Sunday, October 11, 2015
Are Rolling Hi-5 Carryovers Too Much of a Good Thing?
HALLANDALE BEACH, FL, October 11, 2015—When it comes to observing the phenomenon of gambling at the racetrack after more than four decades, nothing much astounds me. We’ve pretty much seen it all.
But I was simply amazed by what happened at Gulfstream Park West with respect to its newly created Rolling Super-Hi 5 with carryover.
And, no, it wasn’t that the winning payoff on the final leg of the Saturday program paid $127,569, which was astonishing enough.
Rather, it was that bettors spent $231,000 chasing a $58,000 carryover, the result of the bet failing to be won for four consecutive races. The sixth race carryover was $11,594, which grew by a factor of five over the next three races.
But almost a quarter-million spent chasing $58K? If that’s not a stunning development, then I don’t know one when I see one.
Yesterday I was suffering through a very long afternoon in Simulville yet I was never tempted to throw even a few dollars at the free money.
First, the degree of Hi-5 difficulty is extraordinary. I know this because under the right circumstances, I love playing Dime Supers--and they are plenty tough enough. Given the added permutations, the $1 minimum for a majority of players is too much to bear.
I know that Gulfstream’s philosophy is to build handle via carryovers on bets with a high degree of difficulty, but these wagers prevent bettors with capped bankrolls to manage their money effectively, even those with deep pockets.
It might take a little longer, but a 50-Cent wager would get more people engaged in the initial legs and, even at the more affordable rate, rollover handle would be significant enough with an added benefit of allowing players to preserve their bank.
Saturday’s GPW 12-horse finale was viewed as a one-horse affair. It featured a 17-10 favorite with co-second choices at a lofty 5-1, and co-‘third’ choices at 10-1. The favorite finished last of the dozen $10,000 claimers.
The results thereafter were not outlandish. Heart Doctor, one of the two 5-1 shots, won the race, followed in order by 15-1, 10-1, 17-1 and 26-1, the longest shot in the field but not outrageous considering the field size.
Obviously, the payout was the product of a strong favorite not hitting the first five. Only two deep-pocketed bettors were the beneficiaries.
While the publicity generated by a big payoff is a positive, it sends a mixed message:
Those who can’t afford to play the wager properly have no business in the pool. Luck plays a huge role in these multi-tiered finishes. Is that the message the industry wants to send, that it's mostly luck that produces a small-bet life-changing score?
Further, is this how any track should represent itself to a dwindling number of customers or to introduce new ones, that if you want to win big, you might want go out and buy yourself a lottery ticket. All they need is a dollar and a dream.
Meanwhile, the newly created $5 quinella has yet to find an audience despite more of an accent on handicapping than bankroll--in addition to its more manageable degree of difficulty.
The first four days of the meet that began Wednesday attracted handle of $4,540—for all four programs! The better news were the payoffs; generous at best, thought provoking at least.
The figures for the first four days, with odds of the top two finishers, in order, followed by the $5Q payoffs: 16-1 and 3-1 returned $272; 2-1 and 15-1 paid $244; 7-1 and 5-1 combined to pay $280.50, and 5-1 over 15-1 returned $428. Food for thought and worthy of continued tracking.
International Trot: A Welcome Return
After a two decade hiatus, Yonkers Raceway revived the old Roosevelt Raceway classic and it turns out that the country that won the last edition, Sweden, with His Majesty, won the revival with Papagayo E at 9-1.
Odds-on Canadian favorite Bee A Magician finished off the board following a very good but extremely wide brush approaching the mile-mark of the mile and-a-quarter event. She flattened out midway of the final turn while the winner enjoyed a pluperfect-pocket, passing-lane, trip.
The aggressive Johnny Takter made the winner’s trip possible by having enough speed to park the field all the way to the top of Yonkers’ notoriously short stretch before weakening, hanging on long enough to give the eventual winner clearance as the leader drifted as the wire rapidly approached.
As opposed to the normal harness race on a half-mile harness track, the International was anything but a pack of overland trotters or pacers going head-to-head first, second, third and fourth-over in a tight pack. There were moves and middle-move sweeps throughout the last half-mile, a good, exciting show.
One thing we’d like to see, however. With Roosevelt far back in the rear view and branding within the same circuit unnecessary, don’t understand why the start-and-finish line couldn’t be farther up the stretch, giving ralliers half a chance.
With todays’ harness tracks as glib and speed favoring as they are, the final result shouldn’t be a foregone conclusion before the entire field gets a chance to find its best stride in the straightaway. Interesting and more competitive half-mile harness racing would benefit fans and horsemen alike.
Written by John Pricci
Tuesday, October 06, 2015
Thoroughbred Racing: Whose Game Is It, Anyway?
HALLANDALE BEACH, FL., October 6, 2015—To paraphrase a popular refrain commonly heard on one side of the aisle in the nation’s capital, I’m no economist, but the recent handle figures released by Equibase appears to indicate that if you throw enough money at the purse structure, bettors will come.
The surprising aspect here is that not only do the horsemen benefit from increased purses but so, too, does the industry. The numbers clearly indicate that bettors prefer to wager not only at the best price but on the best product available.
