No More Ms. Nice Guy: I’m angry as Hell, I’m packin’ heat—and I’m naming names. I’m up at an ungodly hour of the morning, writing this rant because I just saw something that sent me over the edge.
This video online (Yahoo! News) is about 100 horses being starved to death by their owners in California.
Not “just any” horses—these are Thoroughbreds. OUR Thoroughbreds. Every person who has a stake in Thoroughbred racing—whether you’re the breeder who made the horse; the owner, trainer, jockey, exercise rider, groom--or the bettor who makes money off their sweat—you are responsible for the welfare of our equine athletes. If you make your living from your involvement in the sport—you are responsible for their welfare. You can’t have the perks without the responsibilities: that’s a lesson we teach three-year-olds.
Back to the starving Thoroughbreds in California. Oh, let’s name names: they were/may still be—on Cochema Ranch in Frazier Valley, California. Owned by Cecilia Bor and her family, this Thoroughbred puppy mill is a member of California Thoroughbred Breeders’ Association. Three of their stallions—General Gem, Giant Asset and Cat in the House—are listed in the 2008 CTBA Stallion Directory.
We must note here that Giant Asset’s pedigree is Affirmed, out of Nashua’s Frolic, a daughter of Nashua. This horse was no slouch.
Ah, yes: “was.” Giant’s Asset is dead. In 2006. Apparently of starvation. The other two are probably dead, too—just a wild guess. I tried to find them at Pedigree Query, but nothing beyond their pedigrees there. That awkward silence on the ‘site, when there’s no information about a horse. (“He, uh, ‘slipped through the cracks.’ Yeah, that’s it, he slipped through the cracks..”)
Responsible breeders and owners are happy to provide info to accompany their horses’ pedigrees. Ergo, it’s a good guess that, when a horse’s information is missing—the horse found its way to the killpen, starvation or some other unsavory end.
The story out of California is that a good citizen—and no doubt, horse lover—Patty Wallace—collected a stack of complaints about Cochema Ranch and the horses locked on that farm, starving to death and suffering from myriad unthinkable diseases and rot. Ms. Wallace handed over the stack of complaints to the local Humane Society, which apparently took its time getting investigators out there. So Patty called the Sheriff, who looked at the complaints and descended on the ranch.
That’s the only Good News of this piece: that someone (Patty Wallace) has a heart of compassion, and did something. And that the sheriff’s department got involved, and began removing horses from the clutches of the human vermin who owned them.
Now for the Bad News: not “news,” per se—just my observations. Now is the time to flip the channel or hang with me, pick one. I am livid. My eyes are practically filled with blood, as rage about this incident floods my heart and mind. I cannot fathom anyone—the Bors, the owners of Cochema Ranch—having 100 horses (Thoroughbred or other) and allowing them to starve to death. There is absolutely NO EXCUSE for it. None. Zip. Zero. Zilch. Nada. Noyle.
If you have horses and you can’t afford to feed them—if life’s gone down the dumper and you can’t provide food, clean water, medicine and shelter for your horses—give them away. Hand them over to TRF or any of the myriad wonderful charities that will gladly find homes for them.
Stand on the roof of your house and scream, “HELP!” until someone comes to the rescue. But do not—DO NOT—tell me that you love your horses, yet you allowed them to rot like so many corpses in a Wes Craven film.
I don’t want to hear your excuses: “the price of gas is high.” “The price of hay is high.” “Feed is going through the roof.” “We love our horses, but…”
Clearly, the Bor family is nuts, simple-minded or both. No one with a decently-high IQ would allow this to happen, and actually go on record as saying, “We love our horses. They’re our children.” Cecilia Bor said that to a TV reporter. Obviously, Ms. Bor is either a liar or an idiot—there’s no middle ground.
The Mansons were a “family,” too.
Now for the Big Indictments: where is the CHRB and the CTBA in all this? The California Horse Racing Board—while a governing board that oversees the racing aspect of the industry—must surely have its eyes on the breeding operations in the state? And if not—why not?
And the California Thoroughbred Breeders’ Association? To wag my finger at them and say, “Shame on you,” is not enough, clearly. Believe it or not, Cochema Ranch is actually a member of CTBA.
Those three stallions are listed in THIS year’s California Stallion Directory. Including the dead one.
Seems the California Thoroughbred Stallion Directory needs to hire a fact-checker.
The CTBA had under its nose at least one Thoroughbred breeding farm that was killing its horses by starving them to death—and either didn’t know it, or ignored the fact. Does no one from either CHRB or CTBA take a drive and do spot-checks on farms? Or was it so important to add the names of those three emaciated stallions to the roster of state-breds that they took the Bor’s membership fees and ran into that comfy state of denial?
At any rate, someone, somewhere, dropped the ball. 100 horses—including foals, mares in foal and stallions—have been starving to death on Cochema Ranch since at least 2006. These horses have been dropping like flies, too weak even to neigh, too discouraged to nicker. And some stupid, self-absorbed, money-grubbing pig of a human at every step along the way—either ignored or denied the plight of these horses.
Oh, I know that the pro-equicide people will say that Cochema Ranch is a good example of why America “needs” equicide (horse slaughter for money). That “unwanted” horses starve to death, so slaughter is the viable option. And that, as we know, is a load of crap—because, while the pro-slaughter people hold their thumbs and middle fingers together, chanting “Ohm” and “unwanted horses”—they know, as do you, that horses in the shape of those on Cochema Ranch aren’t “fit” enough to make it onto the killerbuyers’ trucks.
Think about that for a minute: these horses were too weak and sick to walk onto a slaughterhouse-bound truck—so even the killerbuyers, the scum-suckers of the Earth—wouldn’t take them.
(So the “unwanted horses” argument is invalid. Don’t send me a comment ranting about “unwanted horses” and why equicide would have been “better” for the Cochema horses. That’s non-sense, and you know it.)
Can you hear it? Can you smell the money in the air: Breeders’ Cup Season is upon us. For the next month, the industry will be fawning over the richest owners and breeders. Kabillion-dollar horses will do battle on the untested artificial surface of Santa Anita. Wealthy women with way-too much money will don Versace and Prada, their men proudly displaying their fillies—and their horses. Conspicuous consumption will mark the party to which the masses are not invited, the soiree for those who can afford the best caviar, champagne and feed.
Rome burns. Nero fiddles. 100 miles away from the Breeders’ Cup at Santa Anita—100 horses are dead or dying. One-hundred miles, 100 Thoroughbreds—children of Affirmed, grands of Seattle Slew—call out to the California Thoroughbred Breeders’ Association and California Horse Racing Board. Their cries are drowned out by the sound of All That Money flapping in the breeze at Santa Anita.
The two governing bodies whose responsibility it was to oversee breeding farms in the state of California have failed miserably. I cannot be convinced that they didn’t know this was going on: the chain of evidence from two years ago indicates that the first reports—when Giant Asset was found starved to death—had to have gone straight from the Ventura County Sheriff’s Office to the CHRB. There is no valid reason why, two years later, Cochema Ranch is still in existence, the Bors locked in a Cal State detention barn.
If every Thoroughbred farm in California offered to take, love, nurture and feed just ONE of these horses—the problem would be solved. But I’m sure it won’t happen, because there’s no money to be made on a sack of bones that was once a racehorse. The only reward to stepping up to the plate and taking responsibility is the knowledge that you did The Right Thing.
Shame on you, CHRB and CTBA, for expending every ounce of energy, money and attention to those two days at the end of October—and for ignoring 100 of your own charges, suffering for over two years.
You Thoroughbred “experts” haven’t stepped up to the plate—I am ashamed to be in the same sport as you. You don’t deserve your fat jobs overseeing the California Thoroughbred industry—and 100 horses don’t deserve to die for YOUR sins.


08 Oct 2008 at 01:35 am | #
I agree , the CHRB, CTBA needs to step up to the plate along with the Jockeys Club.
I, now , own a Th stallion, I do not service mares for anyone at this time. No one can afford the responsibilities of raising one of his foals. I respect my stallion as if he were my own flesh and blood. I have even turned my own family and their mares away , because of their lack of discipline. I also own a Qh mare , and have no intentions of raising any foals. I can only afford to care for my 2 Equine friends.
08 Oct 2008 at 04:13 am | #
God bless you, KB, for being a responsible,caring horse owner. Would that everyone in our sport--in all equine sports--had your sense of integrity and genuine love for the creatures in their care. You are a shining example of the right way to do it--thank you so much, KB.
08 Oct 2008 at 11:35 am | #
Marion do you have horses in your life ? My horses keep me HONEST, they are the pathway I walk.................I have thought of going public and getting involved in the Political side of life and running for offices , affiliated with the welfare of our horses, you think I might stand a chance in hell........for all the years I have been at the race track , my record is spotless and I go by the rules. I am no buttox kisser or whistle blower. When handling the public and you run into the negative side of some folks , well I handle it like gelding a horse. Off to the side, no drama. A bit of tranq, pain killer , a swift clinch and the balls are gone, no ifs and's or but's. Move on to the next issue at hand
Kudo's to the gal that wrote this blog at the start and named names , that takes character and value , why not!
My name is Kim Bagnell and I am the HUMBLED servant of the thoroughbred "LastMangoinParis" who retired from racing in CA. He is by BOLD BADGETT and he is of solid body and sound mind.
Would like to cross him with several good Qh mares and raise and run them in NewMexico, that area seems to he HORSE FRIENDLY , unlike MONTANA, where racing is dying because of lack of common sense and good ol boys running it into the ground.
Bless you too , there MISSY!
08 Oct 2008 at 11:42 am | #
There has to be programs organized and honestly managed by the Jockey's Club and AQHA for starters. When a foal is born it should have a AUTOMATIC Insurance/Savings policy started. That money is to be used to care for that animal when it is pensioned. Monitored by Organizations and drop in visits . If not Jail time ...........for the human lacking in values............
Its like a city of people , birth certificates are like registered papers.............for our horses. That's one idea!
08 Oct 2008 at 01:02 pm | #
Dear Marion,
As you mentioned in your very strong article people doesn't like to take responsibility of their behaviors. Few people like me and you who can see this paining image. People who are in the racing field sees races "amazing" "wonderful" "stunning" and "waaaw". But unfortunately they don't look beyond that surface. People all over the world loves to watch horses dying as simple as that because horses became as leisure tools to make people happy!!
hmm.. lots of thoughts makes me really crazy..
thanks for the great efforts.
Kind Regards
Hanan Al Muhairi
United Arab Emirates
Dubai
12 Oct 2008 at 02:53 am | #
Sad that a obviously sick family abused these horses, they obviously were sick. What's your excuse "Mare"? Tar and feather a whole industry that is currently under attack because of an isolated incident? On a "legitimate" pro horse racing site? Your editorial reads like a fanatic who looks for animal abusers everywhere. Please consider another profession. Horse Amiga wants a socialist like care program for horses monitored by Horse Protection Services (HPS) with Jail Time. Loving horses and wanting good care for them is great. Becoming a hysterical zealot out for all the evil doers- in an industry overflowing with great people- is the kind of stupidity an industry under attack does not need. Take your concerns to the proper channels, not on the Internet landscape run by activists already casting horse racing as a "blood sport" and poisoning the general public. I am dead serious, no need to knock you for no reason at all. You have taken a rare occurence and painted it into a crime commited by the whole industry. You have given fodder to groups more powerful and well funded than you could ever imagine to use against our industry- full of hard working families who take excellent care of their horses. Your heart may tell you what to do, but your brain should have told you to use another avenue.
12 Oct 2008 at 06:57 am | #
Anonymous: No one loves the sport of racing Thoroughbreds more than I. Tthe sound of those beautiful hooves pounding during the one second in which they roar past is truly the sound of God's own power. There's not another soul on the planet who is more passionate about Thoroughbreds, or racing them.
And no one is indicting the hard-working families in California racing and breeding--I'm angry with the regulators in the State. And you should be, too--especially if you're one of those hard-working families.
But loving the sport means loving the animals, first. Without them, there would be no racing. I am not--did not--paint a landscape in which I indicted an entire industry. That indictment came from a videojournalist in Los Andgles. I'm guessing that you're involved in California breeding or racing, and that's wonderful. But don't you think it's an interesting--if not horrible--coincidence, that these 100 horses were so overlooked by an entire state of regulators and professional organizations? I'm sure that it WAS a case of overlooked--and not of intentionally turning their backs on the horses. No one would do that.
But don't you think that one of the California organizations should keep an eye on the breeding facilities in the state? Or should sick people like that family be allowed to benignly murder as many horses as they "love"? And, now that the story IS out--I am not the one who broke the story, that was the aforementioned reporter--I've not read or heard anything about any California racing officials stepping in to even make a statement about the sad, horrible situation.
I googled, and there's nothing. I went to the 'sites for both CHRB and CTBA, and there's no acknowledgement of the situation. It's been 10 days since I saw the video at Yahoo! News and wrote my little rant. Ten days is plenty of time to circle the wagons, and come out with an official statement.
I just found it ironic that, 100 miles from the location of this year's Breeders' Cup--this happpened right under regulators' eyes. Or perhaps just outside the periphery thereof. Whichever the case--the irony of the sad, painful case of 100 starvimg Thoroughbreds is a blot on the sport. Not a blot that *I* created--I'm just someone who noticed the blot and is angry about it.
You'd shoot the messenger, Anonymous, rather than the offenders (who SHOULD be in jail). And I'm guessing that you may be fairly high up the totem pole in the State of Disgrace--or you wouldn’t have chosen the pseudonym, “Anonymous.” Just a guess.
You suggest that I get out of the sport, A.Nony.Mouse--but, nah, I won't. Every business needs pains in the butt, pebbles in the shoes of those who run things. Maybe no one is reading a damned word I write, but my "still, small voice" will continue to raise whenever I see an injustice.
And you don't see a tremendous irony that 100 horses are dead or dying on that Ranch, 100 miles from the 'site where all-that-money is going to change hands? Where expensive champagne and egos will flow, unchecked. You don't see anything even vaguely ironic about all that cash and passion, 100 miles from 100 horses who didn't even have good grass to eat? I think that it IS an interesting irony--and that someone, somewhere--even the Breeders' Cup, themselves--should step in (there's still time) and put down some serious money to get the horses who are left alive into safe, loving adoption situations.
And after the fuss-and-feathers of the Breeders' Cup is over, the CHRB, CTBA and BC folks should sit down together. Stop counting money, and count heads. Find out where every registered Thoroughbred is living; how they're being treated; and make an official statement about the horror show on that Ranch. Officials in the sport need to make huge strides to become the allies of those of us who care--and not condemn or ridicule us because we DO. Until we hear some news from California, or read an official press release--we can only assume that the glamour of the Breeders' Cup is completely blinding everyone in the California Thoroughbred community. And that's a damned shame...don't you think, Anonymous?
12 Oct 2008 at 11:36 am | #
I have forwarded this website to an associate of mine in the Office of one of the largest tracks in the US. Asking if this has come up in conversation in their office's , on the backsides and track kitchens as of late .
Alpha Mare is pissed and has stated so in the beginning blog. Ananymous ,can be pissed also and state his or hers feelings on the keys of the computer also. It is the voices on this blog, that might get the story out there, it all starts somewhere. So hang in there and keep it coming...................
17 Oct 2008 at 01:46 am | #
Check out media of this incident:
Bakersfieldnow.com (Search for "Horses"
KCAL9.com (Same Search)
17 Oct 2008 at 10:20 am | #
Hay there Cochema Crush: Can't find your info . Typed in Bakersfield.com. Then Horses . LOTS of choices to choose from, can you help out this farm gal and not really a computer GURU but am trying to learn.........Thanks!
28 Oct 2008 at 10:34 pm | #
Make sure you type in exactly "Bakersfieldnow.com"
24 Nov 2008 at 04:12 pm | #
Thank you Marion for your candid account of COCHEMA RANCH, trial is in progress (Nov 21) Ventura County, 14 counts Felony Animal Abuse.
View many accounts of this story by searching: "Ernie Bor"
View horses, first 13 removed (one euthanized) "Camarillo Shelter" (adoptions, other animals).
View some of the 38 by searching "Ojai Shelter"
Remaining 50+ are still at Ranch, pending outcome of trial
People who have not been paid for feed have contributed to saving the horses. There are at least 7 pregnant mares at the Ojai Shelter. Some thoroughbreds may have been bred to mustangs?
Unfortunately, this is not "Isolated", and if you did not speak so truthfully, the industry would never change.
HBO featured Bryant Gumble, Real Sports: Horse Slaughter.
(not breeders, people with no money to spare, scraping pennies together to save horses lives!, an overwhelming proposition).
PLEASE folks, have compassion for these beautiful, noble creatures... they are a gift, and deserve so much better! Many blessings.
10 Mar 2009 at 02:32 am | #
If there were more slaughter facilities for horses then these animals could be put to good use before getting in an abusive situation. The solution is very simple.
10 Mar 2009 at 02:50 am | #
Off the track Thoroughbreds are worth a dime a dozen. It takes a hundred bucks a month to properly care for these animals.
The question to you people posting in this thread is how many do you have in your back yard?
10 Mar 2009 at 11:02 am | #
I think there should be Slaughter Houses for some Humans...................these animals could be put to good use , before they ABUSE other animals in THEIR so called CARE................there was a case of 2 men from Georgia , after the court trial( Hamilton MT ) they were punished ............I can't find the article to share for you to read.................I would not like to have been the horses in their CARE.
I Euthanize the horses in my care if their lives are not HEALTHY and there is suffering or if I feel they will not get the right care after I am not able to for them , I will euthanize them , even if they are healthy............better not to have a horse if you can't take care them or let them take care of you ...........as you can read by now Scott, I am not much of a people lover
10 Mar 2009 at 07:17 pm | #
No responses, I guess you people haven't been willing to put your money where your mouth is.
12 Mar 2009 at 05:41 am | #
HorseAmiga, it's refreshing to see that there is someone out there get's it. You are certainly a responsible doer and thinker and not a whiney talker.
