Tuesday, May 12, 2015
Preakness Suffers From Middle Child Syndrome
MIAMI, May 12, 2015--The Preakness' suffers from middle child syndrome. From the moment juveniles start coming to the fore each summer at Saratoga and Del Mar, owners, trainers, the media and fans begin speculating about which ones might be "Derby horses." No one talks about "Preakness horses" until the herd has been culled just before the Run for the Roses.
These late developers and non-Derby qualifiers almost never win the second jewel of the Triple Crown. It's only been done twice since 2001. Both were the result of extraordinary circumstances.
Super filly Rachel Alexandra, who opted for the Kentucky Oaks over the Derby, outfinished Mine That Bird, who never won another race after his Derby upset in 2009, and Bernadini won the ill-fated 2006 renewal in which then unbeaten Barbaro suffered his fatal injuries.
This yearâ€™s candidates include Divining Rod, winner of a weak Lexington, Tesio winner Budhisattva and Tale of Verve, with only a maiden win. Any of them remind you of Rachel Alexandra or Bernadini?
Meanwhile, owners and trainers, who reach for justifications to run in the Derby and finish up the track, stretch just as hard to find reasons not to run back in Baltimore.
Todd Pletcher, who runs more horses in the Derby than anyone, almost never brings one back in the Preakness. Reportedly,Materiality and Stanford from the three Pletcher ran in Louisville are still under consideration for the Preakness. If Materiality goes he has a shot off his nightmate trip in Louisville but it will be out of character for Pletcher to drop him into the entry box on Wednesday.
It appears that the only other Derby starter other than the Big Three-American Pharoah, Firing Line and Dortmundâ€”who is going to run back is Danzig Moon. Anyone afraid of him?
For sure, the Preakness would get a few more of the top tier of 3-year-olds if it were run a month or longer after the Derby. But is it worth upsetting a century and a half of tradition to pick up a few Derby also-rans? If not for tradition, the middle jewel of the Triple Crown wouldn't be run at the spithole that is Pimlico. Tim Ritvo is likely to do the right thing within the next few years and move it to Laurel.
I am not advocating it and it isn't going to happen but if the Triple Crown were fair and based on contemporary racing, one of the three races would be at Santa Anita. Three of the last four Derby winners and the first three finishers this year are Southern California based.
It isnâ€™t just the Preakness that gets short changed with the two-week turnaround. The Kentucky Oaks got Alciabides winner Lovely Maria, Louisiana Oaks champion Iâ€™m a Chatterbox, Gulfstream Oaks victor Birdatthewire and Santa Anita Oaks winner Stellar Wind .The Black Eyed Susan is getting none of them.
The lack of the cream of the crop coming back from Derby weekend to run in the Preakness supporting stakes is another thing that grates the folks at Pimlico.
It's not like being the middle component of the Triple Crown doesn't have a big upside. Barring injury, which thankfully has not often reared its ugly head, the Preakness always gets racing's newest star, the Derby winner, the only horse still alive to capture the Triple Crown.
Pimlico will get its hundred thousand-plus fans Saturday. Forbes magazine reported that in the first four days after American Pharoah lived up to his billing in Louisville, ticket prices for the Preakness skyrocketed 39 percent, an indicator of the heightened interest in this year's race.
Whatâ€™s wrong with that? If American Pharoah comes up short Saturday, Belmont ticket prices are likely to plunge more than 39 percent.
Remember when a super Met Mile looked like it could serve as a life saver in the event a Triple Crown wasnâ€™t on the line? Shared Belief is out for the year. Honor Code got beat in Louisville. Palace Malice lran third in his
return on Sunday. Tonalist is a really nice horse but heâ€™s not a crowd magnet.
NYRA has to hold its breath rooting for American Pharoah to keep a Triple Crown possibility alive for the Belmont. The difference is only tens of millions of dollars, which could affect the color of the ink when the year-end financials are tabulated.
The most curious decision of Triple Crown season is NYRAâ€™s capping of the Belmont Stakes crowd at 90,000, especially in light of the record of more than 170,000 at Churchill Downs and the possibility of another record
crowd, well over 100,000 at Pimlico.
Last year more than 102,000 showed up at Belmont for California Chromeâ€™s bid for a Triple Crown. Some of them are still waiting at the Belmont station for their Long Island Railroad ride home. NYRA has been saying for months that working with the LIRR, this problem has been resolved. Obviously it hasnâ€™t been.
Then again, the easiest way to create a demand for something is to limit the supply. The Belmont Stakes cap forces the hand of those wavering about buying tickets. If they wait for the Preakness result, they could be shut out. Those shut out this year are more likely to purchase early in subsequent years.
You have to like American Pharoahâ€™s chances in Baltimore. Bob Baffert has said he considers the Preakness the easiest of the Triple Crown races.
American Pharoahâ€™s stock rose Saturday without him leaving the barn. Madefromlucky toyed with four opponents in the Peter Pan. He loafed toward the rear until starting his move on the far turn. At the top of the stretch, he still had only one horse beaten. But once in gear, he ran past the pack as if they were tied to a pole.
In his two previous starts, in the Rebel and Arkansas Derby, Madefromlucky was not in the same zip code with American Pharoah. So much for the theory that the Derby winner was beating nothing in the preps.
The game is still about betting, so itâ€™s hard to get excited about an odds-on favorite.But there are plenty of races to make decisions for the pocket. For the good of the game, Iâ€™ll be rooting hard Saturday for American Pharoah.Iâ€™ll be surprised if Iâ€™m disappointed.
Written by Tom Jicha
Tuesday, May 05, 2015
Derby’s a brief antidote to all that ails racing
Racing has its problems but a dying sport? Hardly. The TV ratings for Saturday's Kentucky Derby were spectacular, substantially higher than TV's most popular shows. The interest is there. Racing's challenge is to find a way to sustain it beyond the Triple Crown.
MIAMI, May 5, 2015--The Kentucky Derby is a beautiful thing. No matter what else ails racingâ€”there is plentyâ€”but on the first Saturday in May, everything is beautiful.
Itâ€™s more beautiful when a potential superstar like American Pharoah lives up to the hype and comes through like a champion. Heâ€™s the kind of horse who can capture the attention and hearts of America, just what racing needs.
Apparently heâ€™s well on his way to doing that. For those who dismiss racing as a dying sport, I would point to the TV ratings for this yearâ€™s Derby. The preliminary rating for Saturdayâ€™s telecast was 10.8, the highest in 23 years.
To put the 10.8 rating into perspective, the final day of the Masters, the â€śtradition unlike any other,â€ť which CBS begins pumping as soon as Santa is back at the North Pole, pulled an 8.7 rating.
The Derby shines even brighter when compared to the most popular prime time shows. For the week of April 20-26, the most recent available, the only program that out-rated the Derbyâ€™s 10.8 was the â€śI am womanâ€ť Bruce Jenner interview by Diane Sawyer. It registered 11.1.
The second highest rated program was The Big Bang Theory
, the most popular comedy on TV, at 8.9. 60 Minutes registered 6.7. Greyâ€™s Anatomy
, the episode in which Dr. Dreamy cashed it in, did 6.5.
So the Derby ratings were superior to everything but a once-in-a-decade sensationalistic special. Moreover, the Derby aired pre-prime time when the audience level is substantially lower, especially on a glorious day like it was in most of the country on Saturday.The amazing thing is it sustained this rating in spite of the show being much too long. Three and a half hours around one race--the Turf Classic was barely acknowledged--is too much. NBC tried hard and succeeded often but couldn't avoid long stretches of nothingness. A rundown of the major preps would have been useful, especially for casual racing fans, who make up the bulk of the audience.
The Derby has established itâ€™s a ready-for-prime-time player. The only question is when this is going to happen. The Breedersâ€™ Cup Classic is in prime time and it captures only about 20 percent of the Derbyâ€™s TV audience. NBC has to be salivating at the prospect of having the No. 1 show of the week in prime time during the May ratings sweeps month.
Churchill Down has lights, so darkness is not an issue and the rest of the terrific supporting card would still be run in daylight. Repositioning the Derby post from 6:40 to 8:40 would make the race more accessible to a wider TV audience and would eliminate the necessity to begin the marathon Derby card at 10:30 a.m.â€”7:30 on the West Coast.
Getting back to American Pharoah, I mentioned in my Derby preview that I was concerned about his longevity because of the leg injury, which took him out of action for six months. As I wrote, Bob Baffert has not been characteristically forthcoming about the injury.
Baffert also has been exceedingly low key about American Pharoah racing with a bar shoe, a fact that was under-emphasized in the racing media. As a member, Iâ€™ll share blame. Truth is, I was caught unaware until a few minutes before post-time on Saturday. Given the aggressiveness of those who comment on this site (God bless them), I have to think I wasnâ€™t the only one. Not one commentator I read brought it up in assessing the race.
In any event, this is an indication that whatever was wrong hasnâ€™t been completely alleviated. It would be a shame to have a superstar have his career cut short due to injury, or worse. Racing needs another big star. It doesnâ€™t need another Barbaro.
Pletcher bashers are know-nothings
Three more out-of-the-money finishes in the Derby are sure to bring out the worst among the Todd Pletcher bashers. Pletcherâ€™s Derby cumulative record is now 1-43, which is misleading and unfair. He has entered multiple starters on many occasions but he has taken part in only 15 Derbys and won with Super Saver in 2010.
This is still a dismal less than 7% but the Derby is arguably Americaâ€™s toughest race to win even for some of the greatest trainers ever to walk a shedrow. Charlie Whittingham didnâ€™t capture his first Derby until he was 73. Bobby Frankel never won one. Bill Mott is still looking for his first. Anyone want to knock them?
Itâ€™s a challenge to even get to the Derby, so the fact that Pletcher has been able to get so many 3-year-olds to Louisville on the first Saturday in May should be a badge of distinction.
But the people who put others on a pedestal solely for the opportunity to knock them off love to put down Pletcher for his Derby resume. All praise to Bob Baffert for winning the race--running one-three in fact-- that every horse person covets. But letâ€™s take a look at the entire Derby weekend.
On Friday, Baffert started only two, Callback and Enchanting Lady, in the Eight Belles. Callback was second at 5-1. Enchanting Lady checked in ninth at 5-2. (Surprise! The longer Baffert ran better.)
The same afternoon, Pletcher took the third, an allowance, with Curalina. Three races later Feathered won the Grade 3 Edgewood. In the 8th, the Grade 2 Alysheba, Protonico outran 9-5 Honor Code.
Pletcherâ€™s Sweet Whiskey ran off the board in the LaTroienne, as did Eskenformoney and Angela Renee, both 21-1 shots, in the Oaks. But three wins, two in graded stakes, on one of racingâ€™s biggest afternoons is a career highlight for most trainers.
Saturday brought more of the same. Baffertâ€™s day began with Cat Burglar running second at even-money in the fourth race. In the fifth, his Gimme De Lute and Lord Nelson were third and fourth, respectively. The winner? Pletcherâ€™s Competitive Edge.
In the seventh, the Grade 1 Humana Distaff, Pletcherâ€™s Dame Dorothy out-gamed Eclipse champion Judy the Beauty. He also got a third with Sandiva in the Grade 1 Distaff Turf Mile and a second with Jack Milton in the Grade 1 Turf Classic.
Baffert fired the weekendâ€™s biggest dud, Bayern. The Breedersâ€™ Cup Classic winner ran last of six at 4-5 in the Grade 2 Churchill Downs.
However, Baffert won the Big One, earning all the praise he is getting.
Anyone who uses only the Derby to knock Pletcher is one of those people you never want to get stuck sitting next to at a bar or simulcast site.
Uniformity? What a joke
Anyone hoping for nationwide uniform rules, especially as they relate to race day medication, is probably also waiting for Godot.
Racing canâ€™t get it together even with minor things. Lovely Mariaâ€™s win in the Oaks kept me alive in the Oaks-Turf Classic-Derby Bet 3. Then Ken Ramsey got into a snit with Chad Brown and scratched all three of his entrants in the Turf Classic, including Stephanieâ€™s Kitten, who I keyed.
Would I get a consolation or was I moved to the favorite (Finneganâ€™s Wake), who happened to win. No one in my party knew, because every track has its own rules. A similar situation occurred last year in Las Vegas. No one there, including the director of the race book, knew. In fact, he guessed wrong.
There was no on-screen announcement on the closed-circuit feed and no Pick 3 will pays involving the scratched horses.
It turned out I got a consolation, a pretty skimpy one, $19.60 for a buck. I didnâ€™t find out the payoff on the screen. I had to run the ticket through the machine. It was almost like a scratch off lottery ticket waiting to see what I had coming.
Is it asking too much for all tracks to have one uniform rule, whether it be consolation or move to the favorite? Probably.
Written by Tom Jicha
Wednesday, April 29, 2015
At the prices, ‘the other Baffert’ is the Derby bet
This is the deepest Kentucky Derby field in memory. I couldn't reduce it to less than nine who could win without shocking me. Ergo, it makes no sense to take a short price on American Pharoah. There's a saying that you should never bet a horse to do something he hasn't done before. Dortmund, "the other Baffert" has never lost. Neither has Materiality but there's that curse of Apollo to consider.
MIAMI, April 29, 2015--I canâ€™t remember a Kentucky Derby I anticipated more than Saturdayâ€™s. Itâ€™s the most talent laden in memory. Every season there are two or three horses, who seem to stand out, and one or two others worth a saver at a price. I had trouble narrowing this group down to fewer than nine.
The romantic and fan in me would like to see American Pharoah live up to his billing as the second coming of Seattle Slew, one of my favorite thoroughbreds ever. Can anyone explain why the only horse ever to win the Triple Crown while still undefeated-- a New York based and developed star--has not been honored by NYRA with a major stakes named for him.
How about the Peter Pan, the major New York prep for the Belmont? If you stopped a hundred racing fans and asked who this race is named for, does anyone doubt a strong majority would respond Tinker Bellâ€™s buddy?
But I digress.
I would love to see another dazzling great like Slew for what it would mean for the game. However, a couple of things concern me about American Pharoah. The leg injury that knocked him out of action for six months has never been fully explained. The usually loquacious Bob Baffert has been uncharacteristically evasive when the subject is raised.
Also, you canâ€™t let the fact that this is the Derby knock your horse playing sense out of whack. Estimates are American Pharoah will be in the 2-1 range. Itâ€™s insanity to take that price against this bunch.
This is one of those occasions â€śthe other Baffertâ€ť makes sense record- and price-wise. Dortmund has never been beaten and he showed grit the others havenâ€™t had to call upon when he came back against Firing Line after being passed and seemingly put away. Heâ€™ll likely be twice or three times the price of American Pharoah, too.
Another sign of the depth of this field is there is another Grade 1 winning undefeated colt, Materiality, whoâ€™ll be no better than third choice and possibly less than that. Then again, thereâ€™s a reason it has been 133 years since a colt who didnâ€™t race as a juvenile won the Derby. Most recently, subsequent two-time Horse of the Year Curlin couldnâ€™t do it.
Carpe Diem has been managed this spring like the Florida Gatorsâ€™ early non-conference football schedule. Heâ€™s looked great but so do the Gators when theyâ€™re playing Bemidji State. Now Carpe Diem steps back into the Southeast Conference of racing.
The colt weâ€™re all guessing on is Mubtahhij. Anyone else but Michael deKock training him and heâ€™s a toss. But anyone other than DeKock isnâ€™t training him.
If you like Dortmund, and I do, you have to consider Firing Line. He has been in a couple of photos with Dortmund and a slight twist of racing luck could put him on top this time at a big price.
For most of the Gulfstream season I was in love with Upstart. I wonâ€™t say his DQ in the Fountain of Youth wasnâ€™t justifiable but he was the best horse that day. Then Materiality looked him in the eye in the Florida Derby before bidding him a fond adieu. Materiality should benefit from that race more than Upstart will.
At the top of the stretch in the Fountain of Youth, Frosted looked like a cinch. But he gave it up faster than a fun prom date. If the Wood Memorial is any indication, whatever was bothering him has been alleviated by throat surgery. Still, I donâ€™t think he beat much at Aqueduct. Tencendur? Really?
International Star rang up the most Derby qualifying points but he did it at the Fair Grounds. The last time a Kentucky Derby winner came out of the bayou was Grindstone in 1996. Moreover, I know International Star wasnâ€™t beating much. Louisiana Derby runnerup Stanford was no match for Materiality in his prior start and War Story, who stretched International Star in the LeComte and Risen Star, is a nice horse whoâ€™s a cut below the best of his generation.
Only one horse, Keen Ice, made the Derby field with fewer than 30 qualifying points, another indication of the quality of this field. So Iâ€™m not going to denigrate any of them. They'll cumulatively win a lot of stakes this summer and fall. But if any of them win, I lose. It won't be a maiden breaker.
So the moment of truth is here. My Derby win play is Dortmund.
Iâ€™m going to use Dortmund, American Pharoah and Materiality (and Mubtahhij if heâ€™s better than 15-1) in multi-race wagers and in the Oaks-Derby double with Stellar Wind, who made a good group of California distaffers look ordinary.
If Stellar Wind is anywhere close to her 7-2 morning line, sheâ€™s the play of the weekend.
The one thing Iâ€™m not going to do is get involved with exactas or triâ€™s in the Derby. Some hard-to-find longshot always seems to get up into the place or show spot.
There's one other personal reason. I don't want to diminish the experience of seeing a Derby winner go under the wire by concentrating on who's clunking up for the minor awards.
(Note: This had to be published before the post draw. If any of my selections land the one hole, all bets on him are off.)
Written by Tom Jicha