Statistics show that the formula for success this entire year, thanks to the month of September, has been relatively simple: Decrease the number of races by 5%, increase the amount of purse money by $15-million, and reap a $71-million reward.
We check the national handle figures when they are released by the Equibase News Service each month. For the most part, the percentage increases or decreases are almost always minimal or, in bean counters language, flat.
But not last month, and not so, albeit to a lesser degree, for the third-quarter of fiscal 2015. The third-quarter betting figures show a total handle increase of 3.65% across the U.S. compared to 2014. That’s a fairly significant gain.
And it’s important to note here that these numbers correspond with overall purse increases of 1.23%.
Admittedly, this seems like an empirical coincidence. But when factored into the decline in race days, number of races and number of starters, by 2.16% 3.78% and 2.54%, respectively, a new picture begins to emerge.
Throughout 2015, handle has been down marginally. In context, however, this makes the third-quarter increase, a current-day aberration, significant:
Handle in September increased by a huge double-digit margin of 11.90% year over year while purses were increased by 7.13%. Meanwhile, the number of race days, races, and starters all decreased, by 0.45%, 2.91% and 1.29%, respectively.
Acknowledged is the amount of money saved by not distributing purses over fewer dates, races and starters, thus allowing for increased revenue for racetracks at the bottom line. But that “saving” is unrelated to increased betting, during football season yet.
The Triple Crown, topped by the prodigious Kentucky Derby, is racing’s best hoof forward regarding the sport’s appeal among general or mainstream-sports audiences. Of course, the Triple Crown and its run-up spans the first half of racing’s yearly calendar.
The just concluded third quarter is that segment of the year which on balance is the season’s best. Destination tracks, led by Saratoga and Del Mar, and to a lesser degree venues like Monmouth Park, comprise the first half of the third quarter.
This year, Saratoga enjoyed a record season but Monmouth Park, despite American Pharoah’s Haskell appearance, posted only modest meet gains while Del Mar’s numbers were a flat-out disappointment.
As football season began, purse-enriched Saratoga and Del Mar remained open but were winding down in every way. Racing in the fall has made a championship prep season the new normal as tracks begin to stage their biggest races of the year.
With Belmont Park and Santa Anita front-loading the beginning of their 2015 fall meets, mega-event days and weekends resulted in a glut of dollars being thrown the horsemen’s way.
To this mix add Keeneland, with or without Breeders’ Cup, the brief return of Churchill, the huge five-day success that is Kentucky Downs, the new Parx Racing Festival and the latter portion of Gulfstream Park's popular record-setting summer meet, and racing’s third-quarter offers the year’s best sport.
The common thread coursing through all the above are wildly enhanced stakes purses, which turns out to be the good news and the bad news. For fans and most owners and trainers, the purse money thrown at a handful of stakes would be better spent overnight on a daily basis.
But these mega-quality programs are what the bettors want and they vote with their betting money, even while complaining that many of the races aren’t as quality-laden as they should be.
The increase in fractional betting and lower takeout available hither and yon also has the positive effect of putting more of the people’s money into more betting pools, a.k.a. a win-win.
Note, however, that the third-quarter numbers do not reflect two “Super Weekends” of Breeders’ Cup preps conducted at Belmont Park, Santa Anita and Keeneland: Those occurred the weekends of October 3rd and 10th.
Several recent studies have determined that field size is not as critical a handle component as is widely believed, however counter-intuitive the notion may be. The comparative trends released Monday by Equibase underscores this point.
Marketers who struggle to make horse racing compelling again have tried everything except aggressively promoting gambling, a legitimate and familiar lament. By comparison, fantasy sports—especially in consideration of a New York Times story alleging inside-information trading by employees at Fan Duel and Draft Kings results in pre-posting its fans/bettors--have promoted gambling boldly and obviously quite effectively.
This is yet another example from which racing can learn. If September’s nationwide handle figures mean anything, it’s this: Horseplayers, racing’s indispensable life-blood, are betting more money on quality races despite a perceptible presence of heavy early favorites.
And there’s one more philosophy that all racing executives might do well to consider going forward, if the goal is to increase the sport’s overall popularity in the future: Less may be more, a lot more.
Written by John Pricci
Sunday, September 27, 2015
Wigglin’ N’ Jigglin’ Through First Round of Cup Preps
HALLANDALE BEACH, FL., September 27, 2015—We bring you this interruption in our analysis of first-round of Breeders’ Cup preps in order to provide a look at possibly the greatest pacing event we’ve ever seen on a half-mile harness track.
As stated here often, we cut our horse-racing teeth at Roosevelt and Yonkers Raceways, highlighted by those amazing Friday night Free-For-All pacing battles between Eddie Cobb’s Adios Butler and Clint Hodgins’ Bye Bye Bird.
Not long after that came the slugfests between Stanley Dancer’s Cardigan Bay and John Patterson’s Overtrick. Meetings with Frank Irvin’s Bret Hanover would come later, one that required fans to park alongside the Thruway because lots at “The Yonk” were filled.
