The Horse Race Insider is a privately owned magazine. All copyrights reserved. “Bet with your head, not over it.”

The Conscience of Thoroughbred Racing


Jack Whitaker May 18, 1924 – August 18, 2019
photo: Fast Philly Sports

As a sports fan and later an aspiring journalist, I always looked forward to the magazine segments of Jack Whitaker of CBS Sports.

One of the things I loved about Whitaker and his great friend and mentor, the inimitable Heywood Hale Broun, is that they more than got it about Thoroughbred racing; they revered it!

Whitaker, Broun, Chic ‘Tremendous Machine’ Anderson, and horse trainer-turned-analyst Frank Wright represented the golden age of horse-race broadcasting at CBS.

Each in his own way recognized and appreciated racing’s treasure trove of stories, both equine and human, punctuating them with understanding and wit.

They riffed on the charm, majesty and mystery that lay beneath the surface of past-performance lines and played it for all it was worth with the kind of reverence that’s lost on too many of today’s horseplayers.

Erudite print coverage of racing came first, something I tried to emulate by imitating the style of those who preceded me, my dear friend the late, great Bill Nack. It was Nack who introduced me to Dick Sadler, Newsday’s late, great sports editor.

Fortunate enough to win a couple of writing awards during my 17 years there, it was Sandler who taught me the best way to tell a story was to “begin with a narrative.”

It never could have gotten that far if in my earliest days Nack had not taken an interest; critiquing my Sunday column, always with a desire for me to make the next one better.  Sometimes I can achieve this, but never without bleeding a little, as the writers say.

The first time I can remember getting Nack’s help coincided with the sudden and mysterious death of Swale, the 1984 Belmont Stakes champion.

Don’t recall what I wrote but I remember struggling with the lede. Do I start with a Belmont Stakes narrative, or get right to it; the shocking and unusual circumstances surrounding Swale’s death? The men above would have known what to do instantly.

I did not know Jack Whitaker very well, Broun and Anderson hardly at all, and Wright quite well from his days as a trainer and racing commentator on a local New York network, WOR-TV.

I learned from them all but literary role models, particularly in sports, have all but disappeared from the scene, especially in horse racing that enjoyed such a rich scholarly history.

When it was announced that Whitaker passed, it was another wakeup call, another reminder of an era gone, when words and the search for truth mattered. Now, at a time when perspective is needed most, the scholars of sport are gone.

Such is life, and death, and birth of the Internet.

What an honor it has been to know, read, hear and learn from these men, commentators who were more poet than pundit, wordsmiths of the highest order, the truly gifted that created mythic legend on the spot.

In considering Whitaker’s influence, it wasn’t until I read the recollections of Bud Lamoreaux, creator and executive producer of the CBS Morning News with Charles Kuralt that I began to recall his great work, especially the 1973 Belmont.

“…What is lost in all of those feel good moments,” Lameroux wrote, “is the performance of the CBS broadcast team headed by Jack Whitaker. He was the silver-tongued orator from Philadelphia who could turn a phrase as quickly as Secretariat could get to the wire.

“Jack Whitaker [and Broun, Wright and Anderson], were old school CBS… They were just better than all the rest. They could look in the CBS eye and viewers knew they were getting the real deal – no hyperbole… just some straight talk.  And oh what sweet talk it was.

”At the end, with the hyperbole flying all around Secretariat’s 31-length victory, Jack had the perfect understatement. ‘I believe Dick Butkus could have ridden this horse today and won’.” Then, switching gears, he said of the hard-bitten racetrackers who rarely show emotion, “‘Today, I actually saw people crying’.”

But Whitaker had role models, too; Eric Severeid, Red Smith and Broun among them.

When Broun passed, Whitaker wrote: “He gave the genre a rich and rare dimension, which unhappily departs with him. He had the authentic fan’s enthusiasm for the games and the players, but he also had an unerring talent for spotting the sham and the hype. 

“I will miss his colorful anecdotes…his droll humor and marvelous writing. Heywood Hale Broun was a comfortable man of substance and his departure leaves us all diminished.”

As my journey lengthened, I met Jimmy Breslin. Andy Beyer introduced me to Richard Valeriani, a peerless reporter appearing nightly on NBC via remote from Vietnam, or outside the Capitol building during Watergate.

Standing on his feet in a war zone, somehow he made sense of what the U.S. was doing in Southeast Asia, how we were trying to keep dominoes from falling. That never worked, of course, no more than a country could stop a lawbreaker from leaving the White House.

Valeriani, like the others above, were half-brothers to Joe Palmer, George Ryall, a.k.a. Audax Minor, and Joe Hirsch and Charles Hatton and Barney Nagler, when journalism mattered at the Morning Telegraph. All were all mentors in word, if not in deed.

