The Horse Race Insider is a privately owned magazine. All copyrights reserved. “Bet with your head, not over it.”

The Conscience of Thoroughbred Racing


I’m calling an audible. Beneath Sunday’s “Hot Takes” column we promised to get to Friday’s “Future Stars” program. That can wait. Instead, I wanted to make my NTRA ballot choices public this week, but I couldn’t because of the existing format.

For the uninitiated, NTRA polling begins in the spring as the Triple Crown season begins to take definition and the organization provides two polls each week; one for three-year-olds, the other open to all divisions.

When the poll was first introduced, it was explained to me that the rankings were meant as a guide by including leading contenders for Horse of the Year honors which, as stated, is open to all. This notion was underscored last year when grass specialist Bricks and Mortar was voted best in show.

The ballot I filled out Monday morning made no sense to me. Why was there a three-year-old category? Haven’t three-year-olds been meeting their elders already, perhaps not to the extent of Breeders’ Cup demands but they have. Happy Saver did win the Jockey Club Gold Cup, yes?

Were we supposed to sprinkle Monday’s Top 10 three-year-olds among the open horses? If we did, what about the other divisions? At the moment, only two horses than can be considered viable Horse of the Year, and Authentic is the odds-on favorite at the moment.

His distant second would be the defending Eclipse champion female, Monomoy Girl, who pulled a Lady Eli, returning from an approximate 18 month layoff in order to retain her Distaff title and lock up older mare honors for 2020. No other horse would be as worthy as these two.

So I kept asking myself, what was the purpose of Monday’s drill? Wouldn’t it have been better for voters to cast ballots for the Top 10 horses in America, age and sex notwithstanding, with an eye toward the protem Horse of the Year, at the least providing a pathway to would be divisional titles?

Obligingly, I followed the script, not able to fill out the ballot the way I would have liked, one that encapsulated Thoroughbred achievement in 2020.

So here, then, is our HRI Poll, based on facts and empirical observation, horses that separated themselves from the crowd. And I must include honorable mentions because there are horses deserving of recognition but without a slot to fill.

Parenthetically, there is no Eclipse category for Juvenile Turf champion and with the recent proliferation of grass racing, there should be. If necessary, this award can be presented before the big reveals so as not to weigh down a cumbersome Eclipse ceremony-even if some progress was made last year.

Again, these are opinions based on factual resumes and empirical data, in some cases reflecting divisional categories we believe should be included in any representative poll. It’s past time that the poll be tweaked, adding clearer definition and understanding of what the poll is meant to represent:

10—Golden Pal: Anyone who has seen this colt race knows he’s a horse-of-a-lifetime type. I cannot recall seeing a juvenile do what he did: clearing the field easily; taken hold of, allowing three or four horses to gang up on him, before getting his button pushed and whoosh, he was gone again. Remarkable!

As with Juveniles, there’s no category for older turf sprinters. Racing secretaries couldn’t fill race cards in this era if it weren’t for these specialists. These races not only fill but produce exciting finishes and oft-chaotic results make them good wagering fare. Turf sprinters and juveniles deserve to be acknowledged.

9-WHITMORE: In a year where there was no dominant player, the Sprint, as it often has, will determine the fastest horse championship. Whitmore, one of the better feel good stories of 2020, proved to be America’s best sprinter on the day it mattered most.

Vekoma’s loss from the Sprint was significant, even if he is more a 7-furlong or miler type that often turns back effectively, and there is no Eclipse Award for Best Miler. In American racing? No recognition of a top miler, the kind everyone wants to breed to? There’s even a Breeders’ Cup race for it, sometimes around one turn, sometimes two. The time is now.

8-RUSHING FALL:  No, we’re not contradicting ourselves. I had to make a decision and erred on the side of body of work. A very game placing after chasing throughout at a compromising distance for the F & Mare Turf championship. Rushing Fall was 3-for-3, including two Grade 1s. Was her body of work too light in that context? Probably but, you know, it’s 2020.

7-VEQUIST: Even though she had finished second to one of the big three undefeated female youngsters running in the Juvenile Fillies, she won the definitive championship event on a world-wide stage, handing Princess Noor, Dayoutoftheoffice and Simply Ravishing their initial defeats.

6-ESSENTIAL QUALITY: Maxfield’s connections and his fans had this one coming, and so does the horse. Three-for-three, two Grade 1s including the crowning event, and he never had to leave the Commonwealth. But all states, New York notwithstanding, get a chance to play a home game.

5-GAMINE:  America’s female sprint championship came down to a match between this three-year-old and the older, redoubtable Serengeti Empress. The only mild surprise was the level of dominance Gamine displayed…the poor thing.

4-TARNAWA:  Yes, another division in which top tier stock took turns beating each other. No hearts and flowers intended for H H Aga Khan, but we were pleased he was rewarded for his loyal support of America’s best racing series has to offer. And he won it with a filly yet—and isn’t trainer Dermot Weld also deserving? If not, he was more than most.

3-SWISS SKYDIVER: After the Preakness, the protem three-year-old filly champion was in the Horse of the Year conversation, hence her high placement in the HRI Top 10. She didn’t deserve the unlucky stumble at the start of her showdown with the three-year-old champion of 2018. Log all those miles and get tripped up on your home track. Tough game, this.

