard. Itâ€™s a tough demanding racetrack. But heâ€™s handled everything thrown at him so far. Heâ€™s been such a special horse and has this following now. I want to make sure I do the right thing.â€ť
Unsaid was how the Travers fits into having American Pharoah ready for his ultimate goal, the Breeders Cup Classic on Oct. 31. There is a nine-week gap between the two races, not the ideal scenario. It would likely necessitate another race in the interim, probably the Awesome Again at Santa Anita, his home base, on Sept. 26, since Zayat has said he has no interest in the Pennsylvania Derby. After the Belmont, Zayat and Baffert said they wanted only two races before the Breeders Cup.
With the cap in place, NYRA doesnâ€™t care whether American Pharoah comes. The tickets will be sold. Situations such as this inspired the phrase caveat emptor (let the buyer beware).
Mixed emotions about Calder's demolition
The old saying goes, â€śMixed emotions is watching your mother-in-law drive your Cadillac off a cliff.â€ť
I experienced a similar feeling during the past week with news that Churchill Downs Inc. plans to demolish the Calder grandstand after the casino-saving Gulfstream West meeting this fall.
Calder was much too antiseptic and charmless to be beloved. But because of its eight-month season, I spent more time there than at any other track and I made some great friends.
Marketing director Mike Cronin invented the Summit of Speed to keep Calder on the map during the summer. His savvy and personable boss, Ken Dunn, is sorely missed running racetracks. Publicity director Michele Blanco was as deservedly treasured by Churchill Downs Inc. as she was disgusted with it. It got to the stage that Michelle left the only business she had known from growing up on the backside in a racing family. The late linemaker/chart caller Chuck Streva, one of the truly good guys, worked all the tracks but fondly called Calder "home." He was taken much too early from us. Publicist Jack Will knows more about racing and racing people than anyone I have ever known. Also not to be forgotten is Damon Runyon track handicapper Dirk â€śDr. Doomâ€ť Ackerman, who hung the nickname (affectionately I think) Tiny Terror on me. After Dirk passed away, I adopted it as my fantasy stable name in tribute to his memory.
Those were just a few of the people who brought warmth to the cold Calder building.
On the other hand, it feels good to be rid of the remnants of CDI, as miserable a bunch of people as you would expect from this company. However, itâ€™s infuriating that CDI is being allowed by the state to retain its casino even though it is out of the racing business in Florida.
Also, Gulfstream is doing such a better job serving the sport and its fans. This was driven home again Saturday. The first stage of the annual Florida Sire Stakes (nee Stallion Stakes) showed a 35% increase in total handle and almost a 26% increase on track over its last renewal.
It has been this way since Gulfstream went to an almost year-round schedule. The brand is better known and valued nationwide by fans, and horsemen have responded enthusiastically to being treated as if they are valued, not tolerated.
Given the problems confronting summer tracks elsewhere, most notably Chicago and, to a lesser extent New Jersey, racing is only going to get better during the warm weather months and the premier winter season is second to none.
Iâ€™m still not a fan of year-round racing at one venue (the Gulfstream West meeting will endure only until the state decouples racing from casinos). But under Tim Ritvo's team, Gulfstream is doing it as well as it can be done.
So whatever warm feelings I have for Calder, they are mitigated by being rid of Churchill Downs as well as the knowledge that South Florida racing is in so much a better place.
Written by Tom Jicha
Tuesday, August 04, 2015
NYRA hits new lows in customer abuse
Nothing appears beneath NYRA when it comes to squeezing every penny out of fans. The latest outrage is charging handicapped fans $7-$15 to park in a lot that is otherwise free. Meanwhile, any thoughts that there ever will be meaningful inter-track cooperation on anything significant is a fantasy,demonstrated by Saratoga, Monmouth and Mountaineer each staging rich races for 3-year-olds within 24 hours.
SARATOGA SPRINGS, Aug. 5, 2015--NYRA has concocted its most vile means yet to squeeze a few extra bucks out of fans at Saratoga.
My family stages an unofficial reunion every summer at the Spa. A couple of years ago, there were so many of us, all wearing colorful shirts designed by my creative niece, that the Albany ABC affiliate took notice and did a feature story on the news on us.
One member of my family now has to get around by electric scooter. When she parked her van, outfitted with a carrier on the back, in the handicapped section of the lot, which is supposed to be free, an attendant came galloping over to inform her, â€śHandicapped parking has to be paid for this year.â€ť The tariff is not cheap: $7 weekdays, $10 weekends and $15 on Travers Day.
This is not trackside parking. This is the first lot you come to off the Northway on Union Avenue. It is more than a quarter-mile from the nearest admission gate.
The attendant was embarrassed and apologetic but said the money had to be collected. My relative was so incensed that she went to customer service as soon as she got into the track. The women there didnâ€™t believe it and thought it was a mistake by the people at the lot. â€śLet me call my boss.â€ť Her boss, also apologetic, said the order came down from the top.
My relative is pondering an Americans With Disability Act complaint. I hope she follows through.
The abuse of customers doesnâ€™t end there. Sunday, my mother, who will be 90 in a few months, had a small umbrella to shield her from the scorching sun at the Top of the Stretch. (All the shade areas were occupied.) A security officer came over and said she had to take it down for safety reasons.
This was not a beach umbrella, more like something you would carry in the rain. Nevertheless, it had to go, she was told. We were not near the rail, where a gust of wind could have blown it onto the track. We were sufficient distance from the fence that it would have taken Hurricane Andrew to do that.
Right nearby, there were about 20 huge Coors Light umbrellas, some right next to the rail, in the cubicles NYRA has fenced off as a revenue generator. The difference: NYRA gets hundreds of dollars to rent them. Supposed safety must not be an issue when the bottom line is.
Howâ€™s this for more penny-pinching? On Wednesday, the restrooms nearest the Top of the Stretch were locked before the last race. On Friday, the ladies room was locked with two races to go. (A monsoon struck on Thursday, so I skipped the track for the friendly OTB in Lake George.)
I didnâ€™t know the attendants, who sit there looking for tips, were paid so much that knocking them off an hour early is a major savings for NYRA.
These outrages happen because Saratoga for the most part is such an addictive experience that management is confident people might complain but they will keep coming back.
I plead guilty.
Cooperation is a drean-on fantasy
American Pharoah is so awesome that he covers up a lot of racingâ€™s ills.
The notion that racetracks will ever cooperate on anything beyond the trivial is nothing more than a wonderful fantasy. The every man for himself philosophy, which has prevailed longer than the electronic starting gate, was driven home again this past weekend. Saratoga, Monmouth and Mountaineer ran huge money races for 3-year-olds, which only served to cannibalize each other.
Saratoga put up $600,000 for the Jim Dandy and wound up with a four-horse field. Not only did this detract from the spectacle of the event, it put a hurting on the bottom line. Superfecta and show betting had to be canceled and the multiple race pools took severe hits from the dearth of possible combinations.
The nemesis of the Jim Dandy, of course, was the $1.75 million Monmouth was hanging out for the Haskell. Even with American Pharoah looming unbeatable, second money was almost the equivalent of winning the Jim Dandy. This directly swiped Competitive Edge and Upstart, who were cross-entered, and perhaps another one or two, who might have showed up for the Travers prep.
Monmouth made its showcase race even more attractive by jacking up the purse by $750,000 only a day or two before entries were taken. Why is baffling. It already had the Triple Crown champion locked up and the enhancement could have bolstered the purse of 250 overnight races by $3,000 apiece.
The explanation was the extra $750K was consolation for Monmouthâ€™s inability to close the deal on a multi-million series designed to attract American Pharoah. Makes you wonder if the Pharoahâ€™s connections knew about the richer endowment when they made the decision to come to New Jersey. But nobody else did.
Not to be outdone, NYRA announced it will raise the purse of the Travers to $1.6 million if American Pharoah shows up on Aug. 29.
The $750,000 West Virginia Derby only aggravated the situation. Why Mountaineer, which runs almost year-round, chose Saturday to put up the richest purse of the year is another mystery. It surely didnâ€™t get value. The field it attracted could have been lured for a third or less of the purse.
Thank goodness Del Mar doesnâ€™t have a significant dirt race for sophomores, something that has always been an inexplicable hole in its schedule.
The fierce scrimmage for top tier horses could have been avoided with some inter-track cooperation. NYRA is more or less locked into running the Jim Dandy four weeks before the Travers. But Monmouth has all summer to run the Haskell.
On one hand, itâ€™s understandable that the New Jersey track would want to stage its biggest event when there is no other racing in the New York City area. But a July 4th Haskell has potential advantages to offset this.
It would be a stage-setter for summer racing on the tourist rich Jersey shore, rather than an attraction so late in the meeting that any momentum it generates is mitigated. It also would be a perfect fit for contemporary training techniques; about four weeks after the Belmont with approximately the same gap to the Jim Dandy.
Another facet of the inter-track rivalry also erupted in the last week. NYRA announced it is dropping the simulcast signals of Churchill Downs controlled tracks in the usual dispute over pricing. With the exception of the Arlington Million card on Aug. 15, this is a ho-hummer for most fans. However, it is inexcusable that two behemoth corporations canâ€™t come to agreement for the good of the game and more importantly, fans.
Written by Tom Jicha