12 Mar 2009 at 08:20 am | #
HorseAmiga,
I concur: the more humans I meet, the more I love horses. Most humans annoy me.
You sound like a wonderful, responsible, loving horseowner, HorseAmiga. God bless you for taking seriously your responsibility for the animals whom God placed in your care. I admire the fact that you are thoughtful and carefully considerate of every case.
And Scott, or whatever is your real name--you overplayed your hand. You showed everyone that you know nothing about horses: if you did, you wouldn't make a statement that it takes onlyk $100 a month to care for a horse. Hello, Scott? It's 1968--they want their prices back.
On what planet does it cost only $100 a month to care for a horse? Try $600 a month for an OTTB mare who may or may not be bred.
See, Scott, the reason I don't respond to your notes is that you write falsehoods (based on your speculation, I assume--like $100 a month to care for a horse).
Or to insult people you don't know. (Doing that makes YOU look badly, Scott, not those on whom you're dumping your misplaced snideness or anger.)
You don't seem interested in writing with an eye to finding solutions. Your enjoyment comes from saying incorrect things about people you don't know. And that's just plain puerile.
You think that you're throwing down the gauntlet when you write vaguely about other people--but you're not. ("They won't...," etc.)
You don't know any of the people who comment on these pages, or who write for HRI--and yet you make gross generalizations about people as individuals, and as a group. Your assumptions and insults are not only ridiculous and wrong, Scott--they completely negate your arguments. Ad Hominem arguments ("against the man") cancel the argument of the person who's flinging the lies and insults.
I don't respond to your emails, Scott, simply because I don't care to spar with you. You don't know me. I don't know you. You have your opinions. I have mine.
We'll never agree--so why toss fighting words back-and-forth on a public forum?
Doesn't make sense.
Is a waste of time.
Is puerile.
Won't do it.
God bless you, Scott, and bring peace into your heart.
And God bless you, HorseAmiga, for being a woman who's committed to her critters from cradle to grave--and every second in-between. You represent the best of the horseworld: I wish I knew you as a real person (not just virtual).
03 Jun 2009 at 04:30 pm | #
Okay folks, here's the even worse news. Today, June 3, 2009, and the Bor's are still doing this crap. Starving thoroughbreds in Paso Robles, CA. They rented a farm, brought in healthy horses and now the mares are foaling and everyone is hungry. These people were in court yesterday, does anyone know what happened? We called County Animal Services twice today, as well as the local television station. I've never had to report animal abuse before, so I'm trying to figure this all out. All you have to do is google, Cochema Ranch, Lockwood Valley and WOW, many articles, too many. These monsters are professional horse abusers and they are getting away with it!
21 Jun 2009 at 07:59 pm | #
http://www.chronicleforums.com/Forum/showthread.php?t=210683
According to this thread at Chronicle of the Horse, one of the above stallions, Cat In the House, is alive and with Neighsavers.com and The Last Furlong, along with a Silver Charm stallion, five mares with foals, two yearlings, and a lone mare. The fifteen horses were apparently headed for slaughter.
25 Jun 2009 at 09:07 pm | #
This information regarding the 15 horses is not correct. The 2 women who rescued the horses are not affiliated with any organization.
01 Aug 2009 at 01:08 am | #
Camarillo Shelter has done an excellent job bringing the horses they cared for back to health. We currently have one of the mares and will pick up another yearling next week. These two horses have a bright future ahead of them, thanks to the wonderful people that make the responsible decision to take them away from their owners. The animal abusers should be required to pay restitution to the County of Ventura and Humane Society. There is no reason for the taxpayors to have to pick up the tab for this sad situation. We need to hold people accountable for their actions. Lets all work on prevention so this situations don't occur again. Tracy Williams
23 Sep 2009 at 06:39 am | #
All I can say is thank you for your heart.
16 Aug 2010 at 03:58 pm | #
I too adopted a mare from the Ventura County Animal shelter. She is an awesome girl and is now happy and healthy. I tend to her twice a day everyday. I am with you on the "getting help". Dont stand there and do nothing while the horses starve. To this day my mare is driven to eat and food is the most important thing in her life. I don't know if she will ever get over what happened to her there. She has scars all over her body. The outside has healed and slowly the inside is healing. I love her with all my heart and those people should never be allowed to own another horse or any other animal. Thank you for your article. Im right behind you.
22 Aug 2010 at 10:57 am | #
Dear Karen,
Thank you so much for telling us about your beautiful girl--your lovingkindness to her will return to you, a hundredfold. All it takes is a good heart and the desire to do the right thing. You have blessed me today, as I realize that there are some very, very good people out there. Thank you for sharing your story.