One picture will be worth a thousand of my words. Suffice it to say that getting hung out for three-quarters of a mile in 27-second quarter-miles, then resurging to win when apparently beaten, just doesn’t happen. A mile in 1:49 3/5, on a half-miler?
Enjoy the race of the weekend: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A5IsLdiUGHcwatch
East Side, West Side, All Around the Breeders’ Cup Prep World
With Keeneland hosting its first ever fall championship event, contestants will be coming far and wide--from New York, California and Europe--to compete in the U.S. World Championships.
It follows that both Belmont Park and Santa Anita had to front-load their graded stakes schedules, to the detriment of both. There’s only so many top class runners to go around. Even races such as the storied Jockey Blue Gold Cup, scheduled for Saturday, has not been immune.
As for competition for good horses, other million-dollar events have proven a lucrative distraction to history and tradition. Of greater significance may be the fact that trainers would like to have their Breeders’ Cup preps over the surface which will host the event.
A city like Philadelphia, for instance, is efforting to become a top racing market, entitled to a spot on the national simulcast map, however brief, despite its player-unfriendly takeout policies.
For Breeders’ Cup horsemen, last week’s seven-figure Grade 1 and Grade 2 events provided opportunities to give them what they covet; graded titles, big bucks and six-weeks spacing prior to a possible championship-defining moment.
Round One Confirms, Denies, Potential Promise and Greatness
Grade 1 Beldame
: Like many of her generation, Wedding Toast
has had the misfortune to come along in the Year of the Beholder.
She dominated a solid field of five rivals, headed by three-year-old runner-up, Curalina.
Wedding Toast obviously has had her issues, given numerous layoff gaps in her form, but has been managed expertly by Kiaran McLaughlin
and staff and generally has proven clearly best wherever she’s appeared, especially at Belmont Park. She dominated here.
If runner-up Curalina has designs on a three-year-old filly title, she probably must win the Distaff. She was a game-finisher despite a stutter-step start and looks like a better two-turn prospect.
Grade 2 Gallant Bloom: La Verdad
is amazing, reminding us of 2015 Hall of Fame inductee Xtra Heat
--that’s what a front-running 15-for-21 lifetime mark gets you. She runs the turns very well. Seven furlongs may be her outer limit but it can allow for an easier early lead. None of her Gallant Bloom rivals impressed with upside Cup potential.
Grade 3 Pilgrim
: Damn good horse race! The first four finishers: Isotherm, Azar, Ray’s The Bar
and Highland Sky
; all looked worthy of an appearance in the Juvenile Turf. Cup fans will need to review the replay and do so often, given the amount of troubled/nuanced trips.
Grade 1 Vosburgh
: Difficult to knock a sprinter that’s been perfect in five starts this year, including his second consecutive Grade 1. But the score by Rock Fall
is a difficult read for us--unless Todd Pletcher,
as he stated post-race, left a few screws untightened.
On one hand, Rock Fall was his typical ultra-game self in an A- performance. On the other, we didn’t particularly care for the way he went to the post. He will be meeting the fastest of the fast give weeks hence and we have a nagging feeling his form might be declining. Hope that's not the case.
Grade 1 Joe Hirsch Turf Classic:
As all know, trips and dynamics are everything on turf, especially marathons. Big Blue Kitten
came with his Big Blue Kick as the rabbit finally did his job properly. And, of course, as goes the hot pace, so goes the course record.
I would expect the big four of the Joe Hirsch; Big Blue Kitten, Slumber, Twilight Eclipse
and Red Rifle
will return to run very competitively in The Turf. But if Flintshire
, or some other talented European shows up, the Americans will be up against it yet again.
Grade 1 Forerunner: Nyquist
did not disappoint yet was disappointing. He just may be distance challenged. Some excellent race riding by Mario Gutierrez got the job done. Swipe,
legally intimidated, in my view, has more upside heading into the Juvenile.
Grade 1 Chandelier: Songbird
did not disappoint nor was she in any way disappointing. She won geared down and ran faster the Nyquist, by a lot; 1:44.89 compared to her 1:43.79. While never a serious win challenger, Land Over Sea
put in a fine late rally and can be an exotics factor in the Juvenile Fillies. However, we’re anxiously awaiting Rachel’s Valentina’s
prep appearance next weekend.
Grade 1 Rodeo Drive:
Similarly, America’s female turf division, the West Coast fillies, at least, appear to be win fodder for some well-meant Europeans. Photo Call
benefitted from a good, ground-saving trip from Drayden Van Dyke but believe these fillies might not even be the equal of turf mares based elsewhere in this country.
Grade 1 Awesome Again:
Bye, Bye Bad Karma Bayern
, or whatever it is that makes him a shadow of his three-year-old self. Four year-old, four-race career Smooth Roller
normally would be the kind of late bloomer that would pique the interest of wise guy Breeders’ Cup handicappers. But not this year.
Grade 1 Grade 1 Zenyatta
: Behold a great race mare. She continues to give notice that she might be America’s best race horse. Should Beholder and American Pharoah
reach the Classic in the top form and she beats he, the vote for Horse of the Year will be unprecedentedly difficult.
Written by John Pricci