Valeriani visited the Saratoga press box every year because, above all, he loved two things: sojourning to Saratoga and cashing a bet.

Sometimes we gave him good counsel, more times not. But every year he returned in good cheer with a beaming smile: “Hey Pricci, whadda’ ya’ got today?”

When I read of Whitaker’s passing, the first thing I thought of was Secretariat’s Belmont, as Lamoreaux had, using that event to sum up his feelings, respect, and appreciation for a late, beloved colleague:

Then, another unforgettable racing moment, albeit tragic, when it was learned that the champion filly Ruffian had to be euthanized after a match race with Foolish Pleasure at Belmont Park, Whitaker looked into the camera and shared his grief.

Lamoreaux recalled Whitaker’s words: “One false step and years of planning and breeding and training and loving come to an end – a horse with speed and stamina and heart – a horse, like the Bible says, whose neck is clothed in thunder.”

Nack introduced me to Frank Deford, and he, too, had that quality. “I never wanted to be an editor,” he once said. “…I just wanted to write, and it didn’t make any difference whether it was fiction or nonfiction, or short stories, or whatever.”

But, lest any of us take ourselves too seriously: “In Hollywood, writers are considered only the first draft of human beings.” And now who is left to teach us?

©, All Rights Reserved, 2019

Facebook Share
Twitter Share
LinkedIn Share

⚠ Before you comment

Our staff likes nothing better than to engage with the HRI Faithful and provide a forum for interaction on horseracing and sports. In that spirit, please be kind and reasonable; keep the language clean, and the tone civil. Comments from those who cannot comply will be deleted. Thank you.

7 Responses

  1. Great piece. Class act, Jack Whitaker. Loved your remark about racetrackers moved to tears (or near tears) after Big Red’s gallop in Belmont. Same thing happened to me after Zenyatta’s last race. I think, like with Ruffian, we understand how magnificent these super horses are and also how they want to win. I wrote, like I’m sure many did, to Frank Whitley after Ruffian passed. He wrote back with a nice note. Again, thanks for an excellent column. Also read NYT’s obit yesterday. Yours is just as good.

  2. Thanks Mal, have learned some lessons but, like handicapping, one never stops learning…

    I didn’t wrote those words about Secretariat’s Belmont, that was a quote from Mr. Whitaker.

    The only time I can remember tears was up on the roof of Belmont Park the evening of the match race.

    Can’t recall if there was supposed to be some post-race celebration, or if everyone just needed to get some air, commiserate, or just give those still on deadline some quiet to write.

    There is much to lament these days and I guess the loss of an era when style and grace was aspirational simply had to be noted.

    A great contemporary wordsmith, colleague and friend, Paul Moran, said to me one night over cocktails after a big race that great races come and go but the words written about them live on. I thought he was taking us all a little too seriously.

    But thinking about it now, in the context of all my mentors above, intended or not, their words live on in me until I kick. I’ll try to keep honoring the past the best way I know how…

  3. I guess in tennis a good comparison would be Bud Collins (Boston Globe). Some of the anecdotal stuff was over my head, going back to past centuries, etc., but still kinda cool to hear this sort of history. Liked the kooky pants, too. Saw him once at old Forest Hills in patch madras, hard to miss. Correction: HOF trainer’s last name is Whitely. Nice touch to respond to railbirds who wanted to express condolences over Ruffian. Promotional gimmick proved disastrous. Who would have won? Maybe FB but Ruffian was a fighter. Really cool that she is buried at Belmont inside of a giant horseshoe designed planting. Again, nicely written words about a legendary sports guy.

  4. Mal, you were right first time, it’s Whiteley… And yes, Bud Collins was cool, but we never did speak that much tennis in Corona, Queens, even if that’s the true address of the Arthur Ashe stadium, not Flushing.

    It’s like Belinda Stronach trying to make Miami out of Hallandale Beach for advertising purposes…

    Jim, good to hear from a fellow Lion! Thanks for checking in…

  5. Thanks for the clarification on Ashe location. Once told someone that naming the entire venue after Billie Jean King was too great an honor and she read me the riot act (Title 9, women’s rights, etc.). Hey, I saw Billie Jean Moffatt at old Forest Hills when she was playing. She was swearing and carrying on like McEnroe. But, I kinda like that behavior. And Johnny Mac was from Douglaston, not what you would call a tennis mecca, either. Used to pick up the 7 train at Hunter’s Point for the two stops to Grand Central. Enjoy the Travers!

    1. Billie Jean was a good suggestion for sure, but Arthur Ashe was a bigger than life transformational figure who transcended his sport and, given the choice, I would have given my “vote” to Ashe. Both are deserving…

      Travers 150 lacks a little glam but its a field deep with talent; maybe one will step up to become a second season three year old that can run the table. Looking forward…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *