Monday, January 13, 2014
Gulfstream Sport’s Best Long-Running Race Meet
HALLANDALE BEACH, FL, January 12, 2014—The timing could not have been better. The escape from New York was delayed but went along as planned. After a few miserable weeks in the Northeast, golden sunshine proved good for the soul.
So is being back on the “good horse circuit” and, in that context, our arrival in South Florida could not have been better-timed. I found this out when Phil Janack, formerly of the Schenectady Gazette and now a member of Gulfstream’s publicity staff, informed me that Saturday's card was the best card of the season.
Photo by Toni Pricci
Christophe Clement reminds Joe Bravo that Summer Front needs patient handling
Janack was not making use of hyperbole here, just simply telling it like it is and proved to be. Special-weight maidens were everywhere, going long on turf, going short on dirt, including a not-so-secret Todd Pletcher first-timer.
There were allowance races galore, two graded stakes, one on each surface, and a NW3 allowances featuring the 4-year-old debuts of two 2013 Kentucky Derby runners, including also-ran Falling Sky show and show finisher Revolutionary, the latter earning his way to the big dance via scores in the Withers and Louisiana Derby.
They ran 1-2, Revolutionary’s win more impressive than his half-length winning margin suggests. And either he was showing his freshness or he's a lot handier now than he was on the 2013 Triple Crown trail. If that’s the case, the War Pass colt will be a tough out in the G1 Donn next month.
Two races later, after the Ramsey’s Charming Kitten, equipped with his new blinkers, made his successful 4-year-old debut, Pletcher completed a personal Pick 3 with the highly touted newcomer Constitution, owned by the WinStar people of Revolutionary fame, along with Twin Creeks Racing.
Constitution broke very slowly from the gate, pulled Javier Castellano through the field, lucky to get through unencumbered by traffic while moving up on the fence. But then things got tougher as he engaged a fast, experienced Juba that gave no quarter, keeping Constitution in close quarters through the long stretch run.
The final time of 1:23.36 was very solid off a half-mile in :44.82, the final eighth in an understandably pedestrian :13.65. But the takeaway was that he impressed by passing the eyeball test, showing class in the process.
Three races later, another 2013 Triple Crown trail-er, Elnaawi, made a successful 4-year-old debut against a field of preliminary allowance types, setting a controlled pace beneath Joel Rosario before coming away with a 1-1/4 length win that can be described as a useful return for To Honor And Serve’s half-brother.
Parenthetically, this gave Kiaran McLaughlin a very good day, who also saddled promising turf runner Macaroon to victory, all after 3-year-old Cairo Prince had an excellent company work with an older horse. It was his second consecutive five-eighths in :59.80. A soft half-mile breeze next weekend should have him set for the following week’s Holy Bull.
Photo by: Toni Pricci
Summer Front proudly returns to Gulfstream winner's circle
Christophe Clement had Summer Front ready for his 5-year-old debut after suffering a nose defeat in Hollywood’s G2 Citation last tine out. Joe Bravo gave him the patient, covered-up handling to show his best as he won the G2 Ft. Lauderdale.
Meanwhile, in his first start for Bill Mott, Lea was a revelation in taking the G3 Hal’s Hope, attending the pace of defending Hal’s Hope champion Csaba, opening ground quickly beneath Luis Saez soon after entering the straight, separating himself from the competition in what should be an ideal prep for he and several of his rivals, notably tough-tripping third Neck n’ Neck and wide-tripping fourth, Uncaptured.
Last year, we wrote glowingly of Saez after it was learned the Calder regular would switch his tack to New York. Saez gained national prominence as the partner of certain-to-be 2013 3-year-old champion Will Take Charge and took the Hal’s Hope occasion to annex career win #1,000. Fittingly, former Calder president Ken Dunn was on hand to present the trophy to the accomplished 21-year-old.
GULFSTREAM RETURN SOMETHING OF A MIXED BAG:
Photo by: Toni Pricci
Lea's first graded dirt win and Luis Saez's career win 1,000
With apologies to Saratoga, Del Mar and Keeneland, Gulfstream Park in recent years has emerged from winter capital of East Coast racing to the best sustained Thoroughbred meet in the country at any time of the year.
Wags will quickly note that now one must include the remaining year-round dates before making that observation, but we don’t think so. Their decision to race year-round was straight economics based gaining on a bigger share of off-season simulcast revenue, at that time the exclusive province of Calder Race Course.
Tampa Bay Downs also added to its schedule last year toward that same simulcast end. To us, prime time Florida racing begins when juveniles become 3-year-olds on New Year’s Day and ends when the last Florida Derby entrant crosses the finish line.
To accommodate this schedule--while having the added benefit of attracting horses away from the track in Miami Lakes--Gulfstream built two full-size barns to handle the equine overload. It’s no wonder that, poor early-week weather notwithstanding, there were no fewer than 211 horses on Saturday’s work tab. That’s the good news.
The not-so-good news is that the new barns obstruct from view the start of races out of the 7-furlong and mile chutes. In order to see the break from the gate, fans must watch the track’s closed-circuit monitors. However, present camera angles do not provide pan views.
Photo by: Toni Pricci
Hall of Famer Bill Mott's excited about new pupil Lea's future
The start of the one-turn mile is viewed head on, great for seeing the occasional stumble or rough-and-tumble start of colliding equines, but poor for establishing depth perception. Did your horse break 2-lengths or 4-lengths slowly away from the barrier? This makes answering the question very difficult if not impossible.
The 7-furlong view is a bit better with a quasi-head-on view that provides some pan context. But in both cases there is an abrupt switch to the traditional view. Horses race more than a furlong out of the mile chute before traditional sightlines become available.
Thus far, veteran observers have taken the transition in stride but newcomers—on any given day there are many at the popular destination venue--doubtlessly are scratching their heads. Hopefully, some new technology, short of binoculars that can see through walls, eventually will correct the problem.
Written by John Pricci
Monday, January 06, 2014
2014: Racing’s Most Important Year in Some Time
SARATOGA SPRINGS, NY, January 4, 2014—Before jumping into 2014 with both feet, a little leftover business from last year that needs addressing.
By now, everyone knows what the big stories of 2013 were.
Certainly, the sport had its share of negative storylines. From the routinely annual embarrassing New York Times Derby Week “expose,” to Washington D. C.’s hearings on medication policies, among other salient issues.
Then there was Penn National’s “race fixing” scandal and, of course, the granddaddy of them all, the “sudden death” of seven from the Hall of Fame barn of Bob Baffert.
How these events will affect racing’s present and future remains to be seen with the takeaway highly likely to produce a mixed bag resolutions:
Can’t wait to see what the paper of record has in store for Derby week, 2014. (It appears that the industry has made a preemptive response, as it were, awarding the Gray Lady with an Eclipse Award for its feature on Russell Baze).
Whether the feds ultimately institute the “Lance Armstrong” testing model for horse racing could make headlines in 2014.
There could be serious penalties, even jail time, for the alleged race fixers of Grantville, Pa. How will that all shake out?
Finally, and significantly, Baffert was cleared of any wrong doing by the California Horse Racing Board, surprising few veteran observers, leaving too many questions unanswered.
“What [the investigation] does say [is] there’s something wrong here,” said Dr. Rick Arthur, the CHRB’s medical director, adding that “the ‘clustering’ of sudden horse deaths over such a short time is ‘undeniably exceptional’…statistically ‘extremely abnormal’.”
Not explained to anyone’s satisfaction is why every horse under Baffert’s care treated with a thyroid medication and why did it take a seventh horse to die to stop the practice when evidence of sudden equine death surfaced earlier.
This story may not make more headlines in 2014 and lovers of the game hope that the adjudication, however unsatisfying as it might be, will be the end of the saga. Gone, maybe, but never to be forgotten.
The closing of Hollywood Park was equally distressing in a different way. It's as if an important part of racing tradition was ripped right out its fabric.
My first and only visit, the inaugural Breeders’ Cup in 1984, was memorable for myriad reasons. On a personal level, getting 32-1 Outstandingly, placed first via disqualification was one; the other was an outstanding job done by the stewards the following day.
It was a show-and-tell-all explanation to assembled media of the rough n’ tumble Classic stretch run of Wild Again, Slew o’ Gold and Gate Dancer. Had never witnessed anything like this, before or since.
The loss of Ramon Dominguez from the jock’s room was sad on any level and we wish only good things for the gentlemanly Ramon in his forced retirement.
The return of “the Coach” to the national stage with a certain-to-be three year old champion does an old heart good.
Interesting how Darrell Wayne Lukas is being hailed for managing Will Take Charge through an 11-race campaign after he had been vilified many times in the past for his aggressive handling of his stock. Time and perspective is a powerful entry.
The elevation of Kitten’s Joy to the highest levels of the breeding world, managed by a man who did it with his own money--generating dollars that often help fuel parimutuel handle--methodology, research, and tireless hours in handicapping research.
The devoted husband of Sarah, Ken Ramsey’s 2013 racing exploits were nothing short of a revelation.
The comeback of Gary Stevens after a seven year absence, the top story of 2013 in several polls, would also have gotten our vote. As stated here previously, to come back and win Grade 1s is one thing.
But to do it at 50, seemingly a better Hall of Fame rider than the retired version and to capture both the Distaff and Classic strains credulity. But it did happen and was our favorite story of 2013.
There’s another story that barely raised a national eyebrow compared to those above that could have implications not only for America’s flagship circuit but the future of how horse racing is perceived and proceeds going forward.
The hiring of Martin Panza as Vice President, Racing for the New York Racing Association might have been fortuitous for a soon-to-be out of work Hollywood Park executive but it was in our view the most significant executive hire of year.
Panza, experienced and highly accomplished, is charged with restoring to New York racing back to its forward eminence, one that is earned but in the present and not by traditional decree.
Under the former NYRA administration, the corporate imperative was to grow the bottom line by any means necessary. Resultantly, field size trumped quality.
Horseplayers also suffered. Handicappers too often needed to navigate a mine field of claiming conditions, sometimes three or four deep in order to assess the matchups, the kind of inscrutable mess that management—and NYRA is not alone in this—hopes will compel bettors to spread deeply in popular horizontal pools.
Turn pockets inside-out today; tomorrow’s liquidity will take care of itself. Never mind that simulcast players just concentrate their play on tracks which might give them a better chance to--you know--win.
I have reserved opinion on the short term stewardship of NYRA Chairman David Skorton and subsequent hiring of Christopher Kay as CEO. I have written positively about both in the past, preferring to point out the promise of positive change. I no longer feel the same way.
The open NYRA Board meetings have been transparent, indeed, but largely have been much ado about nothing. Controversial issues were brought up too late in meetings, limiting meaningful debate. Meetings ended promptly, as if Skorton had a train to catch.
Consequently, sensitive topics were decided “in committee,” typical of the Albany process, apropos of a gubernatorial appointee. Skorton is charged with getting NYRA’s bottom line attractive enough to lure 2015 franchise bidders.
The photogenic Kay was brought in to make use of his corporate talents, perhaps outside-the-racing-box thinking would result in fresh ideas. Aside from efforts to boost employee morale, if progress has been made in other areas they are not yet visible.
Some attendees at the recent Arizona Symposium thought his presentation a bit condescending, as if industry executives never heard of the suggestions that was perceived as original only in its packaging.
Embarrassingly, Kay identified Global Betting Exchange as the world’s largest online betting company, as if Betfair representatives were not in the room. It turned out not to be the best way to make a favorable first impression.
Many industry types are reserving judgment on both men until after a formal business plan is made public. The stakes for New York racing, and beyond Empire State borders, could not be higher.
Written by John Pricci
Friday, January 03, 2014
Voting Your Conscience
SARATOGA SPRINGS, NY, January 1, 2014—One of the privileges associated with being a member of the National Turf Writers and Broadcasters Association—incurring the wrath of readers notwithstanding—is getting to fill out an Eclipse ballot each year.
I can’t speak for all but every NTWAB member I know take their responsibility seriously as unofficial watchdogs of the game. And that’s what it’s all about: the sport, not the business, not the betting but athletic achievement equine and human.
And rewards for those who pay the freight; the owners and, to a certain extent, breeders.
Reviewing past performances at season’s end provides a snapshot of not only what transpired between the fences but a benchmark for comparing present-day competitors with those from the past that distinguished their careers with championships.
While there always are memorable performances throughout the course of any racing season, including this one, on balance 2013 was not a particularly memorable year.
Of the 10 Eclipse categories on the flat, only four categories boasted definitive championship credentials; two on turf and one of with two dirt would-be champs just holding on.
Rules require that voters indicate three graded choices in each division or have the entire vote in that section voided. If voters choose to abstain, they must write in Abstain on all three lines. I abstained in two categories. Here’s one man’s opinion:
Two Year Old Male:
A difficult division to predict likely will come down to either Breeders’ Cup Juvenile winner New Year’s Day or the undefeated late developer, Shared Belief. I’ve been pondering the awards off and on for nearly a month.
When I voted in this category I changed my mind as I began to fill out my ballot. The vote went to an undefeated winner of three starts, two in graded company including a Grade 1, albeit on a synthetic surface.
Switch post positions in the Juvenile and the top vote getter likely would have been Havana. But the best record of all major players belonged to:
1. Shared Belief 2. New Year’s Day 3. Havana
Two Year Old Female
: Most likely award winner, She’s A Tiger, which finished first or second in five graded stakes, finishing first in the Juvenile Fillies but placed second via disqualification. Chrisellium was brilliant in the Juvenile Fillies Turf:
1. She’s A Tiger 2. Chrisellium 3. Sweet Reason
Three Year Old Male:
In a division that went from potential Triple Crown winner to chaotic in a span of five weeks, Will Take Charge, the highly likely champion, danced most of the dances and finished with a flourish, just missing in the Classic and beating Game On Dude in the G1 Clark. Absolutely loved and admired the versatility of Goldencents.
1. Will Take Charge 2. Goldencents 3. Orb
Three Year Old Filly
: Another category in which I changed my mind when it was time to put a name on the ballot. Beholder was dominant in THE filly and mare race of the year, the Distaff, on her home ground.
But I decided I could not punish the body of work compiled by Princess of Sylmar in and out of her division: the Kentucky Oaks, Coaching Club American Oaks and Alabama are something of an equine holy trinity. Throw in the fact that she beat defending older champion Royal Delta before she completely went over the top and it’s not as if she didn’t split decisions with her only rival.
1. Princess of Sylmar 2. Beholder 3. Close Hatches
Not the most memorable year in the handicap division, traditionally a dirt category. (It should be formally designated as such. Doing so does not preclude winning multiple titles when and where appropriate).
But it was the Macho Man that put two big ones together, including the race that every older horse—or three year old, for that matter—wants to win, the Classic, and in doing so beat every meaningful would-be handicap champion.
For his part, Wise Dan carried high weights but both of those wins came at the G2 level, beating four and five rivals respectively on his preferred surface. The voting will be very close but ‘Dan’ probably enjoys the edge.
1. Mucho Macho Man 2. Wise Dan 3. Game On Dude
On balance, one of the weaker divisions of 2013. Any race with championship implications went through Royal Delta who tried Dubai again to no avail, the effort apparently exacting a toll at season’s end.
If every top filly in the division showed up with their ‘A’ race in the same event on the same day, the race would be for place.
1. Royal Delta 2. Joyful Victory 3. Tiz Miz Sue
: A fairly open Eclipse race with the top of the division stringing together important victories—but not over a sustained period in 2013. The BC Sprint winner traditionally has had a huge edge in this category but winning Secret Circle had but a two-race campaign.
Sahara Sky was the most talented of the lot but he didn’t race beyond the Met Mile, an elongated sprint, on Memorial Day. Points Offthebench had the most brilliance in traditional G1s at 6 furlongs.
1. Points Offthebench 2. Sahara Sky 3. Secret Circle
: Another category that was far from automatic due to the slow start of defending champion Groupie Doll. But she won when it counted as early and mid-season leaders started feeling the effects of spring and summer racing and she rose to the occasion, defending her F & M Sprint title.
‘Dolly’ did just enough, and the feeling is that most voters will agree. Dance To Bristol won seven straight before tailing off and Cluster Of Stars went 6-for-6 but only two G2s among them and did not step up when given a championship opportunity.
1. Groupie Doll 2. Dance To Bristol 3. Cluster of Stars
Male Turf Horse:
Finally, a slam-dunk automatic. Wise Dan is as talented as he is consistent; that’s how horses accumulate just shy of $6.3 million in earnings.
Magician won the traditional championship defining event but it’s not enough to dethrone a defending champion. Point Of Entry won two G1s then was injured, returning with a worthy effort in The Turf following a five-month layup.
1. Wise Dan 2. Magician 3. Point Of Entry
Female Turf Horse:
Since the best American bloodstock began filling stalls in Europe, the Far East and, finally, the Middle East, the best turf runners on balance race outside this country. Not even sure Dank came with her ‘A’ game, but it was still enough to handle our best turf distaffers in the F & M Turf.
1. Dank 2. Laughing 3. Kitten’s Dumplings
As regular readers from Long Island to Saratoga know, I like the up-and-overs and enjoy the sport each week during the Saratoga meet. This year, however, no runner was able to put two important victories together. None of the finalists are worthy of a championship in our view.
1. Abstain 2. Abstain 3. Abstain
Don’t believe I’ve ever seen an outfit more dominant at the highest levels than the Ramseys were in 2013. They deserve to be heavy favorites. (I was thisclose to voting for Ed Stanco and company in this category. Clearly, Stanco is deserving of some equine Sportsman of the Year award; Willis Horton also stepped up big time.
1. Ken and Sarah Ramsey 2. King of Prussia Stable 3. Willis D. Horton
Honestly, did anyone besides Ramsey think that Kitten’s Joy was capable of this
1. Ken and Sarah Ramsey 2. Adena Springs 3. Juddmonte International
It’s one thing to earn over $25 million for your owners because you have the most ammunition; it’s another to hit the bull’s-eye so often, so dominantly.
1. Todd Pletcher 2. D. Wayne Lukas 3. Shug McGaughey
It’s one thing to make a successful comeback; it’s another to win the Distaff and Classic in the same year, among other Grade 1s. (Before he was injured, thought that Joel Rosario was a cinch; it’s now likely Gary Stevens will be).
1. Gary Stevens 2. Joel Rosario 3. Javier Castellano
: Darn good year for young riders and another close call. Victor Carrasco is the likely winner with high accumulated earnings but Edgard Zayas has proven, the times we’ve seen him, to be wise beyond his years.
1. Edgard Zayas 2. Victor Corrasco 3. Emmanuel Esquivel
Horse of the Year
: As a sportsman, Morton Fink is a great businessman. If an owner insists on a horse’s preferred surface; that’s fine. But only once did Wise Dan try a distance beyond a mile and a sixteenth, Churchill’s Turf Classic on Derby day.
Instead the connections played it safe when the sport could have used a dramatic boost at season’s end. In his five pre-Mile victories, including two Grade 2s, he beat a total of 24 rivals.
Mr. Fink has a license to do what he wishes; I have a vote. No other horse this year compiled a compelling enough record to unseat a defending Horse of the Year. I’m sure most of the voters would agree and Wise Dan very likely will defend his Horse of the Year title easily.
As stated, it’s all about the sport for us when it comes to post-season awards. Consequently, we will pass.
1. Abstain 2. Abstain 3. Abstain
Written by John Pricci