Thursday, June 11, 2015
Case closed on the Triple Crown spacing
American Pharoah not only made history by sweeping the Triple Crown, he made certain that history wouldn't be tampered with. The arguments that the five weeks of the Triple Crown made it impossible to win were demolished, hopefully forever. As Bob Baffert said, all it takes is a superior horse, which is exactly how it should be.
MIAMI, June 11, 2015--Two words for those who have been saying the relatively brief spacing of the Triple Crown makes it impossible to conquer: Go away!
To elaborate: Go away and donâ€™t come back! I donâ€™t want to hear it, ever again. As anyone who reads this column knows, I never believed it. All it takes, all it ever took, is an extraordinary horse; a horse like American Pharoah.
â€śFor a while.I was starting to think maybe it's never going to happen,â€ť Bob Baffert said Sunday. â€śIt's changed, it's too tough ... maybe it's the breed. It's not the breed. You just have to wait for these superior horses to come around. They don't come around that often.â€ť
Baffert is pleased to have put this bellyaching to rest. "I think the Triple Crown has to stay the same,â€ť he said. â€ťIf you spread it out, it would lose its build. Once the Derby is run, everyone starts getting on board. You want it to stay in a short time frame.â€ť
American Pharoah was the only horse to run in all three races. For good measure, he also won the final major prep, the Arkansas Derby, the closest one to the Kentucky Derby. So his agenda was three weeks-two-weeks-three weeks; four races in eight weeks, just like old times. His final quarter mile of the final jewel, when fatigue should have been taking hold, was faster than Secretariatâ€™s when he ran the most dazzling race in the history of the sport.
Materiality, a quality Grade 1 winner, who tried to run with American Pharoah early, was galloped into the ground. He finished last. He was one of five rivals to freshen for five weeks after the Kentucky Derby. Madefromlucky was off four weeks since winning the Peter Pan. Only Tale of Verve also ran in the Preakness but he didnâ€™t run in the Derby. A lot of good the conservative regimen did them.
One other point: American Pharoah races with Lasix. Somehow it doesnâ€™t debilitate him. Iâ€™ve always felt this is nothing but a crutch for trainers, as valid as the loserâ€™s lament, â€śdidnâ€™t handle the track.â€ť Some horses need more time between races but not all. Just as not all horses need Lasix.
Todd Pletcher is a great trainer. But it doesnâ€™t hurt to have a couple of hundred million-dollar pedigrees in the barn. This affords him the luxury of taking as much time as he feels necessary with each of them. He can pick his spots because thereâ€™s almost always something else in the barn for every race. However. itâ€™s telling that when his spots are dictated by tradition, his record is less than sterling: one Kentucky Derby, two Belmonts, zero Preaknesses. This is despite nominating about 40 3-year-olds to the Triple Crown every season.
American Pharoah has few worlds left to conquer. He has beaten the winners of every major and a lot of minor Derby season preps with the exception of the Louisiana Derbyâ€™s International Star, who is on the sidelines injured. But others who have come out of that race, all the Fair Grounds preps for that matter, have been established to be second tier at best.
So it was great to hear American Pharoahâ€™s owner Ahmed Zayat say he is as anxious to see his colt run again as fans are to see him. â€śWe would like to enjoy him as long as we canâ€¦a very, very long campaign. I personally made a promise to my family and to the fans more than anybody else. We need to enjoy our stars and race them as long as we possibly could.â€ť
One possible destination mentioned by Zayat and Baffert would give American Pharoah the opportunity to do something that has happened only once and hasnâ€™t happened in double the number of years between Triple Crowns. The only Triple Crown winner to add the Travers to his laurels was Whirlaway in 1941. (Affirmed finished first in 1978 but was placed behind Alydar for interference.)
Baffert has a long, prosperous history with Monmouthâ€™s Haskell. Heâ€™s won it seven times, including four of the last five. But he has Dortmund for this yearâ€™s renewal.
The Pacific Class against older horses is another option. But American Pharoahâ€™s connections can save that for the Breedersâ€™ Cup Classic, likely the champ's final start.
The Travers is another opportunity to make history and should be the race Baffert and Zayat point toward. Itâ€™s not as if the centerpiece of Saratogaâ€™s summer is foreign terrain to Baffert. He won it in 2001 with Point Given and tried to encore last year with Bayern, who was coming off a smashing triumph in the Haskell. That didnâ€™t work out so well. Bayern led early but faded to tenth and last. So running American Pharoah in both is probably a non-starter, even though they are 27 days apart.
One will be enough and it should be the Travers. If it happens, I wonder what cap NYRA will put on attendance.
NYRA diminishes great day
The attendance for Belmont Day was conspicuously missing from the charts. This indicates to me that even the misguided 90,000 cap wasnâ€™t reached. Potential customers were either scared away by nightmarish warnings of congestion or convinced they wouldnâ€™t be able to get in. Way to go, NYRA.
Itâ€™s not difficult to gauge the effect of the cap, or the mere threat of it. Handle was up on Thursday and Friday. On Saturday, the main event, it was down.
On-track handle was $16.8 million. Last year, it was $19 million. Last year, 102,000 were allowed to see California Chrome bid for the Triple Crown. The plunge in handle corresponds closely to the mandated drop in attendance.
Last year was a mess. With a year to fix it, itâ€™s disgraceful NYRA was unable to make the necessary adjustments. Instead it took the easy way out. Yet these people expect, and probably will get, bonuses at the end of the year.
Camera friendly NYRA CEO Chris Kay was seen on videos all afternoon on the closed-circuit feed congratulating himself for Belmont Day. But no matter how hard he works it, Kayâ€™s legacy will forever be as the man who kept thousands of racing fans from witnessing history.
Written by Tom Jicha
Thursday, June 04, 2015
Let’s hope the Belmont isn’t deja vu all over again
There are no sound handicapping principles that suggest American Pharoah shouldn't complete the Triple Crown. He has buried every one of his foes. But strange things have happened in the mile-and-a-half Belmont.The main danger appears to be Materiality, who had a horrendous trip in Louisville and has been pointed for this since, a winning tactic in recent years. Other than Frosted, the rest appear in it for their owner's ego. But to reiterate, the Belmont has a history of strange results.
MIAMI, June 4, 2015---Here we go again. Weâ€™ve been in this spot a dozen times since Affirmed became the last horse to sweep the Triple Crown in 1978. On almost every one of those occasions, the potential successor to Affirmed has looked as extraordinarily formidable as American Pharoah does going into the Belmont Stakes.
The list of scalps on American Pharoahâ€™s belt includes the winners of the Wood Memorial, Florida Derby, Blue Grass, Santa Anita Derby, UAE Derby, Tampa Bay Derby, Sunland Derby and a load of lesser Derby preps. He has beaten every other horse in the field. None of his triumphs have been close. With the same past performances, if the Belmont Stakes were a mundane race on a weekday card, American Pharoah would be about 1-5. So if he goes off at his 3-5 morning line, you could almost argue he is value.
Post position is unlikely to be a factor in an eight-horse field going a mile and a half but American Pharoah is ideally drawn in the middle of the pack at No. 5. Bob Baffert says this has always been a lucky post for him but you get the feeling that he would have said that no matter where American Pharoah had drawn, with the possible exception of the rail.
Frammento just inside him and Frosted immediately to his outside are late runners, so Victor Espinoza should be able to get American Pharoah away and into stride cleanly.
Should American Pharoah join the roster of those who were undone in the Belmont Stakes, it will be more likely a result of contemporary breeding strategies than the tight spacing of the Kentucky Derby, Preakness and Belmont. There have been too many close misses to buy into the rationale that the brief separation between the three races is too much to overcome.
Real Quiet came out on the wrong end of a heart-breaking photo in 1998, the closest any horse has come to a Triple Crown since Affirmed. The previous year, Touch Gold ran down Silver Charm in the shadow of the wire. Smarty Jones suffered a similar fate in 2004. To contend these slight margins were solely the result of three races within five weeks is sophistry.
Moreover, given the brilliance of American Pharoahâ€™s post-Preakness workouts, the notion that he will be a fatigued horse is a reach. He seems to be getting stronger, if that is possible.
But American breedersâ€™ penchant for speed and precocity renders few horses capable of handling 12 furlongs at the highest level of competition. This is a quarter-mile further than they have ever been asked to race. So it could be not that Derby-Preakness winners couldnâ€™t go a mile and a half but that they ran into a rival genetically more suited to the challenge. Touch Gold in â€™97, Victory Gallop in â€™98 and Birdstone in 2004 all were horses who became tougher as the distances got longer.
American Pharoahâ€™s pedigree is a mixed bag as it relates to 12 furlongs. His top end says yes. Grandsire Empire Maker ended Funny Cideâ€™s bid for a Triple Crown in 2003 by running away from him in the Belmont Stakes stretch.
The bottom half of his pedigree says, not so much. It is speed oriented but if you go back a few generations, you get to champions Storm Bird and Storm Cat. A little further back, youâ€™ll find Northern Dancer and Secretariat, who ran the fastest Belmont in history. Thatâ€™s the blood American Pharoah will need to call upon in the final yards.
But you never know if one of his seven rivals will turn out to be a 12-furlong freak. This appears to be the only way American Pharoah will be denied.
American Pharoahâ€™s task seemed to have gotten less challenging when Todd Pletcher declared Carpe Diem, who does have distance breeding, out of the Belmont.Maybe Pletcher feels that with Materiality and Madefromlucky, he doesn't need him.
Materiality and Frosted can legitimately claim troubled trips in the Derby. Of the two, Materiality has more upside. The Derby was only his fourth start and first defeat, so there is ample room for a move forward. If he does, it could be a real horse race. Materiality, who lost all chance when he got away slowly in the Derby, also should benefit from the outside post. If heâ€™s tardy again when the latch is sprung, he shouldnâ€™t be squeezed back as he was in Louisville. Pletcher said he expects Materiality, who vied for the lead all the way in the Florida Derby then drew off, to be prominent going into the first turn.
Being outside American Pharoah should be beneficial, allowing him to track the favorite without getting trapped down on the inside. Itâ€™s not difficult to imagine a scenario in which Materiality could pin American Pharoah on the rail behind dead speed. Iâ€™ll have Materiality on at least some of my multi-race wagers. But he's the only other one.
Frosted is reminiscent of Wicked Strong last year, a disappointment in Florida followed by a big Wood Memorial then an off-the-board finish in the Derby. Frosted has won only twice in eight starts, both at Aqueduct. At the price he is likely to go off as the second choice, he offers no value. Iâ€™ll let him beat me.
Mubtaahij is intriguing solely because his trainer Michael de Kock is a magician, who has specialized in developing horses to handle the extended distances overseas. Still, off his Kentucky Derby, Mubtaahij appears to be in deep against a field far stronger than whatever it was he was beating in Dubai. Even de Kock conceded that if American Pharoah runs his race, the others are in it for minor awards. But you could do worse than include him on exotic tickets.
Since strange things have happened in the Belmont, anyone looking to cash a ticket at a big price might as well pick one of the other four out of a hat or bet each of them equally, since the return will be many times 4-1. There are no logical reasons to zero in on any one of them to win.
If you want to take a wild stab, put a few bucks to show on anyone but American Pharoah. If something goes amiss with the odds-on favorite (remember the seemingly unbeatable Big Brown), the show payoffs could be astronomical. If American Pharoah comes through and your selection finishes second or third, youâ€™ll get your money back and make a dime.
But American Pharoah is the bet from the head and the heart.
Written by Tom Jicha
Tuesday, June 02, 2015
American Pharoah can end Triple Crown drought fatigue
The thrill isn't gone from pursuit of a Triple Crown but it does seem that the excitement level for American Pharoah's bid has been muted in the lead-up to Saturday. Tickets are still not sold out even with NYRA's attempt to create artificial scarcity by announcing a 90,000 cap. It could be that some fans, who have helped pack Belmont for previous Triple Crown attempts, have given up on the possibility of it ever happening again.
MIAMI, June 2, 2015--Could racing fans be suffering from Triple Crown drought fatigue?
Shock and dismay describes my feelings last week when a NYRA email arrived, informing that there were still plenty of tickets available for American Pharoahâ€™s pursuit of the Triple Crown Saturday. After the Preakness, they should have been snapped up faster than primo seats to a Bruce Springsteen concert.
That an ample supply was still available a week and a half later seems to bolster what I suggested when the 90,000 cap was announced just before the Preakness. It was an attempt to jumpstart ticket sales, which had been going slowly, by creating an artificial scarcity.
Adding insult, the recent NYRA ad was dominated by pictures and the names of the bands who will present post-races concerts on Friday and Saturday. There was an image of a horse in Zayat colors but he was not identified as American Pharoah, the star of the show.
The potential of witnessing racing history, not a concert, should be the magnet. That it isnâ€™t should be troubling to everyone in racing. The Kentucky Derby is the Kentucky Derby, an annual spectacle of Americana. Otherwise, there is no bigger event in the sport than a bid for a Triple Crown. Yet it appears to be eliciting yawns.
It could be just me but it also seems there has been considerably less attention in the mainstream media to American Pharoahâ€™s attempt to end the long drought between Triple Crown winners. Then again, most of the mainstream media no longer treats racing as worthy of a regular place in the sports section. Where there used to be stories almost every day between the Preakness and Belmont, it looks as if the best racing can hope for is an advance on Saturday and coverage of the race on Sunday.
Maybe many of those who have gone again and again to the Belmont Stakes with high hopes that this would be the year have given up and decided it isnâ€™t worth enduring the hassles with such a high expectation of disappointment.
A more positive explanation is racing fans are not conditioned to purchase advance tickets but they will show up and fill the place on Saturday. Reserved seats for the Belmont have sold out. So to the casual racing fan, there was no urgency to buy general admission early. At every previous Belmont and even when the Breedersâ€™ Cup was in New York, you could walk up the day of the event and pay your way in with no problems.
However, the possibility that a â€śbeen there, done that, donâ€™t need to be disappointed againâ€ť mindset is taking hold is one more reason to root for American Pharoah to complete the sweep. A victory would make the next dozen attempts enticing because it will have been established that it can be done. Another failed effort will enhance the negative vibe that it has become an impossibility, so why get excited?
Return Met Mile to Memorial Day
The Met Mile will be a terrific race this Saturday as it always is.
Breedersâ€™ Cup Classic winner Bayern will be there and Iâ€™ll be shocked if there is an attempt to rate him as there was in the Churchill Downs on Derby Day. A tardy start was a factor but this is a horse who went 44 1/5 for a half-mile then drew away to win by more than 7 in 1:20 3/5 in the Woody Stephens on Belmont Day 2014.
Belmont Stakes and Jockey Club Gold Cup champion Tonalist will be shooting for his fifth consecutive win at Belmont. Cigar Mile winner Private Zone, who also twice won the Vosburgh and outran Bayern in the Churchill Downs, will be trying to enhance his resume of Grade 1 wins. Honor Code, who beat Private Zone in the Gulfstream Park Handicap at the Met Mile distance, is back on his home grounds for Shug McGaughey. Wicked Strong could fire another big one at any time and the price will be more than right.
This is a traditional classic that deserves its own stage, not burial on an undercard of a stakes laden program that doesnâ€™t need it. Adding such a prestigious event to the star packed Belmont program is overkill. Iâ€™ll keep reiterating this until the Met Mile goes back home to Memorial Day.
Meanwhile the Memorial Day card has been taken over by New York bred stakes, nice races but hardly an incentive for a fence-sitting fan to opt for Belmont over other events on the unofficial kickoff of summer.
There are rumblings that big changes are coming at NYRA. At the top of the list should be returning the Met Mile to Memorial Day.
$250K for 2YOâ€™s in June outrageous
I was highly critical when it was announced that the run-up to the Belmont Stakes would include a pair of $250,000 stakes for juveniles at 5 Â˝ furlongs. I predicted they would be Americaâ€™s richest non-winners of one other than. I feel vindicated.
The first of them, the Astoria Stakes, drew a field of only six, two of them maidens, one of those a first-time starter. It came up so soft, it is being run as the third race on the Thursday card. For this, NYRA is putting up a quarter-million dollars.
I know NYRA is awash in casino cash, which has to be put into purses, but there surely has to be a better way to spend it.
Written by Tom Jicha