2-MONOMOY GIRL: She is ranked second because as the connections of Authentic indicated while this healthy colt was getting whisk-broomed off the racetrack to join his father in the next stall, just as he began a march toward true equine greatness, there is nothing left to prove. An Authentic defeat could have elevated this girl to Horse of the Year favoritism. Still, all hail the $9.5 million champion race mare.

1-AUTHENTIC:  In American racing, the Triple Crown notwithstanding, this superior athlete won America’s most significant races in the same year, beating his elders in one of them in a very deep Classic field.

The Honorable Mentions are Knicks Go and Aunt Pearl. Perhaps there should be a third, Fire At Will, but we’re choosing to reserve judgment in that category because, unlike the other two, his effort was more workmanlike than brilliant. Call it a house rule.

Facebook Share
Twitter Share
LinkedIn Share

⚠ Before you comment

Our staff likes nothing better than to engage with the HRI Faithful and provide a forum for interaction on horseracing and sports. In that spirit, please be kind and reasonable; keep the language clean, and the tone civil. Comments from those who cannot comply will be deleted. Thank you.

11 Responses

  1. It’s a very hard list to make this year – I like it. My only different take on it is just due to my suspicions regarding Baffert entrants, I could never put one of his horses on top even if the resume merits it.

    Of course, in a steroid era sort of way, any trainer these days who is throwing a super high win % out there while his horses seem to retain top TG fig form race after race after race has to make you wonder. Don’t have to go very far down your top 10 list.

  2. #8 (Rushing Fall) retired and sold at Fasig Tipton Night of the Stars Sale. Authentic will be next to his father at Spendthrift and his mother, Flawless, was rushed into the sale after her son won BC Classic. Makes sense.

    1. Checked the Fasig-Tipton November Sale and Flawless was offered at 4.2m and did not sell. Midnight Bisou, Monomoy Girl, Got Stormy all sold. Fascinating business, albeit high risk. Obviously Flawless was rushed into sale due to Authentic’s big win. She’s in foal to Into Mischief so you get her and a potential champ for that price. Going once, Going twice…Sold to Pricci Thoroughbreds, LLC for 4.2m!

  3. Best to run that “c says sold to Pricci” past Photos by Toni before posting anything as OFFICIAL. I see an ENQUIRY sign going up in the morning. Lol.

  4. McD, Toni has not finished looking through all the pictures but said she can’t recall ever taking one of Flo.

  5. Jorge told a friend in Player’s Club at Big A that Alydar did not often change leads. He went on to say that in the 1978 Travers he knew Alydar was going to win because he changed leads. Jorge’s wife works in Player’s Club and Jorge sometimes comes to visit. Heard that Got Stormy is also, like Monomoy Girl, going to race next year after being sold the other evening. Mark Casse will continue to train.

  6. Correct and correct. I spoke to John Veitch about that back in the day, said they worked on it all the day but that he was just “a lefty.” Even at that, Alydar needed help from the stewards to win the Travers…

  7. John: I’m very happy that you and Harvey were able to make up after your involuntary “suspension” from Thoroughbred Action. Moreover, you have created a very impressive list of the yearly champions. My only comment is about the BC Dirt Mile. It was designed to be a race like the Metropolitan Handicap, not a two turn race with a short run to the turn. There is a reason why the Met Mile is probably the most important race for Breeders, besides being one of the great races of any year. It always brings together the best Sprinters and Middle Distance horses, even 3 year olds on occasion ( see, Conquistador Cielo or Arts & Letters). Maybe, someday, the Cup will return to Belmont, where it truly belongs?
    As to the Travers of ’78, I will never forget the day as it was my first trip to the Spa. I have been going to the Spa for 42 years now, even made a cameo this year for old times sake ( just took pictures outside by the East Ave gate). It is still the most crowded day that I have ever spent at Saratoga-you just couldn’t move in the backyard. However, it wasn’t just the stewards who put Alydar up, it was Mr. Cordero doing a favor for his buddy, Mr. Velasquez, and sticking it to Laz Barrera for taking him off of Affirmed the year before. I only wished that I hadn’t cashed my old blue colored $2 win bet on Alydar, although I still have an old $2 win ticket on Affirmed in the 77 Great American. Whenever I hear someone speak of “value”, I pull out that Affirmed ticket, and note that Alydar won that Great American at 4/5, while Affirmed went off at 9/2. Whoever “they” may be, “THEY” certainly knew who was going to win the Great American on 7/6/77!

  8. Great share Fram, thanks. Yes, Angel and Jorge were running mates back in the day but Angel never needed a special reason to ride more than one horse per race. But that was ugly–and they probably were send a message to Laffit–go back to Cali!

    When you talk one turn mile, you’re preaching to the choir, but many tracks, like Keeneland, don’t have a mile chute–and I hate short stretches anywhere and everywhere.

    But I do accept a two-turn result the same–one turn is best–and Belmont needs to be back in the rotation, long overdue. But don’t like permanent homes, it was meant as a traveling show.

    And even if I don’t care for the way races develop out west, the weather and time zone are big plusses for any event, especially for